Offensive production was so rare from Pirates center fielders last season that it was almost impossible to imagine them getting less from that spot. That .496 collective OPS? Their pitchers were at .379 in 2019.

Yet, somehow, the players the Pirates have started in center have managed a Seven Springs-style slide so far in 2021, the group slashing .067/.173/.089 with an MLB-high 26 strikeouts — more than five times as many as the Houston Astros (26).

Dustin Fowler has struggled, hitting .167 in his nine starts. Anthony Alford has been worse, registering just one hit out of 20 at-bats. The starting center fielder out of spring training, Alford has racked up 15 strikeouts, with a whiff rate of 44.8% on fastballs.

The offense out of those two has been pretty much nonexistent, although general manager Ben Cherington preached patience on a Zoom call with reporters Thursday morning, arguing that the current 13-game sample size is just too small to draw any accurate conclusions.

Advertise with us

“We know we want to get more production, and we also want to learn more about players,” Cherington said. “We want to give it some time and see where this goes.”

Similar to their limited options with Gregory Polanco, there’s not a ton the Pirates can do here, at least in terms of stuff that makes sense.

Fowler (13 strikeouts, one extra-base hit) and Alford are both out of options, meaning you’d risk losing them if you sent them down. Does that matter? It may not given their collective struggles.

Both are former top 100 prospects and have plenty of talent. It’s entirely possible another team will bring that out. And if/when they do, it’ll be another here-we-go-again label slapped on the Pirates’ development program.

Then there’s this: Who’s actually pushing for time here?

Advertise with us

Fowler and Alford have obviously struggled. Alford, for one, looks lost at the plate, his confidence clearly shaken. Only the Phillies (.258) have a lower OPS than the Pirates (.262) out of that position group, while both teams trail what pitchers have produced (.281) with that stat while hitting for the first time since 2021.

Yes, seriously. Pirates outfielders have been less productive than major league pitchers in terms of getting on base and slugging percentage. It’s a flawed stat, but MLB pitchers also have a better batting average: .116.

The issue, then, becomes fixing the problem. Their most major league-ready outfield prospect, Jared Oliva (No. 16 per MLB Pipeline), hit .120 in spring and has been doing “skill development” work in Bradenton. He’ll join the team on the taxi squad for Pittsburgh’s upcoming road trip, but it’s probably not the time to install him as the starting center fielder.

Brian Goodwin has done some good things throughout his major league career, but he hit .229 in spring, was second on the team in strikeouts and has been working out at the Pirates’ alternate training site. Has he hit there? We don’t know. And does he really represent much of an improvement?

It’s probably a similar story for Troy Stokes Jr., who hit .212 in spring and was third in strikeouts. Travis Swaggerty, the Pirates’ first-round draft pick in 2018, probably should be pushing for time but hit .176 in Grapefruit League play. Oneil Cruz has not yet played two dozen innings in the outfield, while other top 30 guys such as Cal Mitchell (No. 18), Sammy Siani (No. 19) and Canaan Smith-Njigba (No. 26) simply aren’t ready.

Advertise with us

So, for now, Cherington views his best option as riding it out with Fowler and Alford, who are both receiving at least a semi-regular dose of playing time for the first time in their respective careers.

“We've got young players out there who are getting a chance to play at the major league level for the first time with any level of consistency, and there's an adjustment period,” Cherington said. “As long as guys are focused on what they need to do, working hard and trying to make adjustments, we want to support that. At the same time, we want to eventually see better production also.

“For right now, we want to give guys a chance to play and get into the season a little bit more. What hasn't changed, though, is that we see opportunity in the outfield. We see opportunity for guys to step up and win more playing time.”

A bit of a workaround here might be to shift Bryan Reynolds to center field, if the production from the current group doesn’t tick up soon. Reynolds has been solid there defensively and would actually prefer to play center.

Use Phillip Evans to back-fill in left, and play Erik Gonzalez – who’s surprisingly tied for second on the team with seven RBIs – at third until Ke’Bryan Hayes returns. When that happens, bounce Gonzalez and Evans, who are both fairly versatile.

Advertise with us

“I’ll defer to [manager Derek Shelton] on specific alignments,” Cherington said. “Bryan’s done that before, so we'd be confident with him in either spot. I think that'll probably mostly come down to what makes sense as far as giving our team the best chance to win on a particular night and getting guys into the lineup.”

That’s a fair way to think about it, but it’s also hard to see how Alford and Fowler — who don’t have two extra-base hits to rub together — have done that.

And while it’s also reasonable for Cherington to cite sample size before even 10% of the season is completed, it also doesn’t mean the Pirates are married to this current alignment forever.

Or shouldn’t be, anyway.

Jason Mackey: jmackey@post-gazette.com and Twitter @JMackeyPG.

Advertise with us