The next month may be one of the biggest of Ben Cherington’s tenure with the Pirates.
In July alone, he will lead the organization in making the first overall selection in the 2021 MLB Draft and will also oversee a potentially busy trade deadline.
That isn’t typical, as the draft is normally in June, spread out more from the trade deadline. This year, there isn’t that luxury. And although the Draft is now just 10 days away, Cherington says the Pirates are still evaluating and organizing their big board ahead of their selection.
“I think we’ll use all the time we have,” Cherington said in an appearance on 93.7 The Fan on Thursday. “It’s a really important decision. I don’t know any reason why we’d make the decision sooner than we have to, because you just never know what you’ll learn until you have to make it. So obviously we need to be really well prepared. The key is getting the board in a really good spot, because once the draft starts, then it goes extremely quickly, and then you don’t have time to reorder at that point.”
Cherington has reiterated this idea time and time again with regards to their pick. The Pirates aren’t going to decide for certain on their selection until closer to the draft. Even if that weren’t true, they probably wouldn’t tip their hand.
What Cherington also emphasized is that the Pirates are focused on acquiring as much talent as possible in the entire draft, with the bonus pool money they have been allotted. That is the money they have to dole out throughout the entire draft.
Read More
One strategy to doing that could be paying less money — or paying “under slot” — to the first overall pick and using their savings to lure some other prospects to sign later in the draft by paying them more money than their slot value in the draft.
It isn’t a new strategy. Teams have done it in the past. In this year’s draft, where there is no true, consensus, top talent, that could be an effective way to still get one of the top talents while deepening the draft class as a whole. Perhaps that means taking the Pirates’ favorite player in the draft. Perhaps it means taking their second or third favorite player at No. 1 and using the savings to draft and sign a better player later on. It is certainly possible that the Pirates’ favorite player is also the cheapest to sign.
Cherington said that the cost of signing players is information that isn’t typically solidified until late in the evaluation process, though conversations surrounding the topic can happen whenever. He was also asked point blank Thursday whether the Pirates will take whichever player, in their opinion, is the best one in the draft.
“It’s going to depend a lot on the next 10 days,” Cherington said. “We’re in the room now, diving into that board that you talked about. We have some work to do to get it in order still. It’s in a good spot. We have more work to do. We’re still learning about guys. We’re asking questions. We’re having really good debate upstairs about players. We need to do that work first and see where we are. It’s very clear that our decision on who to take at 1.1 is really important, important to the future of the Pirates. It’s also very clear we need to get the most possible talent we can out of the entire draft this year.”
When the dust settles from there, Cherington will have more decisions to make with the trade deadline at the end of July. He’s already been taking calls and texts with other teams and discussing possible interest in certain players.
Perhaps the Pirates’ most heavily-rumored trade chip is second baseman Adam Frazier. Cherington was asked whether Frazier’s one year of remaining arbitration eligibility makes him a more attractive candidate to other teams, as opposed to one who would be a free agent after the season.
“The simple thing is the more control or arb years or whatever you want to call it a player has, the more valuable that player is to the team that he’s with now and the team that might ask,” Cherington said. “So that’s not specific to Frazier, just any player. So Adam Frazier is a really good player, having a really good year, who, as you said, has one year of arbitration left, and that’s really valuable to us. So we’re happy he’s a Pirate. He helps us every day. Other teams like him too.”
Obviously, Cherington wouldn’t tip his hand or imply whether Frazier will be out of Pittsburgh by the end of July. At the same time, whatever the Pirates decide to do in the next month, with both the draft and the trade deadline, will help shape the next several years in Pittsburgh.
Moran returns to injured list, Oliva recalled from Indianapolis
After first baseman Colin Moran was hit by a pitch on the left wrist in Monday’s game against the Colorado Rockies, he left the game almost immediately. But afterward, there appeared to be good news, with manager Derek Shelton saying that imaging on Moran’s wrist came back without any structural damage.
Moran has since had a CT scan done on it, though, which revealed a small fracture to his pisiform bone, and was thus placed on the 10-day injured list.
In his place, the Pirates promoted their No. 14 prospect, outfielder Jared Oliva, from Class AAA Indianapolis. The move for Oliva, as opposed to another first baseman like Indianapolis’ Will Craig, comes in large part because Oliva is already on the 40-man roster, so no players need to be designated for assignment to make room for Oliva.
Shelton did emphasize that Oliva will provide depth, mainly, though he may get a few starts during his time on the big league roster.
Mike Persak: mpersak@post-gazette.com and Twitter @MikeDPersak




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.