Cutting ties with Colin Moran made sense. Although he’s had some decent stretches, Moran has been worth a total of 0.8 Wins Above Replacement (WAR) over his six-year career, according to FanGraphs. With the signing of Yoshi Tsutsugo and Moran’s projected arbitration amount of $4 million, that “value” can be replicated for less.

Steven Brault and Chad Kuhl were understandable, as well. There have been promising signs, yes, but also a multitude of throwing-arm injuries and only a handful of instances where they’ve regularly been able to sustain an above-average level of performance.

But Kevin Newman? It was a bit of a head-scratcher. In case you missed it, the Pirates decided to bring back their light-hitting-but-reliably-fielding shortstop for 2022 on a $1.95 million contract, avoiding arbitration.

The Newman move was confusing on a few different levels, not the least of which is their succession plan at shortstop. But before we get to that, the discussion should probably start with the idea that Newman, who had a .574 OPS last season, somehow has the sixth-highest salary on the team.

Advertise with us

For a team as cost-conscious as they are, theoretically analyzing every transaction, the Pirates are somehow spending nearly $2 million on a player who was dead last among FanGraphs’ list of 26 qualified shortstops in 2021 at 0.3 WAR. (Oneil Cruz played two games and was worth 0.1 fWAR.)

Given the obvious financial constraints that exist here, the Pirates clearly made the decision they did expecting Newman to play, and that’s why this particular move is even tougher to understand.

"One of the things we admire about Kevin is when there’s a challenge in front of him, he works his tail off and gets after it," general manager Ben Cherington said. "He was challenged last winter on his defense. Sure enough, he improved it.

"I know from talking to him a lot during the season and after the season, he feels there's a challenge with his offense, and he’s committed to finding a way to improve.”

Selling wins and losses to fans in 2022 is going to be hard because there likely won’t be much of the former and a lot of the latter. The entry point should be getting in on the ground floor and watching the growth of guys like Cruz, Rodolfo Castro or Tucupita Marcano, their ninth-ranked prospect by MLB Pipeline.

Advertise with us

Following the Pirates this upcoming season should be about who seizes what, and it’s the team’s responsibility to give players the opportunity to do that. In other words, the middle infield should a proving ground for guys like Cruz, Castro, Cole Tucker, Michael Chavis, Hoy Park and Diego Castillo.

The especially odd part here is theoretically blocking Cruz — one of their few legitimate sources of fan optimism — in favor of a guy who had some of the worst power numbers in all of baseball last season.

Among qualified hitters, nobody had a worse slugging percentage (.309) or OPS (.574) than Newman. Only one player, David Fletcher of the Angels, had a worse average exit velocity (85.3).

Does that make Newman a bad hitter in perpetuity? Tough to say. His past 192 games haven’t been good, but the 130 before that — his 2019 season — were great. Where does the truth lie?

In the Pirates’ defense, Newman really was exceptional with his glove in 2021. He made just three errors, had the second-best fielding percentage for a shortstop (.993) in National League history and led all MLB shortstops in FanGraphs’ calculation of Fielding Runs Above Average at 11.9.

Advertise with us

Should that performance or anything even remotely close continue, Newman could enjoy a long career as a Clint Barmes type — a glove-first shortstop teams know will catch the ball and add value different ways.

The difficult-to-square part is why the offensively challenged Pirates, a team in the midst of a very heavy youth movement, decided to spend basically $2 million on a 28-year-old with a checkered history of offensive production.

"This year, what he brought to the field and his primary strength was his ability to play defense at shortstop," Cherington said. “There will be competition, and he knows that. But he has every opportunity to keep the playing time he got this year."

The Pirates are clearly hoping and believing that Newman isn’t the offensive player he’s been the past two seasons, that he can use playing time in the first half to replicate his 2019, when he had a 2.4 fWAR.

But wouldn’t that strand of logic apply to Newman’s defense, as well? Given how good he was in 2021, it’s easy to forget that Newman led the Pirates with eight errors in 41 games in 2020. Logically, if the Pirates are banking on his offense reverting back to a certain form, couldn’t his defense also do the same?

Advertise with us

It’s a risk, the same as all transactions. It’s just one that’s tough to understand for a team in the Pirates’ situation, where they easily could’ve repurposed Newman’s $1.95 million and tried to fill a greater need.

The Pirates must hope that Cherington and Newman are right, that he recognizes the offensive challenge and tackles it the same way he did his defense this past season.

“We trust him to do the work,” Cherington said. “We see how that plays out. We look forward to seeing what he does with that challenge."

Jason Mackey: jmackey@post-gazette.com and Twitter @JMackeyPG.