BALTIMORE — About a week before the MLB trade deadline, Bryan Reynolds approached Pirates senior vice president of baseball development Bryan Stroh with a suggestion. Or maybe a demand.
“We were talking, and I said, ‘Hey, don’t trade me,’” Reynolds was telling me Sunday morning in Baltimore. “He said, ‘We’re not.’ I said, ‘OK, good.’ I didn’t figure they would.”
The idea of Reynolds’ future has intrigued me since the Pirates, as expected, did not trade Reynolds or David Bednar, their two biggest pieces. As we looked to launch this new feature, I thought it would the perfect time to chat with Reynolds about some bigger-picture stuff, and I wasn’t disappointed.
Bottom line, the Pirates would be wise to have a long talk with Reynolds after the season and for the two parties to figure out what it’ll take to hammer out a long-term contract.
For now, though, here’s more from our conversation.
1. One important thing I learned is that nearly taking Reynolds to arbitration over $650,000 is water under the bridge.
Read More
After the Pirates and Reynolds agreed on a two-year, $13.5 million deal, Reynolds met with owner Bob Nutting, general manager Ben Cherington and manager Derek Shelton to clear the air.
“Just kind of talked for a couple minutes. It was good,” Reynolds said. “Nothing major, just smoothing it over.”
Did that matter to Reynolds?
“Yeah, I appreciated them taking the time to talk to me.”
2. Reynolds also said he doesn’t take any of it personally.
“They’ve got their number that they’re supposed to stay close to from the commissioner’s office,” he said. “I think it was just business.”
My own view: The Pirates wanted to ensure the relationship with Reynolds remained positive because they still think they can sign him long-term. At minimum, I think they realized they were overly adherent to rules when a common sense approach was probably needed.
3. Between the two-year deal, signing Hayes to an eight-year, $70 million contract and minimal movement at the deadline, Reynolds believes the organization could be changing its tune. That the Pirates may actually be serious about retaining their best players.
“I think we’re moving in the right direction,” he said.
We can certainly hope, right?
4. Another thing we talked about is how Reynolds legitimately likes it here — the city, fans, ballpark, his teammates and the feel around the team right now. Reynolds said he’s also been impressed and encouraged by the amount of talent being accumulated in the minor leagues.
“We’re closer than people on the outside might think,” said Reynolds, offering one of several quotes that left no doubt about how he feels.
“I want to stay here,” Reynolds continued. “I haven’t hidden it, so hopefully that’s the plan.”
5. Plenty of people have mentioned San Diego as a similar market with a vastly different business philosophy.
The criticism is fair. Given TV dollars and how the organizations are funded, the Pirates should be spending more on the major league product. But you have to start somewhere, and you have to start by drawing a line in the sand with guys like Reynolds.
Now, that’s hard when you have players who are indifferent to your city or franchise. That isn’t the case here. I asked Reynolds how he balances getting a contract that matches his value with ... well, playing in Pittsburgh, where such things aren’t always possible.
“I don’t have a number in my head or anything like that,” Reynolds said. “But I’m sure that both sides could work it out. I think we’re gonna win here soon, and I want to be part of it.”
In non-Reynolds news ...
6. If Penn State fashions itself as Linebacker U — and it does — the Pitt football team really should come up with something for the defensive line.
By my count, tackle Calijah Kancey or end Habakkuk Baldonado could become Pitt’s fifth (or sixth) All-Americans up front since 2013, a group that includes Aaron Donald, Ejuan Price, Jaylen Twyman, Rashad Weaver and Patrick Jones II.
That’s nuts.
David Green and Deslin Alexandre are returning starters — and certainly not bit parts — on a veteran group that believes it’s among the best in the country, which again, is a storyline we seem to discuss every year.
“We have a lot of experienced guys who are ready to play,” Kancey said.
7. So much fuss over who will replace Jordan Addison — and I get it. Also not terribly concerned. When I look at the Panthers’ options, I see his production replaced in the aggregate, plus a potential breakout season for Jared Wayne.
Two transfers should soak up reps in Konata Mumpfield (Akron) and Bub Means (Louisiana Tech). Jaylon Garden and Jaden Bradley are solid secondary options, as well. Most intriguing to me, though, is Wayne, who had 46 catches for 654 yards (14.2 avg.) and five touchdowns.
Off the field, Wayne has embraced a leadership role. It’s also easy to like his physical talents between the lines.
“You can see he’s a high-character, high-motor guy,” offensive coordinator Frank Cignetti Jr. said. “He brings great leadership to the offense.”
8. Had an interesting chat with former Pitt quarterback Tyler Palko last week about NIL and the transfer portal, which Palko described as “bullshit” with the way it has unfolded to this point.
Palko isn’t against either one, but he wants the NCAA to do a better job with regulation.
“Look at how much money the NCAA and these institutions are making,” Palko said. “These kids should get a chance to benefit from it.”
I told Palko that it wasn’t shocking to hear that he’s against kids leaving programs, but he quickly corrected me. He’s fine with transfers if done for proper reasons, citing Joe Flacco leaving Pitt when Palko was named the starter.
As for NIL money ...
“They need to find a way to cap it,” Palko said. “If you look at these mega conferences, it’s gonna turn into an NFL thing. I think that’s only fair.”
9. Trying to exercise some form of caution over the Steelers quarterback competition since it’s only Aug. 8. That said, how unfulfilling — and downright scary — would it be if Mason Rudolph wound up being the starter?
There will be questions about why the Steelers signed Mitch Trubisky and what they should do with Kenny Pickett, but my biggest concern might be this: How could anyone take the Steelers’ playoff chances seriously in a division where Rudolph will be opposed by Joe Burrow and Lamar Jackson, inside a conference featuring Patrick Mahomes, Josh Allen, Justin Herbert and Russell Wilson?
10. What the Pirates are doing with Roansy Contreras — having him pitch in the minors — irritates me.
He’s dominating. If they want to monitor his innings, fine. But there’s no reason that can’t happen in MLB. Pitching in the minors still taxes his arm, likely won’t spur development, irritates fans and raises questions about service-time manipulation. Just stop.
Jason Mackey: JMackey@post-gazette.com and Twitter @JMackeyPG.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.