So are the Pirates going to tear this sucker down to start building it back up again? Or are they going to take another serious run at competing with a similar cast of characters to the one that’s missed the playoffs the past four seasons and limped to a 69-93 finish in 2019?

Those questions have dominated an offseason that’s offered few answers. Outside of the changes in the front office and on the coaching staff, there have been no big acquisitions, nor prominent departures of players under contract. It feels a lot like limbo. Particularly when new manager Derek Shelton is addressing the lack of moves like this.

“One of the things [general manager] Ben [Cherington] said when he took the job is that we were going to identify what we have,” Shelton told the Post-Gazette’s Jason Mackey on Wednesday. “For us to do that, we have to take our time, and we have to see players on the field. We have to work off that.”

Frustrating if you just want this club to get on with whatever it’s going to do already. That type of patience isn’t without fairly recent precedent though. When Neal Huntington, Cherington’s predecessor as GM, took the job in late 2007, the eventual seismic shifts were far from immediate, too.

Advertise with us

“The fact is, we haven't been presented with an organizational-changing trade,” he told the Post-Gazette in January of 2008.

So he didn’t force one for the sake of doing it.

Seven of the eight position players in the 2008 Opening Day lineup played in at least 125 games for the club the year prior. The eighth was catcher Ryan Doumit, who played in 83 games in 2007, so he was far from a stranger.

In the rotation, Paul Maholm, Zach Duke, Ian Snell and Tom Gorzelanny formed the core in both seasons, starting at least 19 games each in ‘07 and ‘08.

And on the departure/acquisition front, little of consequence transpired in the winter between the two campaigns. Infielders Jose Castillo and Cesar Izturis left. Infielders Doug Mientkiewicz, Luis Rivas and Chris Gomez replaced them, while Jason Michaels joined the outfield rotation. Big whoop.

Advertise with us

"It's always a balance between patience and aggressiveness, and short and long term,” he said once the season was underway in April. “We need to continue to think about how we build this thing going forward, all the things we've talked about in the offseason and how we hold those standards high. But we need to do that without making knee-jerk reactions."

And so, it wasn’t until the MLB trade deadline loomed in July of that year the blockbusters began happening. By the morning of the 25th, the Pirates were 48-55 and sputtering. The pitching couldn’t keep pace with a competent offense, and the club was 12 games back in the NL Central.

For all intents and purposes, the season was over, so Huntington finally saw fit to change the paradigm and add some younger talent for the future.

He acted that evening by sending outfielder Xavier Nady and reliever Damaso Marte to the New York Yankees for a raft of prospects. A week later, he shipped star outfielder Jason Bay to Boston in a three-team trade that netted four more young players and put an exclamation point on the message: Huntington was starting over, though it took a full 10 months after he accepted the job to come to a conclusion to truly head in that direction.

And even once he’d reached it, the ensuing sell off didn’t happen all at once. Over the course of the following year:

Advertise with us

● Outfielder Nate McLouth was traded to the Atlanta Braves for three minor leaguers in early June of 2009 in what was considered something of a surprise move.

● A little less than a month later, fellow outfielder Nyjer Morgan and reliever Sean Burnett were dealt to Washington for a package that included future closer Joel Hanrahan.

●Then at the trade deadline in late July, fan favorites Freddy Sanchez and Jack Wilson were sent to San Francisco and Seattle, respectively, for prospects. Sanchez had received a contract extension just a year earlier.

It had been almost two years since Huntington took the job by that point. Only then did the demolition process look somewhat complete and the build toward three playoff bids at mid-decade begin in earnest.

Not all of the trades worked out. Not by a long shot. Little of long-term value came from the Bay, Wilson or Sanchez deals. The Nady, McLouth and Morgan swaps, though? They ended up looking pretty good, producing Hanrahan, Jeff Locke, Charlie Morton and Jeff Karstens, who all played for playoff teams.

Advertise with us

Such is the nature of overhauls. There will be hits. There will be misses.

If there’s one thing we can learn from all of the moves in that period of team history, it’s that change isn’t as simple as hitting a plunger. Time for evaluation — both of the existing team and availability of useful players on the trade and free agent markets — can yield better returns and reveal assets worth keeping around for the long haul. A rebuilding process is just that: a process. Not something that comes together overnight.

And, hey, maybe the 2020 Pirates will surprise all of us and compete seriously for something. They posted a winning record as recently as 2018 and were within spitting distance of first place for a good portion of last season. If they can get off to a good start come April, perhaps Cherington will prefer to add to his roster than start over by subtracting from it.

But even if things go as expected and the team struggles again, history tells us not to expect too much, too soon. Deciding to rebuild is one thing. Doing it is another matter entirely.

Adam Bittner: abittner@post-gazette.com and Twitter @fugimaster24.