Take a step back, have an open mind and try to examine the Pirates’ situation in full. Sure, how owner Bob Nutting has cleaned house has been strange — firing the manager, mutually parting ways with the president, then relieving the general manager of his duties, despite giving that man (Neal Huntington) a vote of confidence at the start of the whole process.

It also doesn’t really matter.

We’re here, the Pirates embarking on a GM search for the first time since 2007, when they hired Huntington. There are also several important issues at hand.

Decisions that, in the interim, will be handled by assistant general manager Kevan Graves and bigger-picture will be made by whomever new president Travis Williams (and probably others) choose to succeed Huntington.

Advertise with us

It’s too tough to separate big-picture from small-picture questions. So here, listed randomly, are some of the decisions the Pirates’ next manager will have to make.

Is it time to rebuild?

“This is not a quick fix,” one National League executive said of the Pirates’ situation. “If they want to do it right and build something that’s sustainable for the future, it’s not going to be a quick fix.”

Nutting does not believe the Pirates are a traditional rebuild candidate and said as much earlier this week, the result of having players such as Bryan Reynolds, Kevin Newman and Josh Bell — young assets to build around.

The new guy will have to decide whether he can make enough nips and tucks to render the Pirates competitive again. If that’s not possible, the Pirates must part ways with their most expensive players and brace for a couple years of bad baseball.

Advertise with us

One prediction: The new man/woman will see enough here to compete. With a couple of solid hires on the major league coaching staff and with better drafting and development (see below), the Pirates will be able to do just enough to avoid completely blowing up their roster.

What about those options?

The five-day window is ticking, as the Pirates must decide whether to pick up options on Chris Archer ($9 million) and Starling Marte ($11.5 million).

The prediction here is that the Pirates will pick up both, then decide what to do after that. If they determine that a rebuild makes the most sense, Marte is coming off his best year as a pro and could likely fetch something in return.

Archer possibly could, too, with the market for pitchers sometimes a tricky thing. But it wouldn’t make a lot of sense for the Pirates to pay more than $20 million to a pair of guys on the wrong side of 30.

Advertise with us

If the Pirates believe they can compete now, they could want what Marte brings and charge a new manager/pitching coach with the task of finally getting Archer right or believe that a better catcher would help. (They’d be right.)

At minimum, it makes little sense for the Pirates to let these guys walk.

Will the new GM try to sign Josh Bell?

Huntington was always open to doing a long-term deal with Bell. “We’re open to it if they are,” Huntington said in August. But there’s also no evidence serious talks ever started.

Bell’s agent, Scott Boras, will obviously want his client to be paid like a star given that Bell absolutely performed like one, and the Pirates are going to want a resolution here that makes sense for them.

Advertise with us

Will a new GM consider buying out Bell’s arbitration years and doling out what would probably have to be the largest contract in franchise history?

Or will the new GM think about trading Bell, assuming he’s going to leave at the first available chance, and try to get something in return first?

It’s doubtful this is an immediate decision, but it’s something to at least monitor.

What to do with Steven Brault?

Steven Brault was slated to become a two-way player … with manager Clint Hurdle and Huntington in charge.

Advertise with us

Now, it’ll be interesting to see what the new regime has in mind for the athletic left-hander.

Brault’s pitching performance in 2019 seemed to earn him a rotation spot in 2020, but how much more he’s allowed to do could depend on a few different factors.

Do you move Marte?

Marte is a better center fielder than defensive metrics gave him credit for, but he also isn’t getting any younger.

Reynolds grew up playing the position and could easily provide the Pirates with a better option right now.

Advertise with us

If the Pirates had these two switch, with Marte going back to his old position, it might keep him fresh for longer while allowing Reynolds to shine at his natural position.

Those offseason moves

This can go any number of directions. It’s also a pretty obvious one: What will the general manager do to improve the club?

Several decision-makers, including Hurdle and Huntington, acknowledged that the Pirates probably need to get better behind the plate. Jacob Stallings was OK, but he’s probably best-suited for backup duty.

Which means the Pirates would need to target a legitimate starting catcher either through free agency or trade, a Russell Martin type of acquisition.

Advertise with us

There’s a good chance the incoming general manager will see the things the same way — only two MLB clubs had a worse OPS from their catchers than the Pirates — but what else is prioritized?

The Pirates could want a late-inning defensive replacement for Bell. Their bullpen was also a problem for much of the season. Additional starting pitching never hurts.

Who’s on staff?

Right now, everybody is in sort of a holding pattern. Graves is making day-to-day decisions, and Stark, whose title is vice president/assistant general manager, continues to show up for work each day, awaiting orders from whomever the Pirates hire.

Based on what he said earlier this week with reporters, Nutting is not at all happy with how the Pirates have developed players at the major league level, the end result with them leaving and thriving with other teams.

Advertise with us

If there’s that much of a push from Nutting and Williams, something has to change with how the Pirates draft and develop, and that would likely involve several of the staff members under the new GM.

Jason Mackey@post-gazette.com and jmackey@post-gazette.com.