As frustrating as the Pirates’ play has been of late, they won’t be short on assets when the trade deadline rolls around.
Adam Frazier is a two-time Gold Glove finalist enjoying a terrific offensive season. Richard Rodriguez has the lowest WHIP of any reliever in Major League Baseball. And Tyler Anderson will help fortify someone’s rotation.
All three should garner interest, and general manager Ben Cherington should be able to spin that into more prospects for Pittsburgh’s minor league system.
It’s also possible that none of the three qualify as the Pirates’ biggest potential trade chip. That honor may go to Jacob Stallings, although there has been nothing to indicate the Pirates are the least bit interested in trading Stallings.
Can you believe it? The Pirates designated Stallings for assignment in May 2019, yet here we are, talking about how he’s their biggest potential trade chip? It’s real, and it’s a tribute to how far Stallings has come as a player.
It also means the Pirates are probably best-served by keeping Stallings around as opposed to flipping him, especially given the lack of prospects at the position.
Read More
“He’s just so integral to development,” a National League national supervisor was telling me last week. “I tip my hat to them for staying patient with him.”
Now, it has paid off. A year after finishing second to Cincinnati’s Tucker Barnhart for the National League Gold Glove, Stallings could potentially become a first-time All-Star, the result of some increased offense in 2021.
Stallings also works cheap. He’ll earn $1.3 million in 2021 after going through arbitration for the first time, an absolute bargain for a contending team looking to acquire catching help at the deadline.
Sort of like another beloved veteran who once called Pittsburgh home.
“Stallings and David Ross are so eerily similar to me in their reputation, their makeup, their skill set and how they kind of got good late and got recognized later in their careers,” the national supervisor said. “You also factor in that Jacob is the son of a coach, which means he’s had coaching his whole life, and there’s a lot to like there.”
Ross played 40 games for the Pirates in 2005, long before he became a beloved figure in Boston and Chicago, eventually succeeding Joe Maddon as manager of the Cubs. The parallel makes sense.
Stallings, now 31, has definitely been a late bloomer. But like Ross, he has also ascended to a position that’s integral to a young club.
As the Pirates look to navigate a couple transition years and do a better job developing pitchers, the presence of Stallings matters. For how he’s able to call a game. For his ability as a pitch-framer, blocker and thrower. For his leadership qualities and how he’s able to make those around him feel at ease.
Which is why, as you probably guessed, the national supervisor wasn’t in favor of the Pirates potentially trading Stallings.
“Keep him around,” the national supervisor said. “The positives far outweigh the negatives.
“I think he’s better served in their organization, just trying to continue to develop the Mitch Kellers and kids behind him. Keep him around for two more years and reap the benefits.”
Among major league catchers who have at least 100 plate appearances this season, Stallings has nudged his way into the top half of both leagues in most offensive categories.
Looking at OPS, Stallings began the day Saturday 12th at .764. Shifting to weighted on-base average (wOBA), which functions like on-base percentage but rewards extra-base hits, Stallings (.338) was also 12th.
The numbers aren’t going to put Stallings in a category with Aaron Judge or Ronald Acuna Jr., but they do paint him as a competent offensive performer.
This, of course, while remaining a Gold Glove-level defender. Per FanGraphs, Stallings has been worth 5 Defensive Runs Saved, which is the second-best in MLB. He’s thrown out 26% of runners — above the league average — despite Pirates pitchers struggling to control the running game.
Then there’s the stuff that’s harder to quantify. How much he works with pitchers in the bullpen between starts. How he calls a game. And how he helps younger pitchers understand what they’re trying to do.
Combine that with a recent offensive uptick — a .341 on-base percentage and .848 OPS in his last 22 games dating back to April 23 — and it may make perfect sense to keep Stallings.
“If the Pirates made Stallings available, there would be a dozen clubs on him,” the national supervisor said. “That may be light. And I mean contending clubs. It’s a nice commodity to have for them.”
THREE UP
• It sure looks like Clay Holmes has finally figured it out and harnessed his terrific stuff. Holmes has strung together nine consecutive scoreless appearances, allowing one run in his last 17 outings. Power sinker. Terrific breaking ball. Holmes had all the makings of a solid reliever. Now, it looks like he’s also found some control.
• One prospect to watch who doesn’t get as much hype as he probably should is infielder Maikol Escotto, who came over in the Jameson Taillon trade. As of Thursday, the 18-year-old was hitting .321 with Low-A Bradenton, including a mark of .347 (with a .500 on-base percentage) since May 7. Won’t be long before he starts showing up on top 30 lists.
• Off all the outfield dumpster dives, I’m intrigued by Ben Gamel, at least as a fourth option. Please, no more Ka’ai Tom. But Gamel has at least been passable. Entering Saturday, he was 7-for-22 (.318) with a pair of doubles and a triple in his last six starts. He’s been more deserving of playing time than Gregory Polanco.
THREE DOWN
• It’s hard to gin up much optimism about the Pirates’ outfield prospects of late. Travis Swaggerty’s shoulder, Jared Oliva’s oblique … it’s tough at the major league level right now, and the available/expected help is injured. Best hope is for Round 2 with Anthony Alford, Dustin Fowler or Troy Stokes Jr.
• Speaking of injuries, they’re starting to pile up with the minor league guys. Including Ke’Bryan Hayes, five of their top 10 per MLB Pipeline are currently out with injuries, while Swaggerty and Cody Bolton are expected to be longer-term. Even Nick Gonzales will be out 4-6 weeks with an injury to the pinky finger in his right hand. Not good.
• Odd situation at shortstop. Erik Gonzalez was hitting .200 and slugging .213 in May entering play Saturday, yet he’s played a lot. Probably too much, many would argue. Kevin Newman has been solid defensively. They’re not going to move Adam Frazier anywhere, nor should they. Would also make sense to find Cole Tucker some time. A tough equation to balance.
UP NEXT
• Royals will host the Pirates for two at the start of the week. Odd year. Kansas City was a majors-best 16-9 through 25, then lost 11 in a row. Had won eight of 13 entering play Saturday.
• Watch shortstop Adalberto Mondesi, who missed the first 45 games of the season after straining his right oblique in Kansas City’s final spring training game. He had 21 hits in his last 40 at-bats dating back to last season (.525) entering play Thursday.
• Marlins (Thursday-Sunday) are in the thick of a stretch where they’ll play 29 of 42 on the road. Pitching has been the name of the game in Miami, with the Marlins beginning the day Saturday sporting the seventh-best ERA in the majors (3.40).
• Welcome back Starling Marte (rib fracture), who returned from the injured list on Friday and went 1 for 3. The former Pirates outfielder was hitting .317 with a .917 OPS in 16 games this season.
NUMEROLOGY
2.68: That’s the combined ERA of Miami’s top three starting pitchers: Sandy Alcantara, Pablo Lopez and Trevor Rogers. Wondering how the Pirates stack up? It’s not great. JT Brubaker, Mitch Keller and Tyler Anderson combined for an ERA of 5.21 entering Saturday’s doubleheader.
Jason Mackey: jmackey@post-gazette.com and Twitter @JMackeyPG.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.