Hello and happy new year to everyone. It's been a busy offseason as the Pirates have overhauled their coaching staff and front office. But of course, fans have concerns about the lack of free agent signings. Other than a few minor additions, it's been mostly quiet.

The silence has fans asking questions, and we're going to do our best to answer them in this mailbag.

One of the signings the Pirates made was catcher Luke Maile, formerly with the Toronto Blue Jays. The 28-year-old hit .151 in 44 games and had an OPS of .440 last season. As of now, the Pirates expect to pair him with Jacob Stallings, who hit .262 with six homers in 2019.

This leads us to our first question.

Advertise with us

Jeff Koontz @JefferyKoontzx: Are they going into 2020 opening day with just Stallings and Maile?

Nubyjas Wilborn: It appears so. And I understand the concern. The Pirates hope that the improvement Stallings showed as a hitter will continue in 2020. The Pirates also hope that Maile returns to being more like his 2018 season, when he hit .248 and had a solid OPS of .700 in 68 games and a 2.1 WAR. Pirates hitters did get better under hitting coach Rick Eckstein.

Maile could become a respectable hitter again, and both catchers are reliable defensively. In summary, it isn't sexy on paper, but it could work.

Scott Briceland @sbriceland920: What are the Pirates plans for a starting rotation in 2020? What are they going to do to get (Chris) Archer & (Joe) Musgrove become productive 3 & 4 starters?

Wilborn: If they don't sign anyone, the Pirates will be looking at Musgrove, Archer, Trevor Williams, Mitch Keller, and maybe Chad Kuhl or Steven Brault. New pitcher coach Oscar Marin will lead the charge in helping the Pirate starters get better. We spoke to Marin about his approach to pitching, and it seems like the Pirates will take a more modern strategy into how they attack hitters. The new regime believes there is internal talent that can get better with new methods. Also, Musgrove and Archer entered last season coming off surgeries. Both are having healthy offseasons. Improved health alone will make each of them better.

Advertise with us

Dane Brody @danebrody: Do we move Josh Bell, or build around him and (Bryan) Reynolds? Is Cole Tucker an everyday SS, average to above average?

Wilborn: I wouldn't trade Bell. I'd build around him and the young core that includes Reynolds and Kevin Newman. Tucker is capable of being an everyday shortstop, but the Pirates are loaded with middle infielders. Tucker will have to earn playing time after Newman's breakout season. And don't forget about Erik Gonzalez.

Thomas Smith: I love your work on the Pirates beat. You've seen a lot during your first season. What sticks out the most?

Wilborn: Where do I start? I could write a book about the 2019 season. But let's look into three moments, starting at Wrigley Field after the All-Star break, when the Pirates got swept by the Cubs.

The team entered that series 2.5 games out of first place. By the end of the series, they were 5.5 games out and never got closer. There are about 40 steps from the visitors dugout to the clubhouse at Wrigley. Watching the players trod up the steps while feeling the stadium shake was an eerie feeling. There was such sadness in the clubhouse. The season was over at that point.

Advertise with us

San Francisco is where the Kyle Crick and Felipe Vazquez fight happened. It felt like rock bottom for the organization. The altercation was the third between members of the team and the second involving Crick. It was embarrassing all around and it was the first time I started to think that the Pirates would move on from Hurdle. It was clear that his message had worn thin and a change needed to be made.

And finally, the Vazquez arrest. Vazquez was arguably the best closer in baseball and was the most valuable trade chip for the Pirates. Vazquez's arrest for allegedly soliciting a child for sexual acts sent shock waves across the sport. It was shocking for everyone around the team. Vaszquez was a respected clubhouse leader, and now he's in jail under some vile accusations.

Dale Walker: Do you have a Hall of Fame vote? If so, what does your ballot look like?

Wilborn: I am a few years away from being a BBWAA voter. However, if I had a ballot, I'd vote for: Barry Bonds, Roger Clemens, Derek Jeter, Andruw Jones, Larry Walker, Manny Ramirez, and Curt Schilling.

Bonds and Clemens were the best of their era. Yeah, I know, PEDs and all. But they were the best and would've been all-time greats with or without steroids.

Advertise with us

Jones is the best defensive outfielder I've seen in my lifetime. Jeter will likely be in with 100% of the vote. I think Jeter is a bit overrated, but he was the star of some great Yankee teams.

Walker should already be in the Hall. He was a seven-time Gold Glove winner and put up incredible numbers as a hitter.

Ramirez got popped for PEDs twice. A lot of my colleagues eliminate him for this alone. I don't. He was 37 when he got suspended in 2009, but he already had 527 home runs and a 66.5 WAR. Ramirez had the numbers before he got busted. I think that means he should be in. However, I understand why other voters wouldn't.

I'm not excited about Schilling's potential speech at Cooperstown, but he should be enshrined. His postseason numbers speak volumes. Schilling also posted 3,116 strikeouts, and if that's not enough, the 79.9 WAR seals it.