The commentary below contains opinion. The author’s name has been withheld at the writer’s request.
The Pirates have completely restructured the front office. There is a new team president, a new general manager and a new manager. There is a new philosophy, some newfangled modernized pitching philosophy, and a brand new culture in place now. It is clear that Bob Nutting wanted to go in a completely different direction, and he has done exactly that.
Now, Nutting needs to commit to going fully in a new direction and tear down the roster and begin the process of rebuilding it. Unfortunately, so far it sounds like this is going to be another offseason of making scrapheap acquisitions and trying to fool fans into believing the team has a real chance to be competitive.
We’ve seen that show too many times to be fooled again, though. This team isn’t a few players away. It isn’t a couple of young players maturing and reaching their potential away from contending. And the players that may be able to help the Pirates contend in a year or two, when they are fully rebuilt and ready to go, will be shipped elsewhere or leave because they will cost too much money or be too old.
That’s why there is no reason to hold on to just about anyone on this roster. Yes, the Pirates should make it clear that every player is available for the right package in return. And in some cases, that package shouldn’t be all that much given the value of the players they are trading.
That starts with Starling Marte and Josh Bell, two players who should have some value and bring some decent prospects back in return. Marte is old and expensive (by Pirates standards) and he is a free agent at the end of the 2021 season. He also doesn’t want to be here. He has value now because he can still play at a reasonably high level and he has a fairly team-friendly contract.
Read More
Bell is younger and still under team control through 2022, but he is going to start to get expensive as he finishes his arbitration years. If the Pirates aren’t going to commit to him long term (which, given his agent is Scott Boras, isn’t likely to happen) then they need to trade him. He isn’t a good defensive first baseman anyway, and his power is a little overrated.
Gregory Polanco has very little value, but the Pirates should trade him anyway. There is no reason to keep him around and he’s probably not the kind of veteran influence you want in your clubhouse. Polanco may bring something back from a team desperate for left-handed hitting, but he really is just taking up space in the Pirates’ outfield.
Two pitchers the Pirates should try to move: Chris Archer and Keone Kela. There is probably more value in Kela because he proved last season he still has great stuff and can be a closer for someone.
Archer is tricky because they did give up about half the franchise to get him, but that was a different regime, so trading him would just be erasing a mistake. Archer has no value for the Pirates, as he is a mediocre pitcher that doesn’t give them any length.
There are reports people are interested in Adam Frazier and that’s great, too. Go ahead and trade him now and stop trying to convince yourself he is an everyday second baseman on a team that is interested in contending. He is a nice utility player, and that is all.
The Pirates should commit to starting next season with Kevin Newman as the starting second baseman, Cole Tucker at shortstop and Ke’Bryan Hayes at third with Bryan Reynolds in left. And then build from there. The pitching staff without Archer wouldn’t be all that much different than it is with him, but at least he wouldn’t be stealing innings from someone younger who may be part of the resurrection of the team in a couple of years.
Yes, it would be ugly. The roster devoid of a few of these players might be awful and there is a chance they could win 62 games. That wouldn’t be a step back, though, as it would be a necessary step to rebuild the foundation of the roster and the core of the team so a sustainable run of winning seasons is possible again.
And at this point, what is the difference between a 62-win season and a 79-win season? The question shouldn’t be about how many games the Pirates win in 2020, it should be what is the quickest, most logical and realistic path to getting back to a stretch of years like 2013-15?
The Pirates have the ability to get back there, and now that they have a new management team in place it may even be probable. It won’t happen, though, if the Pirates keep on the same course of trying to slop together rosters of “hidden gems” in hopes of hitting lightning in a bottle and getting to 81 wins. The management team must be proactive and aware of the flaws in its roster enough to be willing to tear it all down and start over.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.