From Barry Bonds to Gerrit Cole and every Jose Bautista in between, recent history is replete with examples of big names leaving the Pirates through some combination of cheapness or failures on the scouting and development levels.

That earned reputation of not holding onto many of their best young players tends to obscure the fact that the Pirates have been aggressive at times in locking up useful players long before they reach free agency. The goal, typically, is to persuade players to sign for less than market value by offering still-substantial guaranteed paydays before those players have proven much at the big-league level.

It’s for that reason that their reported interest in signing players such as Kevin Newman and Bryan Reynolds to long-term deals isn’t totally without recent precedent. Their results in those endeavors, however, have been mixed.

Andrew McCutchen’s six-year, $51.5 million extension with the club in 2012 remains the gold standard. The deal bought out all of the outfielder’s arbitration years and some of his free agent years at a time that the price of a win above replacement on the free agent market was roughly $6.2 million, according to Fangraphs.

Advertise with us

McCutchen went on to produce 33.5 WAR for the Pirates and 36.2 WAR over the entire life of the deal, which included his stints with San Francisco and the New York Yankees in 2018. That means his real value ended up finishing at around $207 million for the Pirates and $224 million overall. It was a massive bargain for the small-market team before you even consider that McCutchen was the heart of the first playoff appearances in 20 years from 2013-15.

They had similar luck with the recently departed Starling Marte. His six-year, $31 million deal in 2014 paid off almost immediately. His 4.5 WAR that season alone would have been worth about $34 million in a free agent market that paid roughly $7.7 million per WAR. The total value of the Pirates phase of his career ended up at about $151 million before he was traded to Arizona this winter, and his performance in an option year in 2020 seems likely to only add to that surplus value.

Former general manager Neal Huntington, however, certainly produced his share of misses in this department as well.

Remember Jose Tabata? He signed a six-year extension worth a guaranteed $14.75 million in 2011. The deal also included some option years for which the Pirates fruitlessly paid a premium. After a solid rookie year in 2011 in which the outfielder produced 1.7 WAR, Tabata was worth just 0.4 WAR for the rest of his career.

Current outfielder Gregory Polanco has been a kind of a bust, too. His five-year extension in 2016 was worth a guaranteed $35 million with options. That year’s free agent market priced 1.0 WAR at about $10.2 million, so his 5.1 WAR has produced some $17 million in surplus value. But that’s not nearly as much as the Pirates were hoping for when they struck the deal.

Advertise with us

Nate McLouth’s pact with the club in 2009 is probably the most interesting to look back in the context of the present-day reports.

The outfielder signed in February of that year for three years and $15.75 million guaranteed after a breakout 2008 in which he hit 26 homers and made the National League All-Star team. He was gone by early June, traded to Atlanta for future rotation pitchers Charlie Morton and Jeff Locke and outfielder Gorkys Hernandez.

The deal, which jolted a fan base that expected McLouth to be a long-term staple, ended up being a financial dud for the Braves. He produced just 1.8 WAR, which translated to $11.2 million in WAR value, meaning he was slightly overpaid.

Fortunately for the Pirates, they were able to off-load him near the peak of his value and turn two of the players they acquired into All-Stars who locked down spots on a playoff-caliber pitching staff.

Reynolds, in particular, has a similar profile. His breakout in 2019 was unexpected — he didn’t even make the Opening Day roster. And his production, while noteworthy, wasn’t exactly overwhelming either.

Advertise with us

An extension with him could give the Pirates options moving forward. They could keep him with an eye toward building the next playoff-contending team around him. But trade partners also love two things: cost certainty and the appearance of upside. A long-term pact could offer both to a team willing to put together the right package.

Now, like then, the Pirates seem to be at least a year or two from seriously competing. Flexibility is important, so if these deals come to pass, general manager Ben Cherington will presumably have some, the final dollars and cents being the biggest possible caveat.

Still, extensions will always be an inexact science. If history tells us anything, there will be hits, misses and maybe a few unexpected turns along the way.

Adam Bittner: abittner@post-gazette.com and Twitter @fugimaster24.