BRADENTON, Fla. — Ben Cherington hesitated for no more than a millisecond, the infinitesimal pause of someone confident in what he was about to say.

"Yeah," the general manager said while staring into a computer screen over Zoom Sunday afternoon from Pirate City, "I do."

The question asked was a sanitized version of what every Pirates fan has probably thought at various points this offseason, when the San Diego Padres made splash after splash — adding Yu Darvish and Blake Snell, trading for Joe Musgrove, signing Fernando Tatis Jr. to a huge extension and other attention-grabbing moves.

San Diego had an opening day payroll of just $38 million in 2010 and somehow managed to win 90 games. In 2021, the Padres will more than quadruple that number, as their current projection, per Spotrac.com, sits around $160 million.

Advertise with us

With the Pirates' payroll for this season expected to be even a little above where the Padres started — the same site has Pittsburgh around $42 million — Cherington said he absolutely sees a way to grow that number over time and explained, in detail, how he believes it can happen.

"If you just look at the teams that have been in the playoffs for the last several years, you can look at the vast majority of them and rewind from that point two, three, four years, and there are some common things happening in advance of those playoff seasons," Cherington said.

A funny thing about Cherington: He prefaced his lengthy answer by saying he viewed this as an overly simplistic way of thinking about the team-building process. He also closed with a measure of uncertainty, after nearly four minutes of talking, on whether he actually answered the question.

Cherington absolutely did — for now. But the only way this question goes away and the conversation shifts to something else involves the Pirates successfully doing what Cherington described.

The first part of this three-step process started when Cherington took over. After evaluating what the Pirates had, he concluded — probably rather quickly — that it wasn’t anywhere near enough. The Pirates would have to add talent, and a lot of it.

Advertise with us

“Those teams had done a really good job just accumulating talent,” Cherington said, talking about recent playoff teams and the trends he’s noticed. “Whether that was through the draft or international [signings] or trades, or acquiring young players through a combination of all that stuff, very often that’s what those teams have been doing.”

In the draft, you’ve seen Nick Gonzales — a terrific, slam-dunk pick, according to evaluators — followed by a run of right-handed pitchers. Highly rated Dominican outfielder Shalin Polanco checks the second box, while the return via offseason trades will be learned over time.

Whether it’s scouts or outlets putting together farm system rankings, the Pirates have made some sizable gains over the past year, though Cherington will be the first to tell you that the Pirates are nowhere near satisfied.

The second part here involves helping players improve. Another way to put this would be Tyler Glasnow or Austin Meadows, reverse engineered. Winning organizations solve problems with top prospects. They don’t create them.

This falls on the shoulders of John Baker, Pittsburgh’s new director of coaching and player development, as well as a bunch of others — from minor league managers, to pitching and hitting coordinators, to those involved in sports performance or scouting/informatics.

Advertise with us

Remember what happened when the Pirates made the playoffs three consecutive years. Players came to Pittsburgh and got better. When that spigot turned off, the wins and playoff appearances stopped. There remains no rule prohibiting the Pirates from pouncing on another team’s inability to figure out a prospect or seeing value where others don’t, like so many successful MLB franchises — in all markets — are able to do.

“The second thing those teams seem to be doing is that players are getting better,” Cherington said. “They’re reaching another level of performance, whether that’s a major league player or a minor league player. They’re adding value, adding wins to the organization just by helping players get better.”

The third item on Cherington’s list may cause some consternation, but it’s a narrative the Pirates have created and will ultimately and eventually have to change — spending to add the necessary pieces, on or around the time this talent is properly developed.

Again, remember the Pirates’ last brush with success. They added players like Marlon Byrd, Justin Morneau and Joakim Soria. They extended guys like Andrew McCutchen, Gregory Polanco, Josh Harrison, Francisco Cervelli and others.

Many point to the signing of Russell Martin as the deal that kick-started those playoff runs, but it should be fairly obvious that this Pirates team is not yet at that point where doing something like that makes sense.

Advertise with us

“The better we do [the first two things], the faster we’ll get to that point,” Cherington said. “We’ll be excited for that day, but we’re excited now to be at the point we’re at now.”

While the fan sentiment there is definitely not mutual, Cherington said that’s another important part of the equation here. Along with acquiring talent and developing players, it’s imperative for the Pirates to explain those processes, so those following the team can be just as excited as the people running it.

The upcoming season will also matter for more tangible improvement, Cherington argued. Bounce-back years from certain players, sure. But also progress among prospects, better coaching and improved execution with something as simple as converting solid positioning into ground-ball outs or cutting down on the number of walks Pirates pitchers issued.

Those final two things are important now and for infinity, no matter how many talented young players the Pirates are able to find or acquire. They will likely be made easier as prospects develop, too. Then, it’ll be time to focus more on the major league, growing the payroll.

“Whatever improvement we’ve seen in our overall organizational talent — and I think we have seen some improvements in the last year — it’s not enough,” Cherington said. “We’ve got to keep going. We’ve got to be one of the stronger organizations just in terms of overall talent to give ourselves the best chance to win.

Advertise with us

“We also have to help that talent improve. The better we do those two things and the faster we do those two things, the faster we’ll be able to start adding players back in a way where it’s like, ‘Hey, it’s time.’ I want to get to that as soon as we possibly can.”

Jason Mackey: jmackey@post-gazette.com and Twitter @JMackeyPG.