As Ben Cherington walked out of his introductory press conference on Monday at PNC Park and resumed his job as Pirates general manager, two tasks should garner his attention more than anything else: hiring a manager and acquiring more talent.
The first is obvious, as the Pirates will immediately restart a process that began to take shape soon after the season ended. But Cherington must also hire the right manager in order to maximize the talent that the Pirates do have.
“I think we’re off to a really good start,” Cherington said of hiring a manager. “There’s certainly more work to do. We’ll work as hard as we can and be as efficient and as effective as we can over the next several days to find the right person.”
The biggest thing people want to know about Cherington right now is whether the Pirates are going to blow up their roster or try to compete now. A straight answer was not something Cherington wanted to give on Monday, instead emphasizing the fact that he simply wants to get better every day.
That’s not wrong, but it’s also not complete. Of course they want get better. It’s how the Pirates get better that matters most in this context.
Ironically, that brings into focus the second thing on Cherington’s plate at the moment: how they infuse more talent into the organization at every level.
Read More
While once again describing baseball’s financial landscape as unfair to small-market teams — “Baseball doesn’t have a level economic playing field,” he said — Pirates owner Bob Nutting also bemoaned the organization’s current lack of talent.
It’s pitching, catching and hitting. It involves international players. It’s everything.
The Pirates lack talent, and Cherington has a few different options to get more: He can draft well and probably better than the Pirates have, which is never a bad strategy; he can also better develop the talent that they do find; and he could flip some current major leaguers for young guys who fall into those first two categories.
“There's a lot of work that needs to get done, and frankly we don't have enough talent in the organization right now,” Nutting said. “We need to be better at bringing in talent. The talent we have, we've got to be better at developing it because we're not getting the most out of the players that we have. We've seen that in too many painful, visible examples.”
One veteran in that category would probably be Chris Archer, who found a spark in the second half before an arm injury cut short his 2019 season. The Pirates must also find a way to get back the late-2018 version of Gregory Polanco.
There could be more to Colin Moran, while Kyle Crick is coming off a lousy year. At catcher, they’re probably going to have to look outside for a legitimate No. 1. Mitch Keller is a young pitcher similar to Tyler Glasnow, who couldn't get his minor-league success to translate ... until he went to the Rays.
“I’m really looking forward to diving in with our group here to figure out where the opportunities are at the major league level and the minor league level,” Cherington said. “Ultimately, great players and great teams are simply getting better every day. You can call it player development. You can call it improvement. You can call it whatever you want.
“But that process has to be not just continuous, but on the cutting edge and ahead of other teams."
As for manager, a natural top choice would be Derek Shelton from the Twins. He has legitimate small-market experience — something the Pirates were willing to forgo with Cherington — and he’s been on a staff that has quickly produced radical changes.
Minnesota set the major league record for home runs this season with 307. They had just 166 in 2018, and they didn’t break the bank to produce that ridiculous jump. Shelton was the Twins’ bench coach, but previously he worked for the Rays and Indians.
A’s quality control coach Mark Kotsay was another candidate the Pirates really liked the first time around, specifically for his understanding of baseball’s many layers and also his relatability as a recently retired player. If the Pirates are going to make their team more player-centric, either would make sense.
“At the core, it comes back to the feeling that this ought to be a player-centered game,” Cherington said. “Players will always be at the center of it, so if you think about it through that lens, player development naturally is a critical activity for us.
“It's something I've been drawn to my whole career. It's also an area that's completely changed in the last five-seven years. The whole world is upside down in terms of player development, so there's a lot of opportunity out there.”
Jason Mackey: jmackey@post-gazette.com and Twitter @JMackeyPG.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.