Bob Nutting discusses reasons for Pirates personnel changes
Pirates owner Bob Nutting wasn’t quite ready to go there.
Sure, to hire the 13th general manager in franchise history the Pirates plucked Ben Cherington from the Toronto Blue Jays and, before that, the Boston Red Sox.
In two moves this offseason — coupled with the hiring of Travis Williams as president — the Pirates have made two pretty smart hires and restored some semblance of normalcy to their front office.
But Nutting stopped short of saying this was about a credibility boost. More it was about getting someone with a solid background who also had the necessary tools and temperament to get this thing right.
“I'm not sure that credibility is what we're going after,” Nutting said. “I think we're going after the best opportunity for success, and I really believe that's what we've done.”
Give Cherington a lot of credit here: He’s been brought into a unique situation, one that’s also new for him, and he’s been assigned a difficult task: turn the Pirates from something of a laughingstock to a source of civic pride.
Read More
Something he’ll also need to do on limited resources.
He’s confident that will work, and his bosses are even more confident that Cherington will make it work — in large part because of his background.
“I talked to a lot of people in and around the game, whether it’s within the commissioner’s office or other clubs that I really respect,” Nutting said. “For a long time Ben has been one of the really creative minds in baseball, pushing innovation, pushing the edge of how do you develop, how do you identify, how do you continue to improve talent?”
The Cherington hire is important to the Pirates for all sorts of reasons. The drafting and development. Improving the major league roster. Doing better internationally. These guys have repeated those left and right.
But it’s also important because of Williams and his limited experience in baseball. Williams is an incredibly smart guy, but he’s spent about three weeks in the world of baseball.
Installing Cherington as general manager effectively gives him free run of baseball operations; Williams will oversee and ask questions, but the next time he meddles or oversteps will be the first.
As such, it was important for the Pirates to get someone who had done this sort of thing before, someone who had seen all layers of a baseball front office and could bring a sense of calm.
“He knows what it takes to win and build that culture of success,” Williams said. “We had a lot of discussions, too, around how we'll interact. That was an important part of it: making sure it's a good fit for Ben, making sure it's a good fit for myself as well and making sure it made sense to Bob along the way.
“I think what we both respect is he's got a great baseball mind. I bring a different perspective and lens to different discussions and decisions, and I think Ben likes that diversity of thought and perspective."
Nutting and Williams have now addressed the media twice since late October — the first for Williams’ hiring — and Nutting has actually come off as strikingly human both times.
Maybe it’s the smaller settings. Maybe he’s also just flat-out mad. “I was frustrated,” Nutting said when answering a question about this past season. “There’s no question that we needed change.”
And there’s no question the Pirates needed someone with Cherington’s background, someone who had been a part of playoff baseball, franchise reboots and everything in between. The only issue was whether that guy would come to Pittsburgh.
Striking that newly humanized tone, Nutting told an interesting story about when he pursued Williams, the former Penguins executive who had recently taken a job with the New York Islanders.
“Back in August when we began talking about the president's role, it was interesting; I was talking with a leader about attributes that we might want, and he said, 'The best person would obviously be Travis, but you're not going to be able to get him,’ ” Nutting said. “Well, you know, it sounded like a recruiting challenge to me, which at the end of the day worked out pretty well.
“I feel much the same about Ben. I think if someone asked three weeks ago or three months ago, ‘Can you put together a team that has a deep history of success and connection to Pittsburgh with Travis, deep history and success and relentless passion for getting better every day like Ben,’ I don't think anybody would have bet, 'Oh yeah, that's the team you're going to be able to get recruited to Pittsburgh.’ ”
So, the Pirates will embark on a manager search led by someone who owns three World Series rings, one of them won as a general manager, and was a factor in a fourth one where it involved the majority of a minor league system that he built.
Cherington seemed nothing short of elated to bring his experience on the game’s biggest stage to the small-market Pirates.
“First I want to share how I’m feeling,” Cherington said Monday, taking the microphone for the first time in his new role, “which is an incredible sense of gratitude for the opportunity that’s been given to me by Bob and Travis. I got to know a few people through this process who I came to believe would be incredible partners, people who I wanted to work with every day and who I want to learn from. I’m excited to dive into that work with them.”
Can't get enough of our in-depth Pirates coverage?
Support quality journalism. Subscribe today.
Jason Mackey: jmackey@post-gazette.com and Twitter @JMackeyPG.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.