BRADENTON, Fla. — The Pirates threw everyone a curveball Thursday night by signing a guy with a pretty good one himself, as they added veteran pitcher Trevor Cahill on a $1.5 million contract that could be worth an additional $1 million in incentives.
Pittsburgh will be the 33-year-old right-hander’s ninth MLB team. In 2020, Cahill — a second-round pick of the Athletics in 2006 — pitched for the San Francisco Giants, where he went 1-2 with a 3.24 ERA in 11 games (six starts). He totaled 31 strikeouts and 25 innings.
It’s believed the Pirates envision Cahill as a starter, although he’ll have to get to spring training, complete the intake process and actually pitch in front of people before they can make any sort of actual decisions.
For his career, Cahill has logged 1,470 2/3 innings while going 85-94 with a 4.20 ERA, with one of his best (recent) seasons coming in 2018 during a second stint with the A’s. That’s when Cahill went 7-4 with a 3.76 ERA in 21 games (20 starts) while piling up 100 strikeouts in 110 innings.
The Pirates have not yet announced the Cahill move, but they will need to make a corresponding roster move to create space on their 40-man roster.
It will also be interesting to see who Cahill replaces, or whether someone isn’t completely healthy.
Read More
At this point, the Pirates have given no indication it’s the latter. However, JT Brubaker and Steven Brault had been following Mitch Keller in the rotation.
Keller started Thursday, and Brubaker’s start was pushed back to Saturday, giving Chase De Jong a chance. On their official game notes, the Pirates list their starting pitcher as “TBA” for games Sunday, Monday and Tuesday.
Cahill is an interesting addition because of his curveball and its terrific spin. The pitch has been in the 2,800-2,900 rpm range throughout Cahill’s 12-year career, and it’s been something for which he’s well-known.
In 2020, Cahill threw his curveball 23.0% of the time, and it generated a whiff rate of 43.8%, which is extremely good. It was down to 21.9% in 2019 but did not fall below 34.9% in the four years before that.
Over the past five years, Cahill’s curveball has produced a weighted on-base average (wOBA) of .090, .286, .207, .194 and .202 — all extremely low.
Cahill throws five pitches fairly equally and actually relied on his changeup more than anything in 2020 (29.8%). He has evolved from a guy who threw sinkers 52% of the time in 2015 to someone who threw them just 24.6% last season.
What Cahill does well absolutely tracks with how the Pirates have done business lately, on a couple fronts. New pitching coach Oscar Marin has shown a propensity for pitchers with terrific spin rates and likes to accentuate those strengths.
The Pirates have also been more liberal with guys like Keller, Kuhl and JT Brubaker, encouraging them to throw their spin pitchers more. Cahill should fit very well within that.
Cahill has made just five appearances and one start at PNC Park during his career, pitching to a 4.09 ERA over 11 innings. He’s 2-1 lifetime against the Pirates, with a 3.69 ERA in 15 games (four starts) overall.
The Cahill signing could mean bad things for Brubaker, because of the business side of this signing. Cahill and Tyler Anderson both have major league deals. Kuhl and Brault were eligible for arbitration but avoided it by agreeing to contracts ahead of time.
That leaves Keller, their potential starter for the season- or home-opener. It’s extremely doubtful they start Keller with Class AAA, which means they might have to put Brubaker there and let him earn his spot. Or, given the need for a large volume of pitchers with the MLB club, perhaps they could shift Brubaker to a bullpen role.
But manager Derek Shelton has said previously that he envisions the Pirates opening the season with a five-man rotation and evaluating any possible changes from there. The process of elimination sort oof says Brubaker would be the odd-man out.
It’s also probably best to wait for Cahill to arrive and see what he has. If he pitches like he did in 2018 or 2010, when he was an All-Star while going 18-8 with as 2.97 as a 22-year-old in Oakland, then the Pirates will obviously find a spot for Cahill.
But if he looks like he did in 2019, when he had a 5.98 ERA for the Angels in 37 games (11 starts), then things might be different. What we know, though, is that Cahill certainly has the weapons to succeed. It’s more a matter of putting them to good use.
And if it works, this move should fit within another thing general manager Ben Cherington has been trying to do. Cahill profiles as a possible flip candidate at the trade deadline; a strong start could net them a prospect or two for the ongoing rebuilding plan.
Jason Mackey: jmackey@post-gazette.com and Twitter @JMackeyPG.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.