Ben Cherington introduced as Pirates general manager
Ben Cherington was introduced as Pirates general manager Monday, and he hit all the right notes in his first press conference. He talked about why he took the job, ownership’s commitment to winning, and his plan to rebuild the Pirates into a great franchise.
I know very little about Cherington other than what I have read. He seems like a bright, charismatic and energetic person who has a track record of success. But Monday was more about sending a clear signal to Pirates fans that they are valued and that owner Bob Nutting and company want them to come back and support the organization again.
This past season turned off the fan base in a big way. But fans were brought up by all three men — Nutting, team President Travis Williams and Cherington — early in their remarks Monday. And that is exactly the right approach because this past season was a public relations disaster for the franchise and the fan base clearly needs to be rebuilt.
Nutting made reference to how important it is for the fans to have a franchise they can be “excited about and proud of every single day” again.
“It was important that we got it right for our fans, and I absolutely think at the end of the day we did just that,” Williams said.
Cherington referenced fans in his opening statement, then later said he was excited about the opportunity to “build a great team on the field that people in Pittsburgh can be proud of, and I know how much this team means to the people of Pittsburgh.”
Read More
That fan base is far more cynical today than it was 12 years ago when Neal Huntington was hired as GM. He had a lengthy grace period that I don’t think will be afforded to Cherington, so he needs to get it right quickly. He seems to have a plan. He talked Monday about the importance of player scouting, player acquisition, player development and player deployment and how all of that figures into his plan.
It all sounds good, but Cherington needs to win. Fans in this market, thanks to Huntington and ex-team President Frank Coonelly, are tired of hearing about cutting edge methods, theories, formulas, rest programs, healthy eating programs and everything else. The fan base is to the point where it doesn’t want to hear grand announcements about how it will get done; they just want it to get done.
I don’t know that it will be that easy. Cherington insists he was given assurances from Nutting that he would have the resources to win. Nothing we have seen so far in the Nutting era suggests he is going to open up his wallet and start spending money on payroll at a level that puts them on an equal playing field with teams such as the Brewers and Reds.
I believe Cherington can build a winning team, but there is a lot of dead weight in the organization from years of bad drafting and worse development. The team has a lot of holes to fill and filling holes the right way usually costs money. And again, nothing we have seen from Nutting suggests he is willing to make that kind of investment into payroll.
But Nutting took important steps toward winning back some credibility with fans when he cleaned house. He seems to have garnered some more excitement and credibility with the hiring of Williams and now Cherington. Presumably, there will be a similar news conference introducing a new manager, and that should generate excitement as well.
All of these things are meaningful steps, but they are also baby steps. Ultimately fans in this town are starving for a baseball team that wins.
Paul Zeise: pzeise@post-gazette.com and Twitter @PaulZeise





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.