BRADENTON, Fla. — When Jameson Taillon heard Major League Baseball was thinking about tweaking its postseason format, the Pirates union representative’s knee-jerk reaction was to celebrate the additional opportunity it might provide for his fellow players.

But as Taillon thought about it more, other things began to pop into his head. Like how maybe some teams might take the lowered bar as an excuse to spend less money. Or, on a more positive note, Taillon began thinking about the idea of a team picking its opponent and all of the effort (and fun) that would conceivably go into that.

“I think it would be cool to understand why a team calls someone out,” Taillon said. “It’s not personal. It’s not like, ‘Hey, we want to fight you.’ There are matchups involved. There are career numbers. There’s history. There are a lot of things that would go into a decision like that. Even their park — hitters’ park, pitchers’ park, what kind of style do you have?

“I think that part of it is kind of fun. At least it would get people talking.”

Advertise with us

The proposal to go from 10 to 14 teams and to have twice as many wild cards in each league definitely got people talking, especially the part where two of the three division winners would get to pick their playoff opponent. But not all of the discussion was positive.

Next door inside the clubhouse at Pirate City, Joe Musgrove had a vastly different opinion of the proposed plan: He hated it.

“That doesn’t make much sense to me,” Musgrove said. “I don’t know what [MLB commissioner Rob Manfred] is trying to get out of it, if he thinks that’s going to be more exciting. The effort and work that you put in throughout the course of the year, it creates the advantage you have in the playoffs. You work your [butt] off to get that No. 1 seed and get a bye. You get an easier path to the championship.

“I don’t find it very fair or exciting that teams get to pick who they want to play.”

Musgrove, however, was OK with the first part of expanding the postseason field — which, in this case, would include a best-of-three wild-card round, with the bottom three wild cards not receiving any home games.

Advertise with us

The proposal certainly seems like a long shot. MLPBA president Tony Clark said he was in favor of expanding the playoffs, although this was the first he had heard of this particular proposal — one of several being considered.

Major League Baseball is tinkering with its playoff structure to try and attract a younger audience. The thinking is that it’s almost like a reality TV show, where the selections would be revealed live, and that the entire thing was weird enough that it might get watched.

“Higher seeds deserve to have the better path if you win more games,” Taillon said. “I don’t know if that’s through calling a team out or just getting a first-round bye, but it’s interesting.”

One unintended consequence could be what Taillon mentioned. Teams who would otherwise spend a decent chunk of money might figure that extra little bit is useless considering how many make the postseason and simply pocket those dollars.

However, by expanding, baseball would simply be mimicking the playoff processes of the other major North American professional team sports. Sixteen of 30 teams make the NBA playoffs, while it’s 16 of 31 in the NHL. The NFL admits 12 of 32, although that’s also likely to increase.

Advertise with us

“My knee-jerk reaction was like, ‘Oh, good. Maybe more teams will have offseasons like the White Sox, where they think they can get in, they push and go sign a guy or two,’” Taillon said. “But then I kind of thought about it a little more. I thought, ‘OK, if I’m the Dodgers, Yankees’ ...

“Not saying they would do it because they obviously have the goal of winning a World Series, but they could also cut costs and still make the playoffs. I’m worried teams will try to cut costs.”

Musgrove’s concerns are a little different. He’s worried that a World Series might feel cheap or not earned the hard way if one team happens to miss another because of this wacky selection process. The Pirates pitcher is more for the traditional way of doing things.

“Adding two more teams would give more teams opportunities to play in the playoffs,” Musgrove said. “It gets guys more bonuses. That’s cool. But winning a World Series is not easy to do.”

Certainly not. And it could get more difficult if this plan is approved.

Jason Mackey: jmackey@post-gazette.com and Twitter @JMackeyPG.