As part of the recent trade that sent third baseman Nolan Arenado — an eight-time Gold Glove winner and the position player with the third-most Wins Above Replacement (WAR) since 2014 according to Baseball Reference — from Colorado to St. Louis, the Rockies agreed to pay the Cardinals around $50 million.
Meanwhile, Trevor Bauer will earn $40 million this season to pitch for the Los Angeles Dodgers, a team that Spotrac.com projects to have a 26-man payroll of $225,775,000, the highest in Major League Baseball. That's more than three teams, according to the same site, including the Pirates' paltry $30,005,000.
It marks the first time since 1998 that one player (Gary Sheffield, $14.9 million) will make more than Pittsburgh's entire team ($13.7 million), and it’s perhaps the most egregious example yet of baseball’s flawed financial structure.
As MLB finds itself no higher than third among the most popular North American team sports, bypassed by the NFL and NBA (plus the NHL in plenty of cities), it's a major buzzkill when it comes to fans of teams like the Pirates — situated in smaller markets, with owners that either can’t or won’t spend on the same sort of level.
Bauer’s contract is great for him, the result of the right-hander winning the 2021 National League Cy Young award, but it’s depressing for so many other clubs, the ones who will enter this upcoming season with scant hope of actually competing.
Remember, too, that the Dodgers are the same team that signed outfielder Mookie Betts to a 12-year, $365 million extension before the 2020 season, the one whose average opening day salary during a seven-year stretch from 2013 to 2019 ($175.5 million) was actually more than double what the Pirates ($84.9 million) spent.
Read More
What the Dodgers have done certainly isn’t illegal. They have a lucrative television contract that dwarfs that of the Pirates, the exact number of which is not exactly known. They’re playing by the rules. It’s just that the rules don’t mean the same thing for all clubs, and their unevenness create a frustrating cycle for fans.
Figure while the Dodgers bought Bauer, the Pirates’ biggest free-agent signing to this point was left-handed reliever Chasen Shreve, signed Sunday to an incentive-laden deal that could pay him as much as $1.5 million in 2021, if he makes the major league club.
Bauer, meanwhile, will earn more than $1 million per start.
Pirates fans have no problem blaming owner Bob Nutting for the stark disparity, and the vitriol is certainly understandable. Nutting and the Pirates should spend more on the major league product, although Pittsburgh’s most competitive strategy right now does not call for spending much (or any) money.
The best thing they can do is strip it down to the studs, build through the draft and via international signings because they’re cheaper, coming out on the other side with a bunch of talented young players before they hit their prime earning years. Once the competitive window has opened, then it would be time to spend.
That might make sense to you, but try explaining that sort of thing to a 7-year-old. Or a grandfather who used to sneak into games at Forbes Field who worries about seeing the other end of another rebuild.
Establishing a salary-cap floor and ceiling would improve competitive balance. It would harness some of the obscene spending that has occurred of late, where a dozen players are expected to make $30 million or more in 2021, and it would also force teams like the Pirates to put a better (OK, more appropriately compensated) product on the field.
If Nutting can’t or won’t do that, he simply shouldn’t own a team. It would be like walking into Morton’s, trying to order dinner and asking the waiter what you could get for $15. Morton’s isn’t for everyone. There’s no crime in eating somewhere else.
But this is an issue, now, that’s bigger than Nutting’s wallet — and save the jokes about how most things are.
Baseball’s lack of salary cap might work for the upper crust, but it doesn’t do enough for all involved or the sport as a whole. And if you think about it, isn’t that the social or societal responsibility here? Shouldn’t baseball be worried about perpetuating itself and making it possible for that 7-year-old to identify and cheer for his or her favorite player, instead of being force-fed the inequities of baseball’s business side?
Yeah, thought so.
Fans follow the NFL because teams like the Tampa Bay Buccaneers can go from 7-9 to Super Bowl champions in one season. Make smart moves. Draft well. It’s not insane to think your fortunes could change. The immediacy there forces fans to stay involved, to keep a sliver of hope.
In baseball, hope is harder to find. If your team stinks and your owner can’t/won’t spend, fans are forced to endure what we’re seeing out of the Pirates: controlled costs and promises of better days ahead once prospects develop … but with the ominous understanding that bloated salaries could restart the cycle.
Those lean years do nothing to grow the sport. They turn fans away, while too many failed five-year plans will keep them there, ticked off.
The only hope — and this should never, ever happen — is to hope baseball stops. That when the current collective bargaining agreement expires in December, a protracted labor fight ensues, perhaps even a strike.
Maybe then, both sides will realize the short-term gain (and gross inequality) is not what's best for the future of the sport. Especially when capped leagues have zoomed past baseball in terms of national interest.
Jason Mackey: jmackey@post-gazette.com and Twitter @JMackeyPG.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.