SAN DIEGO — Pretty much as expected, the Pirates made no major moves at Major League Baseball’s Winter Meetings, held this week at the Manchester Grand Hyatt.
They grabbed two minor-league pitchers — Hector Noesi and Alex Aquino, the latter in the Class AAA portion of the Rule 5 Draft on Thursday morning — but that was it.
However, the Winter Meetings were productive for the Pirates and instructive for those who follow them. Need proof? Here’s a look at 13 things we learned over the past four days.
1. At the top end, spending in Major League Baseball right now is nuts, the gulf between small- and big-market clubs larger than ever.
Stephen Strasburg got $245 million from the Nationals, Gerrit Cole got $324 million from the Yankees and Anthony Rendon inked a $245 million contract with the Angels.
Over three days, three Scott Boras clients pulled in $814 million worth of free agent deals. Combine every Opening Day payroll (per Baseball Prospectus) for the Pirates since Bob Nutting took over as owner, and you get $822 million.
Read More
Criticize the Pirates if you want. But baseball’s financial structure makes it really hard on fans of small-market teams, even the best ones.
2. Other clubs value Starling Marte and Adam Frazier. The Frazier interest helps, too, because the Pirates actually have some young talent in the infield.
Expect the talks general manager Ben Cherington started here to continue in Pittsburgh.
3. The effects of the Pirates’ late start to the offseason are real.
Give Cherington and others credit; they’re doing all they can. But there have been ramifications with player evaluation, composition of the coaching staff, how they want to do things with this new group, etc.
The Winter Meetings helped expedite that process.
“Ben and I are still getting to know the roster and getting to know the inner-workings of people,” manager Derek Shelton said. “To not only sit in the suite with them but also go to dinner with them and have some social time with them, it’s really nice.”
4. Shelton and Cherington both described what they’d like to see in a pitching coach, and fans should be encouraged by the traits those two are seeking.
Shelton described this person as “a relationship builder” and someone who “has advanced knowledge of how the game is played.” That includes data, tech and biomechanics — areas where the Pirates struggled under the old regime.
5. Spring training will be different.
Maybe that was assumed given everyone is new, but Shelton talked about his time in Minnesota and how the Twins jelled from the start. He’s looking for the same thing in his new role.
“It’s going to be a different spring training schedule than has been run in the past,” Shelton said. “It’s going to be a different culture than the past. So, it’s going to be an important time.”
6. The Pirates definitely want and need a major league catcher, and they’re also taking the scenic route.
On Thursday, they lost another guy who would’ve fit with them — Austin Romine, who signed with the Tigers.
Cherington said the Pirates want someone who’s strong defensively and handles pitchers well; any offense would be a bonus. Shelton said they simply want the best guy.
Both asks are reasonable, but the Pirates should probably get moving soon.
7. As they’ve learned more about their roster, Cherington and Shelton think the Pirates can pitch and hit much better than they did in 2019.
“We certainly hope so,” Cherington said, talking specifically about potential pitching improvements. “I think that will be an important goal.”
Cherington also thinks there may be some “untapped power” for the Pirates hitters. The Pirates tied for the best batting average (.265) in the National League this past season but ranked 10th out of 15 teams in OPS (.743).
“We’d like to increase power production, but there’s not a particular philosophical change to do that,” Cherington said. “You’ve got to go back to an individual basis. How can we put each guy in position where he can untap a little bit more power without losing his strengths? Sometimes, that’s physical. Sometimes, it’s a mindset or approach. Sometimes, it’s looking for certain pitches in certain counts. It can be all those things.”
8. This doesn’t matter whatsoever to the on-field product, but fans should like Cherington and Shelton the more they hear from them.
Cherington is very good at explaining processes and how he thinks about things. Speaks in normal-person terms, too. Shelton is laid-back and funny. Both should offer a refreshing change of pace.
9. Building off that, the perception of the Pirates has certainly changed. Boras said he expects “significant change” in Pittsburgh and for this new group to “provide a competent approach to winning.”
Many around the industry still want the Pirates to spend more, but as for the moves they’ve made this offseason, those have been received extremely well around the game.
10. This obviously could change given the trade market, but several sources here were skeptical the Pirates would do much in free agency before the January.
11. The Pirates are taking the right approach with potential trades — listening on everyone.
Cherington made sure to specify that it would make more sense to trade some guys than others, but they’re casting a wide net.
Good. See what’s out there. Maybe another team surprises you.
12. When he spoke for the first time this offseason, Nutting said he felt the Pirates had fallen behind with analytics — a broad term that covers a few things when it comes to information teams gather and analyze.
As a result, Nutting has authorized Cherington to make any necessary short-term adds and potentially change how the Pirates handle this stuff over the next year and beyond.
13. Rosters expanding to 26 players next season won’t change things a ton for the Pirates, but Shelton said he did appreciate having “another toy to play with.”
To maximize roster flexibility, Shelton said it will place even more importance on switch-hitters off the bench.
“I think switch-hitters are going to become gold in this market because of their ability to go back-and-forth,” Shelton said. “But I think it’s really going to matter who your personnel is.”





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.