Bryan Reynolds on trade request
BRADENTON, Fla. — While confirming reported contract figures that put him and the Pirates roughly $50 million apart in extension talks, Bryan Reynolds explained why he made his trade request and where things stand with his employer on Wednesday morning at Pirate City.
Speaking before the first on-field workout for pitchers and catchers, Reynolds — who arrived a week early — described it as “frustrating” that his camp and the Pirates were so far apart on how they viewed his value.
Enough, of course, to curtail contract talks and prompt Reynolds to request a trade back in December.
“That’s the business side of it,” Reynolds said, emphasizing how much he loves the city, fans, PNC Park, his teammates and Pirates staffers. “It kind of sucked that it came to that since that’s how I feel.”
The Pirates have maintained that they don’t plan on trading Reynolds, at least not right away, reiterating in various forms how they expect him to be an integral part of this year’s team and beyond.
Manager Derek Shelton said he doesn’t think the situation will be a distraction. That the expectation for Reynolds, an All-Star in 2021, remains the same as ever.
Read More
“Everything Bryan has said to me personally and publicly is he’s going to be the same guy and go about his business,” Shelton said. “That’s what we expect. Don’t think there’s going to be anything different.”
The Pirates have Reynolds under contract through 2025, meaning they don’t have to do anything if they don’t want to. As far the awkwardness here or feeling a sense of impermanence around the Pirates, Reynolds said hasn’t been an issue.
“I’m always going to be where my feet are at,” Reynolds said. “I’m here right now, so I’m locked in for 100% Pirates, whatever that takes. I’m just down here now to get my work in and start to have a good season.”
The trade request made by Reynolds became one of the two biggest offseason storylines for the Pirates, along with the return of Andrew McCutchen, and Reynolds did say it would be “cool” to play alongside McCutchen ... if it gets to that point.
“Full circle,” Reynolds said. “Coming from being in that trade and answering all the questions about trying to replace McCutchen ... and now he’s finally back so we don’t have to worry about answering those questions anymore. It’ll be cool, especially for how much he means to the city of Pittsburgh.”
According to sources, Reynolds’ ask has been around $130-$135 million over eight years. The Pirates’ last known offer was six years for roughly $80 million.
Those figures have appeared in several places, including in the Post-Gazette, and Reynolds essentially confirmed the details by saying, “Pretty much everything out there has been fairly accurate. Nothing’s changed.”
So, what could change?
Two additional years at the team rate would get the potential extension’s total value to $107 million, a rough midpoint. The Pirates could start with team options for the two additional seasons, though it’s doubtful he’d take nearly $30 million less and give up those final two guaranteed years.
“I would sign a fair deal,” Reynolds said. “But I don’t want either side of it to come out and be like, ‘Man, they kind of got us.’ I want it to be that both sides have some skin in it.”
Should the Pirates do nothing, again, they could ride this out and keep Reynolds at his current rate — $6.75 million this season, plus two more years of arbitration — through 2025.
The downside, of course, would be housing an awkward situation, daring a well-liked, respected and productive player to live in that world and also forfeiting trade value.
Years of team control — where players like Reynolds come cheaper than they would in free agency — can net additional trade return, which the Pirates could see as a reason to move Reynolds to maximize the prospects they can bring back.
“That’s their [choice],” Reynolds said. “We couldn’t force ’em to do anything. I was frustrated. I think we have a right to kind of have those emotions, too.”
Throughout the offseason, Reynolds said he stayed in contact with a few members of the organization. He messed with David Bednar on Instagram. He told Shelton about the bourbon room he was building. He worked with hitting coach Andy Haines in Nashville.
Reynolds likes the moves the Pirates made this offseason and chatted with teammates, clubhouse staffers and team personnel on Wednesday morning, same as ever.
Nobody would’ve known the difference except for the giant elephant in the room, the gulf that exists between the Pirates and their best player in contract talks.
“I don’t think it’ll be a distraction,” Reynolds said. “I’m down here a week early. Already started to get my work going. Just gonna focus on the same things I’ve always focused on: try to be the best player I can be and help us win.”
Jason Mackey: jmackey@post-gazette.com and Twitter @JMackeyPG.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.