A torn labrum before Ben Cherington’s senior year on the baseball team at Amherst College effectively ended his career as a pitcher. The right-hander, who topped out at 85 mph and — gulp — mostly pitched to contact, was never the same and spent that spring as a fourth outfielder, vying for time.
However, the injury likely jump-started Cherington’s post-playing career as a scout, player development guru and member of a couple different successful front offices. In addition to serving as a depth option in the outfield, Cherington functioned as a player-coach for the pitching staff and wound up spending another year at Amherst as a full-time coach.
“That was a really important time for me,” Cherington said in a March 2018 podcast with MLB.com’s Mark Feinsand. “I connected to the challenge of coaching and the importance of good coaching.”
As the Pirates are set to introduced Cherington on Monday as their new general manager, the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette spent time Saturday studying his backstory to learn who he is, how he got here and what makes the 45-year-old Meriden, N.H. native tick.
What follows is a collection of stories and anecdotes culled from various profiles and a podcast done on Cherington, who spent the bulk of his Major League Baseball career with the team for which he grew up cheering, the Boston Red Sox.
The kid in the mirror
Read More
On that podcast, Cherington said that he first dreamed of working for the Red Sox when he was 4.
You know, as a shortstop or pitcher.
Instead, he had to wait until fellow Amherst alum Dan Duquette, then Red Sox GM, hired Cherington in 1999 and made him an area scout.
“A lot of kids growing up in the Northeast, you gain a passion for baseball,” Cherington said in the MLB.com podcast. “In some respects it’s through the Red Sox or through the Yankees and the other teams in the Northeast.”
For Cherington, it was definitely the Red Sox ... after, of course, former Pirates general manager Neal Huntington helped Cherington get his first MLB gig with the Cleveland Indians.
Apparently Cherington was really good at mimicking players’ batting stances, something he would do in the mirror as a kid. Jim Rice and Ellis Burks were favorites. Apparently he also does a great impression of Nomar Garciaparra.
This November 2011 ESPN profile from Jackie MacMullen, after Cherington was hired to become GM of the Red Sox, is simply terrific.
Family life
Cherington is married to Tyler Tumminia, the daughter of a White Sox scout who was named after Ty Cobb. Tumminia used to be the senior vice president at the Goldklang Group, where she would oversee four minor league teams and one college league team.
Tumminia left her current position after the 2016 season, and it’s unclear what she’s doing now. However, it’s definitely a unique setup given their backgrounds and occupations.
“Maybe the best thing about Tyler being in baseball is she doesn’t have to ask a lot of questions about what happens on the field,” Cherington said in this May 2015 Boston Globe profile of Tumminia, another must-read. “We spend more time talking about things that matter to us.”
The couple has two young daughters, Adwen and Harper. They’re also, according to that piece, extremely private about their family life.
And assuming she would want to, there are probably worse moves Cherington could make than finding his wife a role in the Pirates organization.
“I think she has done an amazing job,” Yankees general manager Brian Cashman said of Tumminia. “She is a burst of positive energy and has passion for the game and for her work. She will live on the edge to reach or create new markets. She’s capable of doing anything.”
The couple actually met at a baseball game, although Tumminia doesn’t remember it. Cherington, per that Globe profile, admitted that he was looking down at a program, saw the name “Tyler” and assumed that person was a male.
A couple years later, after Tumminia thought Cherington ignored her when she tried to say hello — it actually wasn’t him — she sent him a nasty email, and the two wound up laughing about it and getting coffee.
In that same article, Cherington gave a terrific quote about women in baseball, which makes you wonder if he won’t try to improve upon that with the Pirates once he starts making hires.
“There’s nothing we do that a woman couldn’t do,” Cherington said. “You need to process information, have a high level of intelligence, be able to work hard, make decisions, manage people; those are not gender-specific qualities.”
Cherington’s wife isn’t the only famous member of his family. One of his grandfathers, Richard Eberhart, was a Pulitzer Prize-winning poet (1966) and also taught at Dartmouth.
In the MLB.com podcast, Cherington said he basically grew up on Dartmouth’s campus, attending sports events, plays and several other functions.
Motivating factors
You’ll probably hear Cherington use the term “shared purpose” a lot. It frames a lot of how he talks about working in the front office of a baseball team and creating a successful culture.
It’s one of things that led him to the Toronto Blue Jays after he left the Red Sox. That and a couple personnel connections he had with the team.
“What’s most important to me is to be in a position where I can lead people and where I can be a part of something where there’s a shared purpose and a shared set of values that connects that group of people,” Cherington said on the podcast. “I feel like I’m a part of that here. It doesn’t mean there wouldn’t be other places I couldn’t be a part of that, but that’s what is most important to me.”
After chatting with people close to Cherington and learning more about him, it’s also clear that Cherington, in addition to being a bit of a nerd about the leadership process, loves player development and figuring out ways to help guys get better.
Seems that would be a pretty important fit with the Pirates.
Teaching time
Cherington was GM of the Red Sox until August 2015, when he stepped town after the team hired Dave Dombrowski as their president of baseball operations.
“It never felt like a choice to me,” Cherington said of his decision to walk away. “I don’t think that would have been fair to Dave Dombrowski, let alone me. Whatever our best efforts would have been, it would have been difficult for either of us to truly contribute in a way we wanted to.”
That transition period was an interesting part of Cherington’s life. After guiding the Red Sox to a World Series title in 2013, the 2014 and 2015 seasons were pretty bad, with back-to-back last-place finishes in the American League East.
Cherington wanted to step back and learn why things went awry and figure how to get better from it. He didn’t view that as a quick process.
“I didn’t think that was like a week-long project,” Cherington said. “I thought that was like a months-long project.”
So later that offseason, with no more baseball jobs available, Cherington decided to chart a unique path: He contacted Vince Gennaro, president of the Society for American Baseball Research and the director of the sports management program at Columbia University’s School of Professional Studies.
According to a May 2016 article by the Boston Globe’s Alex Speier, Cherington had lunch with Gennaro, and within a couple days they devised a plan for Cherington to teach one of three sections of the class on “Leadership and Personnel Management.”
Cherington insisted that it wasn’t a baseball-only class, but he did pull a lot from his own experience — what to do and what not to do.
“I don’t mind talking about my own shortcomings, my mistakes,” Cherington said in the Boston Globe profile on him teaching. “I think there is plenty we did right over time. I don’t mind talking about the things that we didn’t or that I didn’t do — even things I would do differently. In that sense, I’m fine being in the dunk tank.”
The process also challenged Cherington.
“It really challenged my assumptions about some of things I believed in in terms of how to manage people, how to hire, how to build culture, or whatever those things are,” Cherington said on the MLB.com podcast.
“Because when you prepare to say those things in front of 24 kids who are paying to be there, you have to make sure you really believe in it.”
Other tidbits
There were plenty of nuggets from reading about Cherington that didn’t fit anywhere else.
• Cherington has a close-knit group of friends from back home, and they used to take yearly baseball-related trips together. One way back in the day took them to see the Nashua Pirates. There, Cherington witnessed a brawl that featured Bobby Bonilla and Paul O’Neill.
• One time Cherington went to see Pearl Jam with his former boss, Theo Epstein. While Epstein was a couple rows from the stage, Cherington sat with his buddies up in the nosebleeds.
• Speaking of Epstein, he was once so mad at Fenway Park that he blasted a golf ball that bounced a couple times and whacked Cherington in the forehead, drawing blood.
“Once I realized I didn’t lose eyesight or anything, I look at it as a positive,” Cherington said. “It was going to be a lot harder to fire me after that.”
• Cherington, an English major at Amherst, is big into reading and also would spend time jogging around Boston’s spring training complex. Another physical activity should resonate with Pittsburgh fans: He grew up playing a lot of hockey.
• Funny quote from one of Cherington’s friends via the MacMullen article: "It was never 'if Ben would be a GM' but when," said one of his good friends, Dan McGee. "We always assumed it would be a team like the Kansas City Royals and we'd get rid of all our Red Sox stuff and we'd go to as many games as we could. We wouldn't have to feel bad about asking for tickets because no one else would want to go.
"That was our plan: Let's find a small market and follow Ben."
Welcome to Pittsburgh, gentlemen. Go get some Pirates gear.
Jason Mackey: jmackey@post-gazette.com and Twitter @JMackeyPG.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.