NORTH PORT, Fla. — Major League Baseball commissioner Rob Manfred met with reporters Sunday at CoolToday Park — the spring training home of the Atlanta Braves — and took questions for nearly 30 minutes, almost all of them about the sign-stealing scandal that has rocked the baseball world.
It’s about to get worse, too, as Manfred said he expects to have his investigation into the 2018 Boston Red Sox completed by the end of next week.
Until then, the focus has been on the Astros — how MLB learned they cheated, what exactly they did, if they should lose their 2017 World Series rings and what will be done in the future to prevent this from happening again.
Pittsburgh Post-Gazette baseball writers Jason Mackey and Nubyjas Wilborn attended the event, which kicked off Grapefruit League Media Day. Below, they debate some of what Manfred said.
Topic: Despite evidence the Astros may have worn pitch-signaling buzzers in 2019, Manfred said players — who were granted immunity in exchange for honest testimony — were universally adamant such claims were false.
“It was hard for me to figure out why, when they were immune, they would be truthful and admit they did the wrong thing in 2017 and 2018 and lie about what was going on in 2019,” Manfred said. “Can I tell you I’m 100% sure about that? You’re never 100% sure of any of these things, but that was my best judgement.”
Read More
Is Manfred missing the mark here?
Mackey: There was no logical reason for Jose Altuve to keep his shirt on. I’m sorry. I’m not buying his absurd excuses. I see what Manfred is saying, but I don’t agree with him. The players had to come clean because of Mike Fiers. There was no such thing for 2019.
Wilborn: It feels like we won't know until somebody writes a Pete Rose-style, tell-all book 25 years from now. The players had an incentive to lie. They haven't shown remorse even with the immunity. The Astros players have given no reason to take them at their word. It's easy to believe they said just enough to get Manfred off their backs.
Topic: Manfred doesn’t believe it’s necessary to strip the Astros of their World Series title or take any additional after-the-fact action. Four well-respected baseball men lost their jobs, and nobody will look at that title the same anyway.
“Whether or not you use an asterisk or ask for the trophy back, I don’t think it makes that much difference,” Manfred said. “We did what we should do. We found the facts, and we were transparent about ‘em. Once you go down that road of changing what happens on the field, I just don’t know how you decide where you stop.”
Should MLB take additional action to set the record straight?
Mackey: I’m not a fan of “vacating” championships. Seems pointless. What’s done is done. People will form their own opinions. Plus, I don’t like that guys who had nothing to do with this whole mess — Colin Moran and Joe Musgrove, for instance — would wind up getting punished for something they could not have reasonably stopped.
Wilborn: Taking away the World Series won't change the fact that the Astros won. Sure, you can make the Los Angeles Dodgers the winner, but it doesn't change that the Astros won. Maybe they can put an asterisk in the record book, but we all know the title is tainted. There's not much else baseball can do.
Topic: The steps taken in 2018 and 2019 offered a great start and, combined with some changes for 2020, will be enough to prevent teams from trying this again, Manfred seemed to say.
“I do expect that we will, for 2020, have really serious restrictions on player and playing personnel accessing video in-game,” Manfred said. “I think it’s really important for us to send a message to our fans that not only did we investigate and punish, but we altered our policies in a way that will help make sure it doesn’t happen again.”
Will this be enough to deter teams and players from cheating?
Mackey: I actually think so, at least for a little bit. You would have to be pretty brazen — no, nuts — to try and do something now. However, over time, banging a trash will turn into something else. As long as baseball has been around, someone has been trying to get an advantage.
Wilborn: No. However, it isn't Manfred's fault. Three seconds after athletic competition got invented, there was probably someone trying to find ways to circumvent the rules. It can be corked bats, amphetamines, spitballs, steroids or sign stealing. There is a lot on the line, and someone will always try to cheat.
Topic: Players have been bashing one another over this whole thing. Pirates MLBPA union representative Jameson Taillon said he’s OK with it, so long as they work together to fix this for the future, but Manfred isn’t a huge fan of all the bickering.
“I’m sort of a civil-discourse person,” Manfred said. “It must be because I’m old. The back-and-forth that’s gone on is not healthy.”
Are players wrong for expressing their opinions with this stuff?
Mackey: I can’t fault them. If I was in their shoes, I’d have a tough time holding back. I hope this doesn’t negatively affect their ability to unite whenever it comes to labor issues (and I don’t think it will), but I would have a tough time telling an adult that he or she can’t express an opinion.
Wilborn: It's healthy for now. Players are angry and should be able to express their thoughts. There will come the point when its time to move on. It isn't now. Also, the Astros haven't done themselves any favors in this.
Topic: Manfred also worries about this turning into a bean-ball war that lasts the entire season. Before his press conference he met with the Grapefruit League’s 15 managers about this very thing and will hit the other 15 when he visits the Cactus League teams in two days.
“I hope that I made extremely clear to them that retaliation in-game by throwing at a batter intentionally will not be tolerated, whether it’s Houston or anybody else,” Manfred said. “It’s dangerous. It is not helpful to the current situation.”
Will MLB actually be able to police this?
Mackey: I don’t see how. If you’re, say, the Texas Rangers and you want to drill Altuve or Alex Bregman or whomever, obviously you’re not going to do it early. But what, is every plunked Astros player going to trigger some sort of suspension or warning? That might be kind of onerous.
Wilborn: Yes, but they'll have to dole out a lot of lengthy suspensions. The most effective way to threaten athletes is by taking away their playing time. Players won't risk missing games to get vengeance.
Topic: There’s one school of thought that says the players should not have been granted immunity, while Manfred said it was essential to properly finding all the facts.
As part of his argument that the current punishment is extensive enough, Manfred said, “I don’t think there’s a player in Major League Baseball who relishes the idea of being a 2017 Houston Astro and answering questions about exactly what happened and why it happened.”
Did MLB come down harshly enough on the Astros?
Mackey: I see why Manfred needed to grant the players immunity; there’s no way MLB could’ve taken what Fiers provided and corroborated it to the extent that it did without immunity. But I think because of immunity, we can always say baseball didn’t come down hard enough. Still, I don’t know what else baseball could’ve done here.
Wilborn: No, the punishments weren't enough. Players don't want to lose money or playing time. The sanctions did neither. Other athletes will try to cheat at some point because there isn't a deterrent that works on ballplayers.
Jason Mackey: jmackey@post-gazette.com and Twitter @JMackeyPG.
Nubyjas Wilborn: nwilborn@post-gazette.com and Twitter @nwilborn19.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.