While it will never top the franchise-altering period of time that preceded it — with a new president, general manager and manager taking charge and the seeds of a rebuild finally finding their soil — this Pirates offseason has hardly been boring.
Trades for Joe Musgrove and Josh Bell are two of the more recent marking points on a four-month stretch that has also included international and Rule 5 signings, a roster purge and significant alterations to how Pirates players are developed.
With a little more than three weeks until pitchers and catchers report to Pirate City in Bradenton, Fla., it’s also worth mentioning that several important tasks remain.
Meeting with the media earlier this week, general manager Ben Cherington repeated what he’s said a couple times already this offseason — that the Pirates would like to add to their roster, specifically within the starting rotation. That makes sense. The five players who currently occupy those spots combined for just 158 innings in 2020.
The Pirates could also use some help/depth at first base and in the outfield, while it remains highly unlikely that Adam Frazier — and his $4.3 million salary — will be standing at second base on opening day.
So, what’s left for the Pirates? Let’s take a look.
Read More
Add some pitching
This should be a priority. If you look at their rotation after they designated Trevor Williams for assignment, traded Musgrove and declined to pick up Chris Archer’s option, it’s extremely thin.
Right now it sketches out like this: Jameson Taillon, Mitch Keller, Chad Kuhl, Steven Brault and JT Brubaker. Taillon has had Tommy John surgery twice. Keller has logged 69 2/3 career innings. Kuhl (Tommy John) and Brubaker (right elbow strain) missed all or most of 2019 with injuries, while Brault has battled left-shoulder issues each of the past two seasons. Their next-best option is Cody Ponce, who has a whopping three starts and 17 innings on his MLB resume.
The Pirates’ long-term goals do not include throwing a bunch of money after the present (obviously); they believe they’re better served prioritizing high draft picks, even if they can’t explicitly say that. Still, somebody has to pitch. Nobody wants this to turn into a joke, and what Cherington will do in this lane can actually help the accumulation of prospects.
Sign a veteran. Help him produce. Flip him at the deadline.
“Yeah, it is something we think about,” Cherington said of that particular strategy. “Players are really smart and certainly free agents are really smart. They know what's going on. They know if they sign and for whatever reason, the team is not in contention at the deadline and they're performing well, it probably means their names come up in a trade. I think most guys are prepared for that, and we're honest about it. There's no reason to hide that. So, yes, we consider that.”
Some names to know
That’s the tough part here. The Pirates spend so little in free agency and there are so many pitchers available that predicting anything can be a fool’s errant. Think about it: Did you have Jarrod Dyson or Derek Holland on your big board last year? What about Jordan Lyles in 2019? Likely not.
Nevertheless, it is possible to identify players who fit what the Pirates are trying to do — cheap adds who may be primed for a strong first half and a trade out of town. Here are a few when it comes to the pitching side of things:
Mike Foltynewicz — An All-Star in 2018, finished eighth in NL Cy Young voting after pitching to a 2.85 ERA with 202 strikeouts in 183 innings. Had a lousy start (6.37 ERA in first 11 starts) in 2019 but a strong finish (2.65 ERA in final 10). The velocity issues that plagued Foltynewicz in 2020 were weird. They’re also not insignificant. But if the Pirates thought he was healthy and they could help him, he could be a cheap gamble.
Collin McHugh — Signed with the Red Sox for an incentive-laden deal starting at just $600,000 before opting out of the 2020 season to rehab an elbow injury. He was outstanding with the Astros as a reliever in 2018 — 1.99 ERA, 94 strikeouts, 21 walks and a .176 batting average against in 72 1/3 innings — but could want the chance to start. Career ERA of 3.95 doesn’t stink.
Rick Porcello — There’s history with Cherington dating back to the pitcher’s time in Boston. And say this about the right-hander: He’s been durable, averaging 29.25 starts over his 12 big-league seasons. Porcello signed with the Mets for one-year, $10 million in 2020 and had a 5.64 ERA in 12 starts. Which means he might actually be affordable.
Chris Archer — Wait, no, really? Yes. But depending on the price. Archer for $11 million, no. Archer for $4-$6 million? Maybe, if he’s healthy. But the Pirates should have plenty of good intel there. Now much more current with their approach, Pittsburgh’s revamped pitching program might help rather than hinder Archer.
Julio Teheran — Made 30 or more starts in seven consecutive seasons from 2013-19. Two-time All-Star. Career ERA of 3.81. So why in the world would he fit here? Teheran went bust in 2020, to the tune of a 10.05 ERA in 10 games (nine starts) with the Angels after signing for one year, $9 million deal. Teheran was terrific in Atlanta. Someone will give him a chance.
Adding other positions
Cherington said in his last Zoom call that the Pirates would like to add a depth outfielder along with a starting pitcher or two. It’s hard to argue with that logic — they went 19-41 last season; they could stand to add almost anything — but they could also use some depth at first base.
Beyond Colin Moran, who only switched across the diamond full-time last summer, the Pirates’ most experienced first baseman who has a realistic chance of playing is probably Phillip Evans. He’s spent precisely 13 innings at the position throughout his career.
One intriguing first-base possibility that has been floated is Mitch Moreland, and it’s hard to not like the idea of Moreland coming to Pittsburgh as a first base/designated hitter hybrid. Moreland’s outfield days are long gone, but his .894 OPS in 2020 would certainly receive a warm welcome at PNC Park.
The question is whether Moreland would want to come here when he’s sure to have other, better offers. He also would not address the outfield issue.
As far as true outfielders, there are several who could fit the Pirates’ profile, including Delino DeShields, Tyler Naquin and Ben Gamel. None is older than 30. They were all reasonably productive in 2020 and are types that could probably make good on actually getting regular reps.
A non-traditional add could be someone like Brad Miller, who would fit more in left or right or double as a backup at first base. Miller, who’s done everything on the diamond but pitch and catch, is coming off a year where he had an OPS of .807 and .894 the season before that — which could mean he gets a better opportunity elsewhere.
Are they done with trades?
Very likely not. Again, the possibility of keeping Frazier is incongruent with everything else they’ve done. Cherington has talked about years of control mattering, and Frazier is no different than Musgrove and Bell with that stuff. He’s also a two-time Gold Glove finalist.
The Pirates are also clearly in the evaluative stage, and it makes zero sense to allocate innings and reps to someone who obviously has no future here. Put another way, if they trade Frazier, they could move Kevin Newman to second base and see what they have in Cole Tucker.
It also makes sense for the Pirates to continue to listen on Jameson Taillon. If there’s an enticing offer, perhaps they go for it. But the Pirates shouldn’t just take anything that comes along. Taillon could improve his value a lot with a strong first half.
Minor league questions
This absolutely matters for a team like the Pirates. It’s also real because, as of now, their Class AA affiliate in Altoona technically doesn’t have a manager.
Then again, the club also doesn’t have a schedule, a plan for spring training or a finalized Professional Development License, the agreement minor league clubs must sign by Feb. 10. (If it’s final, that news is not yet public.)
So while the Pirates brace for spring training, there’s a ripple effect at play here. Cherington said he expects minor-league spring training to follow the major-league version, which will obviously delay that season. How much? Remains to be seen.
It’s also tough to predict what a lost year will do for the Pirates and their prospects in 2021. One example: Oneil Cruz was extremely inconsistent in 2019 and needed more Class AA seasoning in 2020.
Obviously Cruz did not get that and will either start with Altoona again in 2021 or with Class AAA Indianapolis and needing some extra work before jumping to the majors. Delays in the season will only hinder his development and that of many others.
Jason Mackey: jmackey@post-gazette.com and Twitter @JMackeyPG.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.