MILWAUKEE — Here’s a question to ponder after the Pirates’ 5-2 loss to the Milwaukee Brewers on Sunday at American Family Field, Pittsburgh’s season-high seventh in a row.

What if Wil Crowe’s final pitch — a low-and-inside fastball to Tim Lopes, the 10th pitch of a terrific at-bat to open the bottom of the sixth inning — had been called a strike instead of a ball? It was close. In this era, it would take about 30 seconds to search online and find something worse.

So say Crowe retired Lopes. It would have been the 16th consecutive batter retired for the Pirates right-hander, the longest stretch anyone on the Pirates pitching staff has enjoyed this season. At 82 pitches through 5⅓ innings (5.125 per out), Crowe would’ve been on pace for six innings and roughly 93 pitches.

Alas, the pitch wasn’t called a strike, Lopes walked, and what happened next became the biggest talking point to come out of this one, for a few different reasons. One, after manager Derek Shelton pulled Crowe, the Brewers grabbed the lead for good on a couple of misplaced pitches from David Bednar.

Advertise with us

Two, Shelton had allowed Crowe to hit with the bases loaded and the Pirates trying to build on a one-run lead the inning before, and Crowe grounded out to second.

“It was the 10-pitch at-bat,” Shelton said about why he pulled Crowe when he did. “We let [Crowe] hit. He was at 72 [pitches]. He was pounding the zone. That at-bat got extended and all of a sudden we have the tying run on, so we went to Bednar. If [Crowe] gets [Lopes] more efficiently, then he probably gets another hitter.”

Shelton was then asked if one long at-bat could end his pitcher’s outing, whether he regretted not pinch-hitting for Crowe in the sixth.

“He was at 72 [pitches], and he was efficient,” Shelton said. “We were planning on running him through. It was the fact that that at-bat got extended that long.”

Another interesting part here was that the Pirates (23-41) had Bednar warming as the inning started. That would seem to indicate that the Pirates thought Crowe was nearing the end, which brings into further question the move to not use a pinch-hitter in a big spot.

Advertise with us

Either way, it’s also not the worst decision to turn things over to the Pirates bullpen, which has been one of the few bright spots this season. The blowup suffered here Friday was an anomaly, the same for what Bednar did after entering the game.

So steady while allowing just 8.3% of inherited runners to score — fifth-lowest in MLB — Bednar hung a curveball to Luis Urias and a splitter to Avisail Garcia. Triple, home run, three runs scored.

“When you leave balls in the middle of the plate in the big leagues, they’re gonna get hit,” Shelton said. “Both of ‘em got hit.”

The encouraging part of Sunday’s game was mostly how Crowe performed, how his tempo was improved and he seemed to fall into a nice rhythm after allowing a run in the first.

When Crowe was sent to Class AAA Indianapolis after his last start, he said he worked a lot with aqua bags, which helped him stay more in his back leg. It stopped him from being so “jumpy” toward the plate because felt like he had better balance. Stronger command stemmed from there.

Advertise with us

After allowing a single and double to start, Crowe caught himself around the fourth hitter of the game and realized he was operating a little slow. He tapped on the gas, and he seemed to find cruising speed pretty quickly.

“It’s just getting the ball and going,” said Crowe, who struck out eight. “A big thing for me is my breathing. If I get going too fast, my breathing goes away. If my breathing gets slow, I might be getting away or taking too much time in between my breaths.

“It’s just more a matter of feeling the game speed, being cognizant of how it’s going and just keeping [the defense] interactive and ready to go. You don’t want your defense to fall asleep behind you, and a bad tempo can do that. So just being aware and having that sense.”

The situation here might be a bit of a Catch 22, honestly. Shelton said Saturday that he’d like his starting pitchers to give the Pirates more innings. It’s a fair expectation. They also have to earn that trust with their performance, which they have not done.

By tiring late, it’s hard to blame Shelton for wanting to get the ball in the hands of his most trustworthy weapon — the bullpen — as quickly as possible, although it’s also hard for these guys to pitch deeper in games without getting some valuable experience doing so, especially younger guys like Crowe.

Advertise with us

“I was good to go,” Crowe said. “But everyone knows our bullpen is incredible. We’re trying to win a ballgame. … I had all the confidence in [Bednar], and so did Shelty, even though it didn’t go our way. Those have shown through 60-plus games that they’re going to dominate out there. You go to those guys when you need to.”

Around the horn

Colin Moran left the game with lower-back tightness when he experienced back spasms while running the bases. He’s receiving treatment, being evaluated and is considered day-to-day. … Jacob Stallings homered, Ben Gamel had three hits, including two doubles, and Adam Frazier had two singles. … Ke’Bryan Hayes extended his hitting streak to 10 games this season, 18 dating back to 2020.

Jason Mackey: jmackey@post-gazette.com and Twitter @JMackeyPG.