The MLB draft will get underway Sunday with the Pirates holding the top pick in the first round. Here’s a look back at some of the guys they’ve selected in that spot in the past.
Jeff King (1986) — The Pirates’ first selection at 1:1 came in the shadow of the Pittsburgh drug trials, which engulfed the club in 1985 and led to a 57-104 mark that was one of the worst in franchise history. Fortunately for all involved, King lived up to being the needed bright spot to emerge from that dark time. The University of Arkansas product reached the big leagues and 1989 and quickly became a contributor on division championship teams in 1990-92, hitting 14 homers and driving in 65 runs for the latter group en route to a 96-66 finish. You know how those playoff runs ended in disappointment. But King, at least, got even better in his later years here, hitting .271/.346/.497 with 30 homers and 111 RBIs in his final tour with the team in 1996. He was traded to Kansas City the following offseason and had a couple more solid years before calling it quits at the end of an injury-riddled 1999.
Kris Benson (1996) — A decade later, Benson was supposed to be the guy the Pirates built a winning pitching staff around, but it never quite worked out that way. He reached the big leagues roughly on schedule in 1999 and reached the 30-start mark in each of his first two campaigns with ERAs of 4.07 and 3.85, respectively. Unfortunately for the Pirates, he was never the same following Tommy John surgery in 2001. He missed that entire reason and never posted an ERA below 4.70 before he was traded to the New York Mets in the middle of the 2004 season. He was a bit better there but washed out of the majors at the end of 2006. A comeback bid later in the decade fizzled after just 11 appearances.
Bryan Bullington (2002) — He’s probably the gold standard for Pirates first-round busts of recent vintage. Unlike his predecessors at first overall, the Ball State product needed five years to reach the big leagues if you exclude a cup of coffee that lasted fewer than two innings in 2005 before shoulder surgery cost him all of 2006. He wasn’t any good when he got here either, posting a 5.29 ERA in five appearances — three of them starts — in 2007. The Pirates had pretty much seen enough. After a rough start with Class AAA Indianapolis in 2008, Bullington was designated for assignment to end a disappointing tenure. Cleveland, Toronto and Kansas City gave him chances in subsequent years, but he couldn’t make it stick with any of them. He was out of the bigs by 2011 having never thrown more than 50 innings in any season.
Gerrit Cole (2011) — The club’s most recent first overall selection was also probably their best. Cole arrived quickly and made an impact immediately, posting a 3.22 ERA as a rookie in 2013 and helping the Pirates to their first winning season since 1992. He started and won the game that ensured they’d finish over .500, and he pitched well in the playoffs, allowing two or fewer runs in both of his starts in the division series against St. Louis. In subsequent years, he was a reliable force in the rotation, posting sub-4.00 ERAs in four of his five seasons here, though he did take the loss in the 2015 wild card game, turning a 98-win season into a disappointment. Following some relative struggles in 2017, he was shipped to the Houston Astros for a package of players that included current Pirate Colin Moran. He helped lead them to a World Series before signing with the New York Yankees for a lucrative contract in 2020.
Adam Bittner: abittner@post-gazette.com and Twitter @fugimaster24.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.