Jason Mackey: Hello, everyone. Welcome to my weekly Pirates chat. Thanks for stopping by. A lot to talk about. We'll get started at noon.
Bill: Jason, first of all congrats on your big career news. Very well deserved! With Heineman hurt, do you think the Bucs will try to claim Pedro Severino who the Brewers DFA? He's 29, under control another year and a better option than what they currently have. Only WSH/CHC ahead of us in waivers.
Jason Mackey: Hi, Bill. Thank you very much for that. Really excited about the new role. Yes, I could see them looking into that. Can't say for sure, but I think I'm saying the obvious by pointing out that having Taylor Davis as a regular option behind Jason Delay is not ideal. Can't say for sure they will get him, but any help would be good at this point.
Bill: Who are the next group of young players to come up? Swaggety and Suwinski are both hitting well at Indy and should get another shot.
Jason Mackey: Those are the two I'm looking at, Bill. Maybe not together, but I think whomever has more confidence or might be in a better place to succeed -- Suwinski would probably be the easy answer -- would be my choice.
madeintheshade: If a Pirate is DFA'ed or released, do they still get their full salary? Also, if a player is injured, do the Pirates pay their salary or does an insurance company?
Read More
Jason Mackey: It depends on the type of deal. Also matters where or not they're claimed on waivers. If a player is injured but, say, on the 10-day injured list, yes, the Pirates continue to pay their salary.
Cullen: Congrats on the new gig, Jason, and very well deserved! Peguero has been on a prolonged cold streak for the last month, he is young for AA but should we be concerned?
Jason Mackey: Thanks, Cullen. And no, I don't think we should be concerned. As you said, he's young. There are going to be growing pains. I think Peguero is going to be just fine in the long run. Very good player. Nothing over which to fret.
Wayward: Who and when are the DFA's and who gets called up?
Jason Mackey: Next one I'm looking at is JVM. They need to make space for some outfielders at Triple-A as I mentioned. I wouldn't be surprised if it happens soon, to be honest.
Cullen: Do you expect to see any more of the Pirates 2021 draft class promoted to Bradenton this year? Bishop seems to be hitting pretty well in rookie ball.
Jason Mackey: Yes, I would imagine they want to get those guys a taste of affiliated ball before long. Would not shock me at all if that happened here in the next couple of weeks.
Prince Bob: How surprised are you the Ben Gamel is still here? Were there no offers? Could the fact that none of the new kids in the outfield look like Cutch 2.0 yet have them thinking of trying to re-sign Gamel? He wouldn't cost all that much even by Pirate standards.
Jason Mackey: I am surprised, yes. I thought he would for sure be gone. I wonder if their ask was too high. I know they were talking with Toronto but ultimately didn't finish anything. And, no. I don't think it makes sense to keep Gamel. Nothing against him, but they have other guys they need to play.
Cullen: Due to the glut of middle infield talent in the system, could Termarr potentially get moved to CF? If his bat is as good as advertised he should fit pretty much anywhere but would play up at the premium position.
Jason Mackey: I don't think so. From what I know, he has limited experience out there. He loves playing the infield. He's also highly rated. Never say never, but I think they have guys they could move before him. Nick Gonzales actually came up as a CF. Wouldn't shock me if they tried him out there. I think you let Termarr show what he can do before moving him.
Mike: Hayes has to be a huge disappointment right
Jason Mackey: Not in my mind. I don't know why so many people view Ke'Bryan as a finished product. We knew his offense would have to grow when he signed his deal. He's an elite defensive player who will need to mature a little as a hitter. That doesn't make him a "huge disappointment."
Stuck-in-Philly: Good morning, Jason -
Jason Mackey: Good morning to you.
Prince Bob: I asked last week about the Pirates and Brian Reynolds getting a deal done. Mulling it some more, I doubt it will happen. He is going to cost money even with a home team discount, maybe eight figures a year, and probably for at least five years which means they'd be paying him for three years when he's past that magical age of 29 when his hitting statistically has peaked. I just don't see that as the kind of money they'd spend and think if they were going to do a deal with him they'd have it done by now. But I'd like your thoughts here.
Jason Mackey: I see where you're coming from, and you might not be wrong. However, not all cases are the same. They got something done with Hayes. I think they could do the same with Reynolds. Reynolds a couple years ago was an elite, elite rookie. Not ready to back off of something because he would be past his prime. Sign your best players would be my approach here.
Scott C.: Jason - assuming Cruz sticks at short, there could be a logjam at second with Newman, Marcano, Peguero, Gonzalez, Castillo and maybe even Johnson if he progresses quickly. How do you see this playing out?
Jason Mackey: There's so much to see and learn, Scott. It's hard to say. I will say this: Cruz offers more offensive upside than anyone on this list by a long shot. His defense hasn't been bad enough that I would want to move him. Tough to see him NOT in the mix. Marcano can bounce around. I don't think Newman's production will match his cost after the season. And TBD on the others. I think they're far from finished products. You could always trade one or entertain Cruz going to the outfield -- it may be what makes everything fit -- but again, there's just so much to take in at this point.
Prince Bob: And on a whole other note, what do guys who are back and forth between the minors and majors do about housing? Suwinski, for example, had to get a place in Altoona then another in Pittsburgh when he's called up. But he couldn't really let go of the place in Altoona knowing his time in Pittsburgh could be short and he'd be back. I assume that meant a hotel in Pittsburgh, at least at first? But if he got a more permanent place he's got two rents to pay and now he must be paying a third in Indianapolis? That's a lot of rent to pay for a guy making MLB minimum or less.
Jason Mackey: Suwinski stayed in a hotel in Pittsburgh, like many. In the other two spots, the team supplies housing that players can move in and out of fairly easily. He may be living in a couple different places, but he's only playing rent once -- wherever his feet are.
Dave: Do you think it would be a good move to keep Gamel around for another year or two. I don’t think he will be very expensive, seems like a good professional & clubhouse guy. Could be a mentor/Dh/4th outfielder?
Jason Mackey: Given what Gamel has done, I think he will have options as he hits the free agent market. I think he will entertain those, to perhaps play on a winning club. Same time, the Pirates need to find out about the young outfielders in their system. Just makes sense for them to move on, in my opinion.
Stuck-in-Philly: Good afternoon, Jason. Baseball used to be my favorite sport. Long after I graduated college in '98 I would have been able to tell you major league roster for almost every team and the stats for most of each team's players. Now, not so much after the past 20+ years of Pirates baseball. I am still tangentially interested in baseball (I watched "Thor" make his debut for the Phillies last night and I am not a Phillies fan). Here is my question: Have you seen any indication from Cherington and ownership that things will change? I think them not moving to move Bednar and Reynolds at the deadline was a massive failure and only confirms my opinion that they are not interested in truly tearing things down to move in the right direction. If ownership and management think that keeping those players on the roster for an extra 100 people in the stands each night and another 500 TV viewers, they are losing the forest through the trees and losing generations of Pirates fans. What are you thoughts?
Jason Mackey: Couple things: If they would have traded Reynolds and Bednar, there would have been a large group of fans that said they weren't interested in winning, etc. They were in a no-win situation. I would also say that the Pirates are the furthest into a rebuild we've seen them in a long time, maybe ever. It's taking time, no doubt. You would also like to see more progress. But I don't think all hope is lost here. They have talent in the minor leagues, and they need to develop those players appropriately. They also need to keep the good players they do have, and I have no problem with them doing that.
Jps717: I like the plan that BC has put together to grow the club into a winner. That said, How can you get to Aug and not have 5 starting pitchers on the team? What’s their plan for starters for the balance of season? Why are so worried about pitching Contreras?
Jason Mackey: They're thin on pitching, no doubt. It's also not like it grows on trees, especially when you refuse to spend money. But I get it. They need to find more, and they're going to be shoe-horning stuff the rest of the way. Probably hoping younger guys like Bryse Wilson or even Cody Bolton take a step. They're being cautious with Roansy because he's one of the only elite arms they have at that age/level. They're also not built to win right now, so as much as I want to see him, I get not wanting to waste the innings.
C. Montgomery Burns: Bligh Madris hasn't been hitting at all recently. Do they explore sending him down and bringing Suwinski or Swaggerty back up?
Jason Mackey: He hasn't, you're right. And, yeah, I think Bligh -- if he's not hitting -- would be one of the roster casualties if/when they decide to promote the guys you mentioned.
Guest: when is Jack back? and who goes when he does come back?
Jason Mackey: I think relatively soon. Maybe on this (long) road trip. At this point, I would think maybe VanMeter. It's not a position-for-position swap, but I could see them keeping Madris to see what he can do at first.
Dave: I don’t mean this as a negative Pirate comment. You can’t realistically expect 25 young kids to all figure it out at once. That being said will the Pirates supplement the roster with a veteran (a good one) if said prospect doesn’t turn out. Basically like the Blue Jays but with a more modest payroll?
Jason Mackey: I think when the core of what they have grows up a little bit and is bigger. Basically the young guys need to take some lumps and grow. When they're able to compete a little more, the team is better, then I think you will see them patch holes. I also think they could be more aggressive doing that this offseason.
johnkovalcin1: Why has the best catcher been sitting on the bench?? Jason Delay? Now he is playing because Heineman is injured AVG 204
Jason Mackey: He'll be playing a lot more now. Assuming they don't go out and try to claim someone.
Doug Frobel Fan Club: I don't know if this makes any sense and if it doesn't, please say so. It seems the Pirates have a group of young players like Castillo, Marcano, Suwinski, Mitchell, Madris, Castro, and Park. So far none has really taken a hold of a job. It goes beyond just "play the kids". They just don't seem to be content to run someone there every day and "say the job is yours for six weeks, sink or swim.". It's hard for me to see how they figure any of these guys out with how Shelton constructs his lineup. For example, Marcano should be the every day 2B for the rest of the year except for the occasional day off. But I doubt we're going to see that.
Jason Mackey: It makes some sense. I understanding wanting to give guys opportunities. But Marcano's value may be as a utility type. I'm OK with him bouncing around, but you're right on this part: If he continues to hit, he should absolutely be in the lineup somewhere. And will be.
Doug Frobel Fan Club: I didn't see the tweet you made in frustration. But for my money, you're one of the best reporters in the game. Your passion, work ethic, and knowledge of the game comes through in your writing. Haters are going to hate as they say. Keep up the outstanding work
Jason Mackey: Thanks, Doug. I just got a little too affected by comments. Started arguing with people who didn't see things my way. It's a dumb way to live, and I'm sorry I let it get to me.
Justin R.: What's the upside for Marcano? He seems to have a well-developed approach at the plate and positional versatility.
Jason Mackey: You're hitting on parts of it. Has a sneaky amount of power. Obviously runs well. Solid bunter. Should be able to get on-base. A top-of-the-order presence, table-setter, that type. I like his game.
Erik: Jason how would you rate the state of our farm system? It seems as tho a lot of our top prospects don’t have the best numbers. Is that a concern
Jason Mackey: It's still top 10 in MLB. Have trouble saying it's top-five right now because of some steps backward taken, but I still think there's plenty of talent there. But, no, no huge over-arching concern about any of that. I think the big dogs -- Davis, Gonzales, etc. -- will be fine.
Guest: Oops! Hi, Jason, Do you think the Pirates will try to keep Tsutsugo in the organization, or outright release him if no one picks him?
Jason Mackey: I would be surprised if they kept him in the organization. They need to let Mason Martin work, even though it won't be up here. Could also see them wanting to keep a spot open for Malcom Nunez or give Bligh work at first base if they send him down. Just doesn't make sense to me to allocate those reps to Yoshi.
mrsafeway: Does Nick Gonzalez take over at third, or is there a chance O'Neil Cruz winds up there? Cruz has the size and there's no question about his arm strength. Just the lack of experience. If you have the reflexes to play short, you can play third.
Jason Mackey: Um, Ke'Bryan is gonna play there. If either moves, it'll be to the outfield. They're not going to third.
Guest: When it comes to the trade deadline, I’m afraid the Pirates have developed a reputation of “sell at any cost” which has resulted in getting low ball offers. I’m not smart enough to really evaluate the return they get but it seems other teams selling are able to get better returns. You’ve written about the value Quintana brought to the team. For what they got back, it seems it might just have been worth it to keep him around. And, who knows, they might have been able to strike a deal to keep him longer. They certainly are short on decent starters. So, my questions are: what do you think about my premise about their reputation and do you think the return for Quintana justified shipping him out?
Jason Mackey: I do. I have no issue at all with what they got back from Quintana. I think the world of Jose as a person, but I like the upside of Oviedo and Nunez. No issue at all trading him when it's doubtful he would sign anything long-term here.
ev: Jason, I can't process the Pirates silence at the trade deadline. Were their vets not coveted? Did Cherington want too much? Are they going to build (future) with Newman and Gamel? Why pay that veteran salary? I could go on,,..
Jason Mackey: I don't think they had a ton of super attractive offers, which I can sorta see. I think they did value having those guys around a little bit as older players/mentors. Don't think they re-sign either in the offseason, but I also don't think they had a ton of options at the deadline.
Guest: Any word on Suwinski timeline to return? Seems unfair to ding him for high K rate with overall high K rate for team. Looks like he's back groove at plate.
Jason Mackey: No word but expecting it to happen relatively soon.
Lad9: Hi Jason. Congratulations on your new role! You will do great I am sure. Your Vin Scully piece was amazing! One question for you, and it probably isn't a great chat question, but I will ask it anyhow. Do you have any idea of who the significant prospects are that need added to the 40 man in the off season to protect them from the rule 5 draft? I know that Nunez does, I think Burrows, and if they consider Bolton a prospect he does, but after that not sure. I mean, there should be space once the roster pruning is complete I would think. Thank you.
Jason Mackey: Admittedly haven't looked at that much -- and thank you. Part because of the deadline, part with everything else going on for me professionally. I know Nunez. Bolton, too, because he was a Rule 5 guy last year. Not sure of anyone beyond that.
ev: Jason, why is Van Meter still playing?
Jason Mackey: I'm afraid I don't have a good answer for it. Don't understand it either.
Bill: This kind of piggybacks my question ewarlier about Severino. I like GMBC and I believe in his plan and love what he's done with the system. That being said, the catcher spot at the MLB level has been awful (outside of Stallings) going back to the first year BC was here. Next year I would be fine with R. Perez coming back but they have to have a more reliable backup plan in place. Would you agree?
Jason Mackey: Yes, I would. Organizationally they are still too thin at catcher. Again, why I would take a chance on one of those guys mentioned. I'm fine seeing more of Delay. I would want more of a comfort blanket beyond that.
Chief Powhatan: Do you think Mason Martin gets a call up soon? Also, how long do the Bucs go with Allen over recalling Suwinski?
Jason Mackey: No, I don't think Martin gets called up soon. There's a lot on which he needs to improve. And, yeah, I think Allen is probably candidate No. 2 for a DFA behind VanMeter. Maybe ahead of him, depending on how you want to construct your OF.
Will: What's the latest with Contreras? FO called is a pause but now there's talk of shutting him down til Sept or maybe the year. Are there injury concerns? Seemed like an obvious candidate to slot into Quintana's vacated rotation slot.
Jason Mackey: I don't know what you're talking about shutting him down until September. He's pitching in Indy -- albeit in limited fashion. They're being super careful with his innings, not wanting him to jump too much year-over-year. I think they're just gonna slow play it and probably bring him back at the end of the month.
Austin: One down. Two to go. With Yoshi DFA’d and a nice series sweep of the Brewers, how much longer do you think we wait before someone comes up for JVM and Allen?
Jason Mackey: Probably this road trip.
Chief Powhatan: With only four left in a rotation that's far from world-beaters, who do the Pirates give the most opportunities to the rest of 2022?
Jason Mackey: They don't have many who are MLB-ready, to be honest. I know this will irk some people, but it wouldn't surprise me if they gave Eickhoff another shot. Bolton would be another tweener type I think they'll want to check out. Could see Oviedo up here, obviously. There'll probably be another waiver claim or two. Again, it's not great.
Craig: Do you expect there to be any interest in Dinelson Limet from the Pirates?
Jason Mackey: He has a 9.49 ERA this season. I mean, maybe. They're thin on pitching. But this strikes me as a bit of a reach.
Liam: Nick Gonzales is said to be close to returning to game like action. Does that mean he’s going to be in the lineup in Altoona soon or is that just like live reps?
Jason Mackey: A little unclear based on what TT said the other day. I think it would probably start in a controlled environment, like rookie league, then progress. I doubt they would plop him down in Altoona right away.
Jeff H.: I remember when Syd Thrift did his firesale in the 1980's, and after the final trade, he said he had his team, take a picture. I believe that was in 1986. Do we have our team we're going to move forward with? Can we take a picture? I know it was a different era, but I'm just hoping this is not a continual "trade for prospects" situation.
Jason Mackey: Umm ... I think the Pirates are always going to have shuffling in and out. Not sure I would ever take a picture of a team and expect it to stay. Not the way the game works anymore.
Chief Powhatan: I'm dreading this 10-game roadtrip but can you see a scenario where the Pirates could go 5-5?
Jason Mackey: It would take a lot, but yeah, I could see it. 7-3 no. But 5-5 is a reasonable expectation given the teams they're playing. Not like it's the Padres, Cardinals and Dodgers.
The Dude: I know we have to hear that Pirates are so bad that no manager could win with them, but don’t we still have to consider day to day decisions and whether individual players are showing any improvement? Is there a player on the team that has actually improved after working with Oscar or Andy?
Jason Mackey: Mitch Keller has. They've had young guys contribute. Jack Suwinski should be here and certainly showed promise. I get Reynolds' start, Hayes, etc. But there have been some. I'm more concerned on the pitching side because from my understanding, it was more Dewey Robinson than Oscar helping Keller.
Chief Powhatan: Is it really in the works for MLB to have every team play every other team in 2023?
Jason Mackey: I believe so, yes. And I'm kind of excited about it, not gonna lie.
Chief Powhatan: What's the status of former #1 overall pick Henry Davis? Is he shut down for the season?
Jason Mackey: No, he's taking swings in a cage. Has progressed from soft toss. Saw something he put on his Instagram story from the cages at Pirate City.
I C Light: If the Pirates have a deep farm system as has been printed, why are there no first basemen or catchers available to bring up? And is there no one better than Vanmeter or Allen?
Jason Mackey: Well, there are better options than VanMeter and Allen. We've been over that. They also have a top-50 prospect at catcher in Davis. Yes, I know he's been hurt. But it's not like that causes people to instantly cut bait.
Will: What are your thoughts on the hitting inconsistency and vulnerability to offspeed/out of zone pitches. Is this just of byproduct of young hitters learning MLB pitchers? Many young Pirate hitters look locked for fastballs and opposing pitchers are wisely getting them to chase offspeed / spin. Lots of really frustrating ABs and not surprising Pirates dead last in NL in Zone Swing % rate (but then again Yankees surprising bad there too)
Jason Mackey: I think the broadest assertion I can make or conclusion I can draw is that, yes, they have young hitters who are good enough or mature enough in their approach. That's sort of the point of baseball, right? Getting your opponent to do something they wouldn't normally do. Would be like yelling at the pitcher to throw strikes. If everyone could just automatically do it, I'm sure they would. That goes for chasing as well.
Bill: I really like the returns in the Quintana deal. Nunez is a type of player we dont have a lot of. Do you think he's a lock to be added to the 40 man this winter?
Jason Mackey: Yes, I do. I'm not ruling out him being the opening day 1B in 2023 given their lack of depth at the position.
john: what's your new gig?
Jason Mackey: It's a columnist/enterprise hybrid called "senior sports writer." I write 10 Thoughts every Monday, likely a newsletter, podcast, video and chats as well. Also doing takeout pieces across all beats and traveling for stuff. Basically bouncing around and reporting a little differently than anyone else at our paper across all sports.
Kenny Pickett: Do I need a restraining order from Fillipponi? Can the guy just let me play?
Jason Mackey: Poni likes Pickett? I didn't know.
Sable: Do you think Chavis stays in Pittsburgh. By the way, I love your chats.
Jason Mackey: Thank you! Yeah, for now I think he does. Makes sense for both sides. I don't know about beyond, say, next year, but he's only arbitration-eligible for the first time this offseason, and I think it makes sense for the Pirates to go through with that.
Moving on: How happy will you be not having to cover this roaring dumpster fire everyday ? Mazel !!
Jason Mackey: I'll still be around the team. And I wouldn't describe it as that. I loved my time on baseball exclusively covering the Pirates. I'm also ready for a new challenge.
Lucky: Was the sweep just a case of the Brewers not playing well or is this a sign of encouragement ? I really don't see any talent in the Pirate organization. I am inclined or more likely too cynical to think it was anything more then the Brewers just not playing well
Jason Mackey: Probably a little bit of both. The Pirates played well, but the Brewers are also a mess. Goes to show what even a little bit of offense will do for you.
Justin: Just wanted to give a quick congrats on the new role and a thanks for being the best beat guy for the bucs over the last few yrs. I appreciated that there were times when you said "I dont know, but I'll send a few texts" in response to a chat question and then a few hours later you'd tweet an answer. Much appreciated!
Jason Mackey: You got it. Thanks so much for reading and participating in these!
Brian: I know they did away with traditional August waiver trades, but can you still deal a guy who is in DFA limbo?
Jason Mackey: Yes, for cash. Typical DFA stuff still applies.
Justin: Would you claim Dinelson Lamet if you were in charge? Very successful at times in the past, due < 2 mil remaining this yr, under control thru next yr via arb. Plus it'd just be sticking it to MIL maybe.
Jason Mackey: I don't know. I would have some reservations. I would want to know from my scouts that they really saw something they could fix. I wouldn't do it blindly.
Troll: Is the t-shirt trolling of Bob Nutting the best video ever ? This kid deserves a statue
Jason Mackey: That was pretty funny. I know people won't believe this, but Bob has a pretty good sense of humor. He knows people are upset. He knows the Pirates have made mistakes. He's not a bad guy, but yeah, I wish they would either spend more or, if he can't, sell to someone who will. Because there are filthy-stinking rich people out there who will treat the Pirates like a toy. Not quite Bob's approach.
New Guy: Cherrington basically admitted the total lack of power in the organization after he traded for Nunez. Why has this organization under him have de valued power for athletic OFs and middle infielders? No problem with spending draft capital on pitching because you never enough but to be here for three years and besides Davis he's done nothing to address it before Nunez.
Jason Mackey: You're making some broad assertions based on one guy. The year prior they drafted Henry Davis. They have Oneil Cruz. It's not like Ben has actively said, "No, I hate homers. Gimme guys who don't hit them." There's a reason those guys get paid a boatload of money.
Cullen: If Cruz puts up solid numbers the rest of the way, what are the chances we see the pirates offer a long term extension, hopefully on a team friendly deal? looking at Atlanta they seem to have a ton of success doing this.
Jason Mackey: Probably very good. It's a situation that would make sense for both parties. I absolutely expect there to be dialogue this offseason with something like that.
I miss Willie: Headed o Altoona tonight -- who should I watch as the next big prospect?
Jason Mackey: I don't know who's pitching tonight. They're also dealing with injuries. But watch Triolo, Fraizer, Sabol and Peguero. That'll keep ya busy.
C. Montgomery Burns: If Burrows has a good six weeks at Indianapolis, and pitches similar to how he did in Altoona, would the Pirates give him a one-start cameo at the end of the year?
Jason Mackey: Yeah, I'm expecting that. He has to put together a nice run in Indy first, though.
Justin: When a player is traded, do they receive paychecks from the new team, or from the team that their contract was with (with the new team being invoiced by the old team for the money)? Like, will Quintanas paychecks for the remainder of the year have cardinals or pirates logos?
Jason Mackey: I've never seen a player paycheck, but the Cardinals are paying his salary, so it would be weird if it had a Pirates logo on it.
Jack: Hi Jason, do you expect Roberto Perez to return to the Bucs next year? He could potentially hold down the catcher position until a prospect (like Henry Davis, Endy Rodriguez) come up in late 2023 or 2024. R. Perez was solid offensively and defensively before the injury. What are your thoughts?
Jason Mackey: Assuming they're good with his medicals and such, yeah, I think that makes a lot of sense. Would not shock me at all if he was back.
Justin: Is Oviedo gonna start out in indy as a RP or SP?
Jason Mackey: It's a blurry line there with the Pirates, but I'll say this: He's gonna come up here as a starting pitcher. How they get him going and build, not sure. But the end goal is to start.
Mateo: Endy Rodriguez has to get a serious bump in the next prospect rankings. If somebody wanted to tell me he’s the best prospect in the pirates system I wouldn’t argue with them. Just curious on your thoughts on him as a player?
Jason Mackey: He's already top-10. I also don't see the rankings as gospel. Guys will get dinged because they've been hurt -- Davis, Gonzales, etc. Look, Endy is one of their best prospects. Not sure I feel differently about him if he's seventh or third. Still a very good player.
New Guy: I understand not getting value for Gamel but what is his true value to the Pirates? Won't be here much longer and taking ABs from the kids. I say getting the kids more ABs is worth even more than middling prospect. They should have dumped him. Your thoughts?
Jason Mackey: Depends on the return, if there was a return. I think he does have value playing a steady left field (helps pitchers makes games more watchable), and you also can't have 26 kids. You need to have some veteran players in that clubhouse, guys younger players can learn from. Gamel plays that role very well.
Canyon: Hi Jason. There seems to be a group of fans that thinks Cruz has a attitude problem. I have no idea where they got this idea from and they also think that his teammates don’t like him either. Why do you think people think this stuff?
Jason Mackey: I think it completely insane. I don't know where anyone started that or heard that, but it couldn't possibly be more wrong. Oneil is a great kid. He's shy and doesn't love the attention, but he's a great kid.
BVA123: Thoughts on Marisnick, I think he could stick on this team as a 4th-5th outfielder. He's ridiculous on defense.
Jason Mackey: I would DFA him. Great defensively, yes. They have other things they need to accomplish in the outfield, and he's not part of the future here.
tgmartin@logility.com: Jason, Gotta say how exciting it has been to watch and follow Oneil Cruz. The kid has skills!
Jason Mackey: Been fun, no doubt.
Not impressed: I see the numbers of the supposed talent in the Minors and I'm not really blow away by any of them. Is this "talent" just all hype because it seems like it is ? Will these guys be anything in the Majors because if they can't excel in the minors how are they gonna do when they paly with the big boys ?
Jason Mackey: You can feel however you want, but nobody on this Earth can predict what these kids will be when they get to the majors. That's what makes it fun. They do have talent right now -- and it's not just people saying that for the heck of it. Scouts spend their lives analyzing this stuff.
Wayward: Of the AAA and AA prospects who have taken steps back this year, who concerns you the most and who concerns you the least? For me the step back Yajure has taken is the most concerning.
Jason Mackey: I would put Yajure up there, yes. And he's been better of late, but I would also add Matt Fraizer into the category. Last year was their minor league player of the year. Obviously hasn't been that this season.
Matt: Why has Ji-hwan Bae not been given a chance yet? Castillo struggled hitting for average almost all season and stayed on the roster. I know he's on the IL right now, but did his offseason problems impact what the front office thinks of him?
Jason Mackey: I think they wanted to allocate playing time to others and give Bae a chance to start and receive consistent playing time. My other suspicion is that he does come with baggage. The Pirates know they'll take it on the chin when he comes up, and they want to make sure it's worth it when he does come up. That's just a suspicion though.
tgmartin@logility.com: With the state of our starting rotation, I would think signing more starting pitching is top priority this offseason. Any idea on what pitchers will be free agents? Would love it if they could resign Jose Quintana. He was always a tough pitcher to face while with the Cubbies and WhiteSox. Wow, he showed a lot of leadership capability while a Bucco too. Yea, I am a fan of Jose Quintana...Beat'em Bucs Terry Martin in Woodstock, GA
Jason Mackey: I haven't gotten that far, Terry. And even if I did, they're not going to sign guys atop the free agent heap. Never do. Probably never will.
ev: Jason, what is your new position that everyone is extending congratulations? Congrats, by the way,,...
Jason Mackey: Thank you! Copy/pasting from earlier: "It's a columnist/enterprise hybrid called "senior sports writer." I write 10 Thoughts every Monday, likely a newsletter, podcast, video and chats as well. Also doing takeout pieces across all beats and traveling for stuff. Basically bouncing around and reporting a little differently than anyone else at our paper across all sports."
Chief Powhatan: Can we hang on to 3rd place?
Jason Mackey: Uh, no.
Art from ct: Although he hasn’t earned it, why not bring mason Martin up forcatastecof big leagyes
Jason Mackey: Because he hasn't earned it and has struggled in the minor leagues. I don't see who that's serving.
Brian: Do you know what the plans are for Oviedo? Do want to see him as a starter or do they like what he's done as a reliever enough to leave him there? Seems like the Pirates acquire a bunch of these swing types (DeJong, Yajure, Crowe, etc) and don't like committing to one role for then to develop into. Crowe sticking in the pen seems to have helped his development a ton.
Jason Mackey: They want Oviedo to start and will be building him up as such. But they also want to work on some mechanical and pitch-usage things with him in the minors before bringing him back up.
Chief Powhatan: Could the Pirates pull an LA Angels' draft strategy and draft all pitchers in 2023?
Jason Mackey: They almost did it this year! But, no. I don't see them going that route, at least not completely.
Art from ct: why not bring mason Martin up for a taste of the big leagues? Yes he has struggled at AAA but we need a first baseman and he is a good fielder. He can’t be any worse at plate than van meter and this version of Madris. Plus we need to know whether to protect him in rule 5 draft
Jason Mackey: They left him unprotected last year and didn't lose him. Hard to imagine his struggles this season would cause him to get claimed. Guys should earn their way up here. I have no problem with adhering to that strategy, although it should also be a two-wat street.
Jason Mackey: OK, folks. Thanks so much for this. Have some other stuff to do before the game tonight. Always enjoy these. Talk to yinz next week!






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.