Thirty-eight minutes into his Wednesday afternoon Zoom call, Pirates general manager Ben Cherington decided to announce — and thus made official — two moves that could impact the Pirates as much, if not more, than any of what he did during the previous 72 hours.
As first reported by the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette, the Pirates have formally installed Andy Haines as their head hitting coach and added Radley Haddad to manager Derek Shelton’s coaching staff to help with game-planning and strategy.
The Haines hire concludes a months-long search that started when the Pirates parted ways with Rick Eckstein on Aug. 30. The 44-year-old Haines was most recently the head hitting coach in Milwaukee but was fired after the Brewers struggled offensively in 2021.
“It was a long process,” Cherington said. “We spent a lot of time on it. [Haines] struck us as an uncommon combination of experience with open-mindedness. Real desire to collaborate. Really excited to be working with him. Reports about him from the last couple places he's been have been really strong."
It will certainly be interesting to see what Haines can do with an offense that finished last in runs (609), home runs (124) and slugging percentage (.364) this past season.
And if his Milwaukee tenure serves as any sort of template … well, OK, that doesn’t help a ton.
Read More
Haines took over in 2019 and enjoyed a terrific start, with the Brewers slugging a franchise-record 250 home runs to finish seventh in MLB. Their OPS (.767), meanwhile, was 12th.
There have also been subsequent struggles. Christian Yelich, who won the National League MVP in 2018 and finished second the following year, has hit .205 and .248 the past two seasons while striking out 26.2% of the time.
Milwaukee also hit just .233 (only two clubs fared better), its OPS was a pedestrian .713 (20th), and the Brewers had the seventh-most strikeouts (1,465) in MLB.
It’s tough to blame all of that on Haines, but his task list in Pittsburgh isn’t short. The cliff notes version should look something like this:
• Help Roberto Perez and Kevin Newman recapture their 2019 form, when the former hit 24 home runs and the latter had an .800 OPS.
• Work with Ke’Bryan Hayes to pull the ball more and rediscover the power he flashed in September 2020.
• Continue the positives we saw from Cole Tucker (.308 average, .892 OPS over his final 14 games) and Anthony Alford, who found additional power after reviving his season with a stint in the minors.
As for Haddad, who’s just 31 but has been a Yankees coaching assistant/bullpen catcher for the past five years, Cherington said he will get to expand his role in Pittsburgh.
Mike Rabelo, now third-base coach, will keep his field coordinator duties, while Haddad “will be a big part of our pitching and catching group, helping us prepare for games in terms of pitch usage and sequencing, and then he'll be in the dugout in-game, helping to make adjustments with our strategy, particularly pitcher-batter matchups."
Assistant hitting coach Christian Marrero and analyst Tim McKeithan remain in their current roles, Cherington said. Bench coach Don Kelly will assume the infield instruction that was handled by former third-base coach Joey Cora.
Prospect talk
Before announcing the coaching staff, Cherington discussed the prospects involved in the Jacob Stallings trade and what the Pirates like about each.
Zach Thompson, 28, is the most well-known of the bunch after making 26 appearances (14 starts) for the Marlins last season, pitching to a 3.24 ERA over 75 innings.
Thompson’s best pitch is his cutter, which he throws 35.1% of the time. It netted a .284 slugging percentage against in 2021, the lowest of his five offerings. Cherington called Thompson “a late-bloomer” and said they’ve seen a recently uptick with the quality of Thompson’s pitches and his comfortability using them.
They also like the 6-foot-7, 230-pounder’s ability to pound the strike zone and generate weak contact, as well as his off-field makeup.
“Our group was high on him,” Cherington said. “There was an opportunity to add someone we think can be part of our rotation mix in 2022 and obviously, given where he is in his career, has a chance to be here for a while.”
The second piece was another big-bodied pitcher in Kyle Nicolas, who reached Class AA last season and had a 2.52 ERA across eight starts. Nicolas (6-4, 224) was the 61st overall pick (compensatory round) out of Ball State in 2020 and throws in the mid-90s with a terrific slider.
The knock is that he needs to develop a third pitch; neither his curveball nor his changeup are refined enough.
“There are some things he needs to develop in order to be a starter in the major leagues, but we're going to keep him in that role,” Cherington said. “Excited to work with him. Again, a really good reputation as a worker and a teammate. The Pirates spent a lot of time on him in the draft, so there's a good history there.”
The last player was Connor Scott, an athletic outfielder Miami drafted 13th overall in 2018. His development has been slow, as he’s only reached High-A, but there should probably be some slack cut for having no minor league season in 2020.
Scott had a solid 2021, where hit .276 with a .779 and a wRC+ of 112.
“He can run, he's athletic, he can really throw, he’s got some pop, and he started to figure some things out this year,” Cherington said. “We hope there’s some untapped potential.”
Jason Mackey: jmackey@post-gazette.com and Twitter @JMackeyPG.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.