SAN DIEGO — Major League Baseball’s Winter Meetings have been dominated by the predictable headlines — Stephen Strasburg, Gerrit Cole, Anthony Rendon, even the report on juiced balls or the shrinking of the minor leagues. Plenty has been discussed.
For the Pirates, however, it’s been pretty quiet. Sure, they’ve been getting to know one another better and have had plenty of conversations about players, both their own and external, but nothing they’ve done has generated a whole lot of buzz.
Well, except one thing: the possible trade of Starling Marte.
The Mets are reportedly the most aggressive, although they’re not alone. In return, the Pirates want talent, both in the major and minor leagues, potentially a catcher or outfielder to replace Marte, or both.
Aside from that, Marte’s comments from Thanksgiving have had reverberating effects. Both manager Derek Shelton and general manager Ben Cherington have been asked about Marte, and they’ve both actually given pretty good answers on the topic.
“I think you want to hear all of your players say, ‘Hey, we want to win,’ ” Shelton said Wednesday. “So don't look at that comment at all in any way that there should be anything made of it. He wants to win. That's good. I want to win, too. We're on the same page there.”
Read More
During his Wednesday session with reporters, Cherington talked about how he handles a player seeing his name pop up in trade talks.
These guys are professionals and they’re used to that sort of thing, but Cherington would be foolish if he didn’t address it right off the hop with guys he’s talking to for the first time, especially when he said publicly that they’re willing to listen on anybody.
“As I’ve talked to players this offseason,” Cherington said, “I’ve talked about, ‘Hey, we’re getting to know each other. You know how this works. Your name might get out there or a team might call and ask about you, etc. That’s just part of it. If you ever have a question about it, call me. If there’s ever a reason to communicate something, we will.’
“But there is a lot of stuff that gets out because teams are talking about all kinds of things. It doesn’t mean that there’s necessarily substance to anything.”
Cherington said he has had players in the past take him up on that offer. He also said he’s been more forthcoming with information regarding a player who’s a more likely trade chip. That has not been the case this offseason.
To mend fences, Shelton chatted with Marte on the phone about a week ago. Third-base coach Joey Cora happened to be around, and Shelton made sure to have Cora translate, so as to not have anything misconstrued because of a language barrier.
“It was a really good conversation,” Shelton said. “I was excited to get him.”
The Mets — or another team — might also be excited to get Marte, should they offer the Pirates what they’re looking for.
And given the Pirates’ situation — coming off a 69-win season and badly needing to add talent across the board — a very good case could be made for flipping Marte, who will make just $11.5 million this season and is under club control through 2021.
If the Pirates decide to move Marte, they would need to plug an outfield spot either via trade return or the free agent market. Brandon Nimmo has been mentioned as a possible piece coming back, and that would absolutely make sense for the Pirates.
He’s 26, is projected to make just $1.7 million via arbitration and won’t be eligible for free agency until after 2022. And while this past season was a rough one for Nimmo, in 2018 he had an OPS of .886 in 535 plate appearances, good enough for a 4.4 WAR, per baseball-reference.com.
If the Pirates got Nimmo, it’s likely they could look to move Bryan Reynolds to center field, the spot where Reynolds has played most of his life and somewhere he occasionally shined during his terrific rookie season.
Cherington previously said that Gregory Polanco should be good to go in right.
“We’d be comfortable playing [Reynolds] in center,” Cherington said. “I think it’ll depend on the roster and the makeup of the team. We think he’s a good player. Whether he’s playing on a corner or playing in center, we think he’ll be a good player and a big part of the team.”
All week, Cherington has mentioned potential adds he’d like to make — catching on Monday, infield or outfield on Tuesday and pitching Wednesday.
“We’re looking for more pitching at the major league level, as far as the 40-man roster and non-roster,” Cherington said. “We’ve pursued guys, we are pursuing guys [via] free agency and trades. We’d like to add more pitching before spring training. I think we will, in some form.”
Trading Marte would offer the clearest path to doing that. It would also allow the Pirates to feel like they’ve accomplished at least something tangible here at the Winter Meetings.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.