Start by giving some credit where it’s due: The Pirates have somehow managed to wedge two once-in-a-lifetime moments into the same season.

Inside of a couple weeks, actually, which is truly remarkable.

The latest mishap was the first of several Tuesday during a 5-3 loss to the Los Angeles Dodgers at PNC Park, a game that could have potentially been a win had the Pirates not taken a day off from fundamentals while facing Dodgers starter Walker Buehler.

First inning. Ball clears the Clemente Wall. Ke’Bryan Hayes rounds first. Looks like he has his third homer in his seventh game back. Small problem: He doesn’t actually touch the bag. Dodgers notice. They appeal. Hayes is out. Home run is history. More palms on foreheads. Sets a sour tone for the rest of the game.

Advertise with us

“Key got caught watching the ball,” Pirates manager Derek Shelton said. “He thought he caught the back corner of [first base], and he didn't. If he even thinks he misses it, he has to go back and touch it."

The play was a doozy, a worthy silver medalist to Will Craig chasing Javy Baez back to … well, the batter’s box on May 27. After both blunders, Shelton and his players described them as aberrational plays, how they’ve never seen them before and won’t again.

Maybe not, but the Pirates should be more fundamentally sound than this. It’s one of the few things, while facing the big, bad Dodgers, that’s firmly within their grasp.

Another miscue, when Hayes over-slid second and was called out in the third, was an out the Pirates can ill-afford to fritter away against anyone, especially the defending World Series champs. Then in the fifth, Gregory Polanco booted a routine single, allowing Gavin Lux to take a couple of extra bases when the ball skipped under his glove.

Viewed in a vacuum, fine. Maybe there’s nothing egregious here. But for anyone who’s watched the Pirates over the past handful of years, they’ve likely screamed at the TV at some point over botched fundamentals. They can’t all be one-offs.

Advertise with us

They're also linked together in that neither Craig nor Hayes talked/was made available postgame. Feels like an opportunity missed when talking about accountability to fans and taking immediate ownership for mistakes made.

At the same time, it should be acknowledged how Hayes comported himself after his first mistake. Instead of sulking, he had a couple of quality at-bats and roped a single to left-center in his next one. Even the gaffe at second could probably be forgiven; he wasn’t wrong to go. He just over-shot the bag.

“I thought he made a good read on that,” Shelton said. “He made a good, aggressive play. He was safe initially, and he just slid past the bag."

The defeat drops the Pirates this season to 23-36, as they lost for the 11th consecutive time against the Dodgers. Pittsburgh had won three of four and five of nine coming out of a six-game losing streak.

Making his first start since May 29, JT Brubaker was actually solid for the Pirates, at least through four innings, allowing no runs and harmless singles to Cody Bellinger and Buehler.

Advertise with us

Brubaker also piled up six strikeouts, five of them looking. Three came on sinkers, two via sliders. The only other ball to leave the infield through four was a fly out from Mookie Betts in the first inning.

But in the fifth, the game unraveled for the Pirates, highlighted by Polanco’s error. Lux singled to right-center with one out. Ranging to his right, the ball trickled under Polanco’s glove, and Lux motored to third base on the error.

AJ Pollock hit a ball that Bryan Reynolds said cut on him at the end, the Pirates center fielder diving at the warning track and nearly making a terrific catch. Betts tripled, and Max Muncy singled for the other runs.

"I thought he got a little tired,” Shelton said of Brubaker. “He did a really nice job the first four innings executing pitches. It just looked like he got a little tired in the fifth, and we got him out at what we thought was the right opportunity."

Chris Taylor’s two-run homer off Chris Stratton in the sixth blew the game open.

Advertise with us

Buehler delivered seven scoreless innings to improve to 5-0 and lower his ERA to 2.56. He retired the final 13 Pirates he faced. It was the 12th start of six or more innings for Buehler this season. The Pirates as a team have had just 10 such starts.

As cold as their bats were against Buehler, they heated up against the Dodgers bullpen.

Phillip Evans led off the eighth with a single and scored on Adam Frazer's double, which extended the second baseman's hitting streak to 11 games. In the ninth, Reynolds and Michael Perez both hit solo homers to cut the deficit to two.

It brought the Pirates close enough to make the mistakes — especially missing the base on a home run — sting that much more.

“That's a once-in-a-lifetime thing, and it won't happen again,” Reynolds said of Hayes’ first mistake. “That could have easily been a day-ruiner for him, and he could have mentally checked out. But he strung together a bunch of good at-bats after that. That says a lot about who he is as a player and as a person.”

Jason Mackey: jmackey@post-gazette.com and Twitter @JMackeyPG.