The Pirates entered this season planning to deploy their pitchers differently.
Dewey Robinson knew exactly how to do it.
The idea of using pitchers in untraditional ways was already put into practice by the Tampa Bay Rays, among other teams, over the last several seasons. They’ve used openers, hybrid relievers, deployed their best relievers before the ninth inning, you name it.
If that sounds familiar, it’s because the Pirates are doing the same thing this season. Robinson, who served as the Rays’ director of pitching development, is now a special adviser for the Pirates.
“We knew coming into this year that we were going to deploy pitching differently,” manager Derek Shelton said. “Honestly one of the interesting or intriguing things about hiring Dewey was he had a little bit of the blueprint of how it’d been done.”
Robinson spent the first two months bouncing between the major league club and Class AAA Indianapolis and has since started working with the lower levels, making his first trip to Class AA Altoona last week.
Read More
When Robinson describes why it’s prudent for a smaller-market team like the Pirates to use this newfangled pitching strategy, it’s like a mechanic explaining the make-up of a car. There’s a reason for everything and an answer for any issue, at least in theory.
“Most people don’t really understand it, and even here, it was foreign to them,” Robinson told the Post-Gazette. “The Rays came up with this concept, and it made a lot of sense. They developed it, and if you watch what they’re doing to this day, they’re still doing all of it. They won 100 games doing it last year. Looking through our major league pitching staff, I thought this is the perfect storm. This is the perfect year to start all this stuff.”
That answer launched Robinson into a description of the larger quirks in the Pirates’ pitcher usage.
The Pirates have used an opener at times for multiple reasons, he explained. Managers, in most cases, attempt to set their lineup to match up well with the other team’s starter that day. Tossing an opener into the mix messes with those matchups.
It can also help switch things up for a struggling starter. When right-hander Bryse Wilson limped out of the gate this season, the Pirates put an opener in front of him, bringing Wilson out of the bullpen instead. Same for Mitch Keller. In the long run, it didn’t work for Wilson, who is now trying to get right in Indianapolis, and the jury is still out on Keller, but the idea is to switch things up mentally and hope it helps something click physically.
That leads Robinson to the hybrid reliever. Namely, left-hander Dillon Peters and right-hander Wil Crowe have pitched one, two or three innings in a given appearance. They could come in after the starter lasts five or six innings, or they could help bridge a three-inning start to the back end of the bullpen.
Both these roles stem from the same thought, that starters, in general, fare poorly when facing a lineup for the third time in a game. So whether you put a pitcher ahead or behind the bulk-inning “starter,” you can cover more innings and avoid disadvantageous matchups.
“It’s based on the concept, and you can do all the research you want but I’ll give you the short answer, the third time through the order, it swings to the hitter,” Robinson said. “It’s just based on the familiarity. They’ve seen 20-25 pitches from you. They know what you’re throwing. And actually, very few starters, there’s a dozen in the big leagues who can get through the order a third time. Your worst reliever is better than your starter coming through the third time.”
The idea of using your best reliever before the ninth inning isn’t as new-school. Teams have been doing it in the playoffs for years now. The Pirates have followed suit in the regular season, bringing right-hander David Bednar into whichever inning feels most important at the time. That could mean facing the heart of the lineup in the seventh, a six-out save or the traditional three-out save.
These ideas have leaked down into the minors as well. Robinson asked for that.
“One of the things Dewey feels really strongly about is whatever we ask guys to do in the big leagues, they should be done in the minor leagues first,” Shelton said. “For us, it’s going to be a little bit challenging because we’re deploying them differently here without that. But right now I think that’s why you see us being a little bit more aggressive, especially in AA and AAA.”
There are obviously exceptions. The Pirates would love to have a true ace on their staff, and should someone prove they are able to navigate a lineup the third time through the order, the team has insisted they’d be given the chance to do so. But how do the Pirates identify those pitchers if the inclination is to pull them before the third time through? How does one prove they can do something if they aren’t given the chance to do it?
Basically, the Pirates are identifying plus pitches.
“First of all, it’s usually three pitches,” Robinson said. “You need more weapons to go through the third time through the order. If you’re a two-pitch guy, it’s a little harder. So that’s number one, and you’re looking at guys that have three pitches and they’re average to plus, can pitch to the major league level. Let’s exhaust that. [Rookie right-hander Roansy Contreras] is a great example, with three or four pitches to do that.”
This too can be matchup-based. Left-hander José Quintana has proven over his decade-long career that he can pitch deep into games. When he’s throwing well, Shelton lets him go.
The reality, though, is that the Pirates can’t count on signing aces year after year. It’s worked with Quintana and last year with Tyler Anderson, but both examples rehabilitated their careers. It was possible those signings would underwhelm.
Instead, the Pirates’ best hope at building a rotation of studs is to do it from within. Contreras could be the start. Top prospects like Quinn Priester and Mike Burrows could help. The Pirates have never competed with the big dogs on the free agent market, and they’re not about to start.
“The numbers on starters are going way down. Nobody’s pitching complete games,” Robinson said. “There are those guys that are still out there that we hope to continue to develop. But for us to survive in our market, we’re not going to go out and sign [Max Scherzer or Jacob deGrom]. We can develop them, but we’re not going to go out and sign them at this point anyway. We have to give ourselves the best chance to win ballgames.”
Robinson thinks he can help the Pirates do that.
To be clear, he isn’t directly in the trenches, helping tweak pitch grips or change the shape of a breaking ball. He’s more of an overseer. Robinson watches video, gets data, even reads newspaper clippings. If he thinks a tweak can help a pitcher, he’ll share that information, and he’s working with more and more minor league pitchers to try to help development, but at the major league level, it’s still pitching coach Oscar Marin in charge.
That doesn’t mean Robinson can’t take a direct approach. When Crowe was told that he would be moving into his current hybrid role, Robinson talked to him about what would need to change in his preparation to give him a chance to succeed. Shelton even explicitly gave Robinson an open door to his office.
“When I sat down to have lunch with him before we hired him, I told him, like, hey I want you to have a voice with me,” Shelton said. “You and I have history. I trust you, so if you see something, tell me.”
Robinson has used that voice. Now the Pirates are trying to fit into the mold he gave them.
Mike Persak: mpersak@post-gazette.com and Twitter @MikeDPersak






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.