With Oneil Cruz, you see what you want to see.

Those looking for the Pirates’ next big thing can point to all of the hard-hit balls he had upon making his MLB debut in 2021. He set a Statcast record with a 122.4 mph laser off the Clemente Wall, the hardest-hit baseball since 2015, when Statcast began tracking such things. Plus, Cruz finished with 17 homers, 54 RBIs and 11 stolen bases in 87 games. Over a full 162-game season, that would be a 31-homer, 100-RBI, 20-stolen base pace. Pretty good for a shortstop who is in the 98th percentile among all MLB players in sprint speed and the 97th percentile in arm strength.

Those skeptical of buying anything the Pirates are selling will point out Cruz’s 34.9% strikeout rate was the ninth-highest in MLB among players with at least 250 plate appearances. That’s even with some improvement down the stretch, as he struck out at just a 14% clip in his final 12 games of the season.

Plus, what’s that arm strength good for anyway if he’s throwing the ball all over the place? Cruz made 10 throwing errors alone in 2022, tied for the fifth-most in baseball. Every player who had more than him played at least 300 more defensive innings. Cruz also made seven fielding errors, giving him 17 errors total, tied for the fourth-most in baseball.

Advertise with us

The point here isn’t to decide who’s right because all of those things are true. Cruz knows that himself. During the Pirates’ final series of the season, Cruz was asked what he feels he needs to improve this offseason.

“Primarily my throws, just making sure I’m getting better with my throws,” he said through team interpreter Mike Gonzalez. “The routine plays, just become a master of it. Don’t let any routine plays get out of my grip. If anything, be able to dominate the routine plays and make sure my throws are always on point.”

As for that aforementioned 30-homer, 100-RBI pace?

“I feel l can do even more,” Cruz said. “Many more home runs than 30, many more RBI than what you considered and more than anything, just a way better batting average.”

The only reason any of this matters, the debate over what Cruz is or will become, is even the pessimists among the fanbase can likely admit Cruz’s ceiling is high. Even while hitting just .233 with all of those strikeouts, he still had those 17 home runs, 13 doubles, four triples and 11 stolen bases.

Advertise with us

There were just seven players in MLB this season who had 100 RBIs and 30 homers. Only one of them — Kyle Tucker of the Houston Astros — had 20 or more stolen bases, as well. Point being, if Cruz was on that pace in his rookie season, with all of these obvious areas of improvement, then making those improvements could result in a truly rare player.

Of course, that is mostly contingent on his offense because if the bat does pan out, the Pirates will find a spot in their lineup for Cruz, wherever that is. We know his defensive side of the story. Cruz, despite all of the mistakes, unflinchingly believes he is an MLB shortstop. It’s the only position he’s ever wanted to play, well before he grew to his current 6-foot-7 frame.

At some point, he will have to prove a level of consistency at the position that has eluded him to this point, but Cruz remains steadfast in his belief.

“I feel like I was already able to demonstrate that I can play shortstop at the big-league level,” Cruz said. “The mindset right now is just to continue getting better and continue to master my position. Like I’ve told many people in the past, that’s my position. That’s a position I always see myself playing. That’s a position that I love. ... I just believe, more than anything, I have what it takes to play big-league shortstop up here.”

He’ll just have to prove that part in the years to come. If he does, then you’re talking about a player with all of those offensive skills who plays a premium defensive position. That’s face-of-the-franchise type talk.

Advertise with us

From that, Cruz doesn’t shy away either, even if he knows he isn’t there yet.

“I would love to be the face of this franchise, but I understand I have a lot of work to do,” Cruz said. “I have to work hard and continue to work hard for that.”