BRADENTON, Fla. — Derek Shelton’s smartest decision of the spring may have occurred before the fourth inning of Sunday’s game, and it had nothing to do actual baseball strategy such as pitching changes or pinch-hitters.
At some point during the first couple of innings of a 13-1 victory over the Orioles at LECOM Park, Kevin Newman felt tightness in his left hamstring. So the Pirates manager simply had Newman pack his stuff and call it a day, sending Ji-Hwan Bae to shortstop as a replacement.
Given how Newman has looked so far this spring, it was not a risk worth taking. Newman had a rough year in 2020 — slashing .224/.281/.276, making a team-high eight errors and effectively losing his starting job — but has appeared poised for a bounce-back in 2021, his swing more compact and direct to the ball.
Newman has six hits in his first eight at-bats of the spring while scoring five runs, walking twice and playing sound defense. Although it’s early, it has been enough for Newman to separate himself from Erik Gonzalez and Cole Tucker, who also are competing for the starting shortstop job.
“Competition usually brings out the best in people,” Shelton said. “That's kind of what we were hoping would happen in this situation.”
It certainly seems to have been the case with Newman, who has risen to the occasion. As for the others, Gonzalez is 3-for-9 with a home run and four strikeouts. Tucker is 0-for-3 and currently sidelined with a left thumb contusion.
Read More
At this point Newman has taken the lead, with Gonzalez still adding value as a multi-position backup off the bench, and Tucker the odd-man out. But obviously a lot can change between now and April 1. Now, with nine more thoughts on what we’ve seen during spring training thus far ...
2. What about center field? Good question. And there’s significantly less clarity here.
There are effectively four guys competing for the job, although it’s complicated because of contracts. Dustin Fowler also has been a late, intriguing entry into the mix.
So far, neither Brian Goodwin nor Anthony Alford has done much. They’re a combined 2-for-15 with eight strikeouts. Alford, meanwhile, was limited early in camp due to lingering effects from a fractured right elbow.
Goodwin is on a minor league deal, and Alford is out of options. So, unless someone changes minds, it might make the most sense to keep Alford with the big club and Goodwin with Class AAA to start.
Jared Oliva, the Pirates’ No. 12 prospect according to MLB Pipeline, has looked solid. He even roped an RBI-single on Sunday. But it was also Oliva’s first hit of spring, and he has not yet played above Class AAA.
Fowler, acquired from the A’s for cash in late February, may have changed the calculus at the position. He can run. He’s capable defensively. He also had 25 homers at Class AAA in 2019 when he refined his approach and started taking more pitches.
Remember, Fowler was a top 100 prospect in baseball — so was Alford, to be fair — as recently as 2018, when he hit .341 (also at Class AAA). But Fowler, 26, struggled to do much with the limited MLB time he got in Oakland, was blocked in the outfield and made things worse on himself by pressing.
Watch Fowler in the next two weeks. He smoked a ball Saturday in his first game action of the spring. On Sunday, he cleared the bases with a double. With plenty to sort out in center, the Pirates should want to take a long look at Fowler, who’s also out of options.
3. The battle behind the plate has been fun to watch … and it actually may not be much of a battle at all, considering the return of the taxi squad and the fact that MLB teams again will travel three catchers.
Tony Wolters and Michael Perez are battling for the chance to back up Jacob Stallings. Perez has a spot on the 40-man roster, while Wolters does not — meaning the Pirates would have to get rid of someone to add him.
Perez was a waiver claim from the Rays after backing up Mike Zunino (and others) in Tampa. Wolters has been the Rockies’ primary catcher the past two seasons and statistically has a strong profile; since making his MLB debut in 2016, Wolters ranks third among National League catchers in stolen-base runs saved, seventh in defensive runs saved and 11th in pitch-framing, per FanGraphs.
So far, however, the competition has been extremely close. Both guys have shown the ability to frame pitches. Their throwing has been fairly even, though Perez nailed a runner with a laser during Saturday’s game. Neither has done much to create separation at the plate.
But with basically three weeks of games left, the Pirates should feel encouraged that they have two capable catchers competing for time, in addition to a starter in Stallings who has blossomed into one of the best defensive backstops in baseball.
4. It’s been a rough spring for the group of prospects the Pirates invited to camp. They have eight here guys from their MLB Pipeline top 30, and those players have combined to hit .136 (6-for-44) with 17 strikeouts.
That group includes Nick Gonzales (1), Oneil Cruz (3), Travis Swaggerty (7), Jared Oliva (12), Ji-Hwan Bae (15), Cal Mitchell (17), Mason Martin (25) and Canaan Smith-Njigba (26).
5. Similarly, a few of the Pirates’ recent high-round picks also have scuffled. Tucker (2014, 1st round), Kevin Kramer (2015, 2nd), Will Craig (2016, 1st) and Swaggerty (2018, 1st) have gone a combined 1-for-26 (.038) with 12 strikeouts.
6. Another odd nugget here: The Pirates have added a few pitchers recently who throw a changeup or splitter as their primary secondary offering, choosing those over more common options such as sliders or curveballs. In 2021, that’s not a common way to pitch.
Fitting that category are Tyler Anderson (changeup, 33% in 2020), Duane Underwood Jr. (changeup, 28% in 2020), Chasen Shreve (splitter, 40.8% in 2020) and David Bednar (splitter, 26.3% in 2020).
7. Speaking of Bednar, the Mars product might be pitching himself into a regular bullpen role. In three games, the hard-throwing righty has not allowed a hit or run while walking one and striking out a team-high seven.
“He’s a guy who’s very interesting,” Shelton said. “Ball comes out of his hand hot.”
8. While Bednar is pushing for time, it’s hard to see where Phillip Evans fits on this roster.
Figure the Pirates will have either a four- or five-man bench, and three of those spots will go to Todd Frazier, a backup catcher (Wolters or Perez) and a fourth outfielder. It’s also smart to earmark one for whoever does not become the starting shortstop — at this point, likely Gonzalez.
That leaves the Pirates with a question: Do they keep Evans, who has gotten work at first, third and the outfield, or do they carry nine pitchers?
Considering they have available backups at all three of those spots and pitching depth figures to be crucial given the jump from 60 games to 162, it probably makes more sense to carry nine pitchers instead of eight.
9. Speaking of the bullpen, there’s actually a surprising amount of competition here.
Based on precedent — both last season and with contract status — it’s hard to see the bullpen not including Richard Rodriguez, Chris Stratton, Michael Feliz, Kyle Crick, Sam Howard and Geoff Hartlieb.
The Pirates’ desire to add Underwood Jr. should tell us something — that they like him and feel he can contribute, especially given the fact that he’s out of options.
Even without him, you’re looking at a group of Shreve, Bednar, Luis Oviedo (who, as a Rule 5 pick, must remain on the active roster, or the Pirates risk losing him), Blake Cederlind and Edgar Santana.
Counting Underwood Jr., that’s six guys vying for three spots.
Underwood Jr.’s ticket to a major league job could be his ability to work multiple innings. He never did that much with the Cubs, totaling 36⅓ in his 30 career MLB appearances, but he was a starter for several years in the minors.
Stratton is the only one of the first six with any substantive experience with longer outings. Oviedo is young. Bednar has made just 17 MLB appearances (totaling 17⅓ innings), while Santana has not pitched since 2018 because of Tommy John surgery and a PED suspension last season.
Somebody among that second group will have to prove that he can get more than three outs at a time, and that’s probably not a role best-suited for the hard-throwing Cederlind.
10. Given the impression he’s made on … well, everyone, it’s really hard to see Frazier not making the team.
Not only is he tied for the Pirates lead with two home runs this spring, but he’s hitting .375 overall and has already shown an ability to be a clubhouse leader and veteran voice, something this young club really needs.
Extra innings: Did you worry whether Ke’Bryan Hayes would be able to follow his terrific 2020 season? Seems like a waste of time now, no? His defense looks terrific. His swing has been smooth. There’s power to all fields.
Hayes has been so fun to watch. Last season — and again, for the three people who may have actually worried about this — definitely wasn’t a fluke. He may have actually gotten better.
Jason Mackey: jmackey@post-gazette.com and Twitter @JMackeyPG.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.