The Pirates may not have to look far to find the ideal candidate to succeed Neal Huntington.

Assuming they want someone with ample experience.

And a guy who’s beloved by pretty much everyone with whom he’s ever worked.

Tony Lacava, a 58-year-old Oakmont resident and Pittsburgh-area native, has spent the past 30 years in baseball doing a little bit of everything, all of it well. He’s currently the Blue Jays’ senior vice president of player personnel.

Advertise with us

“With Tony, if you bring up his name, I’ve never heard anyone say a bad word about the guy,” said one American League scout who, like everyone quoted here, was granted anonymity to speak honestly about a competitor.

Similar to Nationals general manager Mike Rizzo, who just won the World Series, Lacava would offer the Pirates a desirable blend of new and old school, something a team in their situation likely needs.

It’s also an interesting time to hire a general manager because, as one AL executive pointed out, “This is a copycat industry. Whenever someone wins a championship, you try to find their secret sauce. People will be studying how the Nationals did it.”

“Every job he’s done, he’s done well,” a second AL executive said of Lacava. “Whether it’s been on the pro side, the amateur side or drafting, he’s a quality guy.

“He’s also as humble as you would ever want to see. There’s no ego in this guy. Just a quality, quality person.”

Advertise with us

If Lacava’s name sounds familiar, it’s probably because it is. The Central Catholic graduate actually interviewed for the Pirates’ GM job back in 2007, the job that eventually went to Huntington.

According to multiple sources, Lacava interviewed, said Huntington would be his first hire, and the Pirates used that intel to hire Huntington in an attempt to replicate the Cleveland Indians’ model for winning.

Lacava interviewed to become Baltimore’s GM in 2011 and was seemingly on track to get the job, but he (somewhat surprisingly) withdrew his name from consideration. The job eventually went to Dan Duquette, a friend of Pirates owner Bob Nutting and Huntington’s mentor.

Lacava signed with the Pirates as an undrafted free agent in 1983 and enjoy a brief stint in their minor league system as a player. The California Angels hired him in 1989 as a scout, and he was there for 10 years.

After a brief stop in Atlanta as the Braves’ national scouting supervisor, Lacava joined the Montreal Expos as their director of player development.

Advertise with us

He jumped to the Indians in 2002 as a national crosschecker and was hired by the Blue Jays that fall to become an assistant to the general manager — J.P. Ricciardi at that time.

From there, Lacava worked his way up to Toronto’s director of player development in 2009 and vice president of baseball operations/interim general manager when Alex Anthopoulos turned down a five-year contract and left to work for the Dodgers.

“He’s highly respected throughout the industry,” one National League executive said. “He’s a lead-by-example type. I think he’s very good at getting the global perspective of the whole operation.

“He’s the quintessential never-get-too-high, never-get-too-low type. He’s got a pretty steady pulse.”

Which, the executive would go on to say, will be essential for the Pirates job, should Lacava wind up getting it.

Advertise with us

“I know nobody wants to be patient, but the organization is going to be have to re-wired,” the NL executive said. “They have to draft better. They have to get their international operation back up and running. I think it’s really a patience thing at this point.”

Lacava, who lived in Brookline through fifth grade before moving to Penn Hills, would seemingly bring the right approach and mindset. He declined an interview request for this story, but those who’ve worked with Lacava through the years or for rival clubs raved about several of his skills, the biggest one likely his ability to identify talent. That would obviously not be a bad thing for the Pirates.

“He can blend the old with the new very well,” another AL executive said. “That’s what stands out to me. He can take a traditional baseball point of view and marry it with analytics or science. He’s eclectic in that regard.”

With the Blue Jays, Lacava has been a part of identifying/developing young stars such as Vladimir Guerrero Jr., Bo Bichette and Cavan Biggio.

In Cleveland, Lacava was a key component in the June 27, 2002, trade that sent Bartolo Colon to the Expos for Brandon Phillips, Cliff Lee and Grady Sizemore.

Advertise with us

The three were prospects at the time of the trade, but Lacava saw potential; even he had to be surprised at the results.

“Tony has the unique ability of striking a healthy and productive balance between instinctive evaluation and objective analysis,” an NL executive said.

“You have to be good at drafting, procuring and developing talent,” one of the AL execs said. “You have to be good in the international market. I think Tony has covered all of those branches of baseball operations and has done it well.”

Will Lacava do that sort of stuff for his hometown team? That much remains to be seen, as the Pirates aren’t talking about the ongoing search.

But this much we do know: The people who make up Major League Baseball’s underbelly, the people who watch games, evaluate talent and talk to others around the game, love Lacava.

Advertise with us

“Either A) he never burned any bridges along the way or he just went ahead and did his job professionally,” the AL scout said. “I think he’s really good at his craft.

“When you’ve done as much as he has, and you’ve been able to appease that many people, that must be a pretty special person.”

Jason Mackey: jmackey@post-gazette.com and Twitter @JMackeyPG.

Can't get enough of our in-depth Pirates coverage?

Support quality journalism. Subscribe today.