nubyjas wilborn: Good afternoon! It's been a wild season to say the least. I'm happy to be here and talking Pirates with you guys and gals. Let's get started.
burt reynolds: is Clint Hurdle really going to be the only coach fired??
nubyjas wilborn: No. Ray Searage told our Jason Mackey that he expects to be fired. I wouldn't be surprised if there aren't other moves as well.
Who Cares Anymore: If Nutting & his Stoogies don’t care to invest in a competitive team......why should we or anyone else care? They suck at drafting & developing prospects & they don’t invest in payroll despite Major League Baseball experiencing record revenue streams.
nubyjas wilborn: Your dollar and time are your votes. If you don't feel the team is giving their best then you shouldn't give yours. However, I and I know this is going to get me clowned. Bob does want to win. The problem is he wants to do the most affordable way possible when it comes to signing players. I do think they've realized that their way of player dev needs to be revised. We'll see how they go forward.
SalemPirate: Congrats on your first season with the Bucs. Look forward to your contributions. Gator is a fav of mine!
Read More
nubyjas wilborn: Thanks! Believe it or not, it's been mostly fun. Obviously reporting on the Vazquez stuff was stressful. But for the most part I enjoyed the challenges of finding angles on a team that was losing so much in the second half.
BLB: Have the Pirates interviewed anyone yet for manager or contacted any they would like to interview?
nubyjas wilborn: Not that we know of. A lot of the potential external candidates are in the playoffs so they can't talk to them. Expect it to be quiet for the next few days.
Annoyed: I am fed up that awful Bob Nutting left Neal and Frank in place. Neal's drafting and developing has been atrocious!! Is Nutting that clueless that he is really happy with those guys?
nubyjas wilborn: Bob knows. He also doesn't and frankly shouldn't care. If he feels that Neal is a good GM and trusts him then he should keep him even if it makes fans angry. However, you have a choice to make as well.
Teke: Barring any moves, the starting rotation will be, on paper, the worst in the entire league, no? I like Musgrove, but if he’s your ace.....
nubyjas wilborn: Miami is worse and there are others. However, barring improvement from Archer, Williams, and Keller it won't be great.

The 3 Stoogies Survive: Nubyjas, I’d really like to win the Powerball. That happening is as likely as Nutting “wanting to win.” Shame on you for defending nutting in any way.
nubyjas wilborn: I don't think that's accurate nor was I "defending" Bob. I know it's easy to kick the team and Lord knows they have flaws but I don't believe that Bob is an inherently evil man seeking to destroy your baseball fun.
AtlantaDan: Good to know Bob really wants to win - I also want a new SL500 Mercedes but at the cost of a subcompact Kia. We know the player payroll is chronically low compared to other teams - any data on what is being invested in player development compared to other franchises?
nubyjas wilborn: At one point they were seventh in spending on non-player payroll. The Pirates have one of the largest analytic departments. They're spending a lot internationally and other areas. The problem is the other teams in the top-10 in those areas are also spending on the field. For years, the Yankees and Red Sox most spent on the field now they're spending the off the field too.
Annoyed: Agree with 3 Stoogies Nubyjas. Why would you write that Nutting 'shouldn't' care? Every time I try and give you a chance you disappoint me with your strange and ridiculous comments more and more.
nubyjas wilborn: Would you run your business based on what fans think? I wouldn't and he shouldn't. Notice I didn't say he should've kept Neal. I'm saying that fan angst shouldn't rule his decisions. Also, the same way, I don't care about the "chances" a person does or doesn't give me when they aren't man or woman enough to put their name on same comment, annoyed. :)
Joe Girardi: What do I need to to do to get the Pirates to hire me? Am I crazy to want yhe job?
nubyjas wilborn: You'll want too much money.
burt reynolds: Given that they are looking at being a budget team as well as the weak farm system, how can the Pirates get help at catcher and with pitching?
nubyjas wilborn: They'll have to spend and there will be options. But they can't come back with Diaz & Stallings if they're serious about winning.
Tim: I certainly hope the Pirates go outside of the organization for the new manager. In my opinion there needs to be a fresh perspective. Jason Kendall May be well respected, but As I recall was never on a winning team. Not to say that was entirely his fault. Just think we need someone from a organization with a history of winning. Thoughts?
nubyjas wilborn: I don't think Kendall will get much consideration. I'd be open to Jeff Banister, he had success in Texas. He also seems to have learned from what failed there. I don't see him as Clint 2.0, but that hire won't inspire fans. I also agree with you that someone who has won and knows what it takes to win is important. There are a lot of potential options out there.
Don Orris: Forbes listed Nutting I believe as the 10th richest owner in mlb. The avg payroll for mlb this season was around $145 million. The Pirates spend half of that. So please tell me why Bob Nutting couldn't up the payroll to about $120 million? It would still be below average but it would allow the team to sign some much needed players and show the fans that the owner really does care about winning! Am I missing something here?
nubyjas wilborn: You make a fair point, Don. The payroll was extremely low, however, they were right there with Tampa and Oakland. Payroll is a factor, but there is a lot more that the Pirates could fix. Also, look at all the money the Phillies and Mets spent, they're at home too.
Evan: If you had to predict the future manager outside of the organization who would be your pick?
nubyjas wilborn: I'd want someone like Twins bench coach Derek Shelton.
Searage: Am I getting fired, or just not getting a new contract?
nubyjas wilborn: whatever makes it easier to sleep at night.

An Observer: Isn’t an indictment against Larry, Moe & Curly (nutting & his clowns) that other small market teams are smarter than this group of morons because they (Oakland, Milwaukee, Tampa) have consistently outperformed the Pirates on the fielded.
nubyjas wilborn: Such rude language. But yes, a fair critique can be made since other teams are overcoming the obstacles.
Wayward: How quickly do you see this manager process playing out? Are there any candidates you think they think enough of to wait throughout the playoffs to speak with?
nubyjas wilborn: it could be slow.
Wayward: Are there any specific areas within player development that you see are the primary culprits?
nubyjas wilborn: defense. pitching as well.
Hernandez, K: Has JB maxed out his defensive improvement? If so, how far away is that DH change?
nubyjas wilborn: I'd hate to say that. He works so hard. As far as the DH, it'll be coming in the next few years, I believe.
Dear Annoyed: Because when teams--who know what they are doing--kowtow to fans, they are much more likely make bad decisions. Quite simple.
nubyjas wilborn: facts.
Guest: With the pitching problems, management limiting them to certain innings/pitch counts, yet starters left in to give up 6+ runs, doesn't seem to make sense. Given that we are rarely likely to keep a player beyond Free-Agency, why do they care about limiting pitchers counts? Recall that Steve Blass and others from his time had many complete games when they were successful.
nubyjas wilborn: That ship has sailed in baseball. Nobody is throwing complete games anymore. They're so rare now and have been for going on 5 or more years.
Daquido Bazzani: What did you think of the Stephen Nesbitt column in the Atlantic claiming basically that Hurdle would be back? It obviously blew up in his face and as I'm sure you know, he used to be the Pirates beat writer here. Is there any accountability for that guy for putting out such a misleading article? He should be fired imo.
nubyjas wilborn: Nesbitt did what any one of us would've done. Hurdle told him he was coming back. The reporter wrote what the subject said on the record. I'll tell you this the org wasn't happy with Clint for doing that. Nesbitt wasn't wrong. If Nesbitt wrote that and didn't have attribution then he would've been wrong, but the manager said it.
Cecil: With the Pirates television contract with AT&T Sportsnet and the naming rights to PNC Park expiring soon, you'd think that Bob Nutting would want to put his best product on the field, in order to maximize the value of those contracts. This money dictates the budget for the next decade at least, and I've seen no indication from the organization that they understand this.
nubyjas wilborn: This will be a pivotal offseason. Bob has a chance to spend some money. If he doesn't that will be telling.
Tim: When you look at the Rays and A’s they are usually competitive with small market budgets. Although the Rays do have a number of ex-Bucs, couldn’t resist. The point though maybe someone from an organization that wins but had a limited budget? That may take a new GM as well though
nubyjas wilborn: Yes, that's why when I gave my initial candidate list I made that a factor.
Don Orris: Expounding on my earlier question sir, do you think Bob Nuttting knows that there is major major discontent now among the fans and perhaps goes out of his comfort zone this offseason to sign some much needed free agents? And I don't mean the Lonnie Chisenhall types. I mean solid $10-15 million a year type players that could immediately help us. This might sound too optimistic but I think Nutting knows there is so much anger from the fans now he might need to shake things up a bit. Thoughts?
nubyjas wilborn: Bob is aware of the discontent. Bob does go to games regularly and speaks to fans he's aware. As I said earlier, he's also not going to be swayed but so much. Nor should he. Also, fans can't have it both ways. The Archer trade was the Pirates going for it. They had to give up prospects to do it, unfortunately it hasn't worked out. But they made a bold move.
BLacey: Spending large sums on analytics is useless if you don’t have the athletes to implement what the analytics tell you. What needs to be changed to improve player developments?
nubyjas wilborn: you make a fair point, but player development takes time. Some times much longer than we want.
Dear Don: Yes, you are missing something--Nutting's net worth is useless. How much he is worth on paper doesn't mean anything. Heck, his net worth means absolutely nothing, because it's the revenue generated by the team that matters, not him personally. That's common sense.
nubyjas wilborn: Not quite a question but a fair counterpoint. I'll allow it.
burt reynolds: Nubyjas, I know it is frustrating to follow the Buccos, and I see why people are mad. However, I find it annoying when people come into these chats and yell at your about ownership, like you can do something about it. Just wanted to say you always do a nice job handling those types of comments gracefully.
nubyjas wilborn: It's all good. I also know that I see things differently than a lot of media here which is good and bad. But if the worst part of my day is a few angry people on here or Twitter I'm having pretty good days.
Gregory P: They can’t really be counting on me to fill RF, can they? I remember you defend my defense like I was your first born, so thanks again for that.
nubyjas wilborn: Talk about an exaggeration. Bless your heart.
Tim: Don"t you feel sorry for Steve Blass? The timing of Hurdles firing was poor. The public relations dept.has to be going nuts.
nubyjas wilborn: He didn't feel sorry for himself. Blass enjoyed the day and the weekend and the season (as much as he could with the losing)
Ernie H: For an owner who tosses nickels around like they're manhole covers, it surprises me that they seem ready to pick up the option on Chris Archer. Do you believe this is a good risk, or do you think the money could be put to more effective use? Compare Archer's cost and production to Ivan Nova's, just as a convenient example.
nubyjas wilborn: I think they will pick up the option on Archer. I think they should as well. I still believe there is a better pitcher than he's shown. Maybe a new pitching coach brings it out of him...
Give me a break: You sighted the Archer trade as an example of fans “wanting it both ways.” The reality is it was a bad move. A desperation move. Many analysts expected Archer’s decline. And are you an extension of the Pirates PR dept cause it sure sounds like it.
nubyjas wilborn: Gees, you need a snack. I said what I said, though. They made a move that hasn't worked. But they thought they were getting a front line starter to push them toward the playoffs. it failed. Also, let's see Glasnow have a full healthy season.
Jay: Have you followed Dejan and his attempts to get nutting to open the books? I think he is pulling out the major issues and is onto something with public funding, amongst other issues. Your thoughts?
Billy : Dejan K had a twitter back and forth with the mayor the other day and it seems that Mayor Peduto might start looking into the owner's books and investigate the guy. Do you believe this?
nubyjas wilborn: I posted both because y'all asked similar questions. There is an argument that a team is a public trust and should do its best to win. I somewhat agree, I'd love for the Pirates to be better, it'd make my life easier in a few ways. However, I'm not sure how I feel about the government getting involved. It is interesting to watch. If nothing else, Dejan is a passionate man when it comes to the fans and teams here.
Mattingly: Nubyjas, I enjoy the perspective you have of the Pirates, and you're correct about Bob Nutting. He can run his business anyway he chooses. Your columns are as close as I've gotten to PNC park in the last 2 years. I've made my choice as well, and other should to. PS- the term "shame on you" is really overused on the 'internets'.
nubyjas wilborn: Thank you. I'm passionate about telling the full story. Even if it upsets people or doesn't win me friends. I honor your choices.
AJ: How many more days do we have to endure you on the Pirates beat? I'd rather watch paint dry.
nubyjas wilborn: You know you looooove me. You know how I know you looooove me? Because you could be anywhere else in the world but you're right here talking to me. And I appreciate that. Thank you for your readership, AJ, you're a saint. Keep reading.
Baz: If I turn out to be good, the Archer trade may well go down in the annals as the worst trade this side of Babe Ruth? And yes, I need to have it both ways....
nubyjas wilborn: okay, call me when you get to the show and when Glasnow pitches a full season with good results.
Sandy: What the hell does Frank Coonelly even do? And I am 100% serious.
nubyjas wilborn: day-to-day operations of the organization
Jeff: How does what he do differ from what Huntingdon does?
nubyjas wilborn: Huntington is in charge of baseball operations. Frank biz development. Frank is the second-highest-ranking person other than Bob. Frank handles TV deals, naming rights, a litany of other business related deals for the team.
Sandy: So what does day to day operations even mean? You really must be part od the lame Pirates PR spin team.
nubyjas wilborn: Now, see, if I clapped back, I'd be wrong after this rude comment that is questioning my integrity. If you wanted elaboration all you had to was ask. But as I said, to Jeff, Frank handles the business side of the ballclub. That includes but isn't limited, TV rights, naming rights, MLB negotiations, stadium development, etc,
Nancy: If I could perhaps make a suggestion Nubyjas. Maybe if you replied to our comments in the PG comments section after you write an article that would win you some points with the readers. You never even reply to anybody's comments game after game and I think it's rude.
nubyjas wilborn: Nancy, is it really rude? Or you just don't like me, which is fine, I won't lose sleep. No Post-Gazette writer replies to the comments. Which comments should I reply to? The ones calling me an idiot or the ones that are worse? I'm extremely accessible via, Twitter @nwilborn19, my email nwilborn@post-gazette.com and these chats which I do twice a month. Until the editors ask me to reply to comment section you can reach me via the options I gave.
GPT: Good lord, people. Wilborn isn't part of the Bucs FO. Write Frank or Bob an e-mail if you need to get some anger off your chest. To NW - Has there been any indication from your interactions with the Pirates management that they plan on being a little more aggressive in free agency, given that a new TV is coming and the stink of this season needs washed away with some hope (even a little)?
nubyjas wilborn: Honestly, as of now, they seem content to mostly bring back the current roster, I think they'll make some moves but I don;t expect splashes.
Josh: Even if the government does get involved, baseball doesn't allow teams to open their books; it's in the rules. I wonder how those two collide.
nubyjas wilborn: I'm curious to see how it plays out if at all.
Sandy: I wouldn't hire that guy to do anything.
nubyjas wilborn: good for him, you don't have that option.
Nancy: Sorry Nubyjas you are wrong. Paul Zeise has commented a few times to people when he has written a column. I think you are making excuses tsk tsk tsk. Not a nice way to win people over. Right now you aren't well liked so you need to try and change things up. I was a teacher for 30 years so I know.
nubyjas wilborn: Funny how the only other black writer is the one who has to reply to people being rude in the comment section. Hmmmmm.
Corey: They are content to bring back the current roster? Oh you mean the same roster that couldn't even win 70 games and that won 24 games in the 2nd half of the season? Boy aren't I all excited.
nubyjas wilborn: I didn't say it was right or wrong. I'm giving you what I believe based on my interactions.
nubyjas wilborn: I'll take a few more good questions if anyone has any?
Spitting in the wind: This group of clowns realizing that they have a problem with their player dev is exactly the problem. These folks got us at this point after 12 yrs. They AREN’T qualified to fix the problem they caused.
nubyjas wilborn: They realize there is a problem.
Corey: Why did Jordan Lyles look so great as soon as he left here? To me that raises so many red flags with the pitching approach the Pirates use.
nubyjas wilborn: He had some injuries that hampered him a bit. But remember there was a 6 week stretch when he was the best Pirate pitcher
Dejan: Have we buried the hatchet? You still a subscriber I hope?
nubyjas wilborn: yes, we even hugged it out.
Realignment: Any chance of baseball division realignment. Get tired of seeing the cubs 19 times a year. Like to see other teams more from the east and west.
nubyjas wilborn: The next CBA is possible.
John: Love your columns and your chats. Don't pay attention to the haters....What free agent catchers do you think the Pirates might take a look at?
nubyjas wilborn: Yasmani Grandal, Jason Castro would be my targets. Also, thank you so much!
Jeff H.: What are your thoughts on the wild card game? I think it's incredibly stupid. My suggestion for improvement would be to either 1. expand the wild card to a best of 3, or 2., seed the teams by record and the worst teams play the wild card game. 2015 really bothered me when you had 2 of the top 3 teams in ALL OF BASEBALL play in the wild card game. I would have put that '15 team up against anyone in a 7 game series.
nubyjas wilborn: I enjoyed last night's game with Brewers & Nats there was so much drama. I like the win or go home scenario. But it also has to not be fun when you're the losing squad.
Drew: I know there was more than meets the eye as to why all of a sudden Bill Brink left the beat early in the season. I wish you would fill us all in.
nubyjas wilborn: we're one of the few papers that has a sports enterprise reporter and it's a wonderful opportunity. He also gets more chances to be at home with his lovely wife.
Mark: Hey Nubyjas. A lot of us look forward to your chats so ignore the knuckleheads. Do you think the Braves can whip the Redbirds?
nubyjas wilborn: thank you, Mark. I think the Braves should win the series.
Honus: Why was Chisenhall allowed to stay home all season recovering from his injury?
nubyjas wilborn: I don't know. They allowed it. But he did the same with the Indians last season.
DJ: Also to follow up on previous Q, in 13-15 the FO had success when being selective and adding legitimate FA/Trade Pieces i.e. Martin, Liriano, Burnett, Since that time it seems the FO has been a strictly trying to reclaim declining players vs known commodities or at least guys you can have a sense what they will bring to team.
nubyjas wilborn: They have taken a conservative approach.
Corey : You never answered my question about whether you think they should fire assistant pitching coach Justin Meccage along with Searage. I think they both need to go.
nubyjas wilborn: sorry. I think they'll both go.
Directile Mysfunction: Just curious. What’s the chain of command in the organization? Does Neal report to Coonelly or directly to Nutting?
nubyjas wilborn: to Connelly
Bruno: You gonna try and do an interview with Vasquez while he is locked up here in Pennsylvania? I think it would be a pretty interesting interview if he would agree to it.
nubyjas wilborn: This would be interesting. I'd love to know what he's thinking,.
DJ: Last years free agent market had several reasonably priced FA’s given the reluctance to sign guys to long term deals. Given they went “all in” with Archer and Kela was there any indication why the FO was not willing to add more given the payroll well below previous season? This is where I think a large part of reason the fans are so distrusting of the FO.
nubyjas wilborn: They cited stats on WAR and fWAR as to why they didn't target certain high dollar free agents
Directile Mysfunction: All things being equal, does NH make it two more years? If he does, does Nutting extend his contract?
nubyjas wilborn: I think so. It seems like he's here to stay.
GPT: The Chisenhall thing is fascinating. A mild calf strain and he's done for the year? Any idea if he pulled an 'Operation Shutdown' like Derek Bell did so many years ago?
nubyjas wilborn: I don't think it's that. But it was disappointing that he wasn't around.
Jon Snow: I know the pitching was a big part of their failure this year but I also believe losing Cervelli was a huge problem. Do you believe they will go out and get a good catcher.
nubyjas wilborn: Yes they needed him behind the plate and as a leader. He was missed a lot. I think they will have no choice.
DJ: Thanks for response. I understand game is analytically driven but just frustrating aspect as a fan is the Pirates seem to approach roster construction hoping that all the stars align and everything pans out. In a game of imperfection it is tough to get behind the plan when options such as Wade Miley, Charlie Morton were options in FA.
nubyjas wilborn: I understand your frustration. It'll be interesting to see what they do this offseason.
nubyjas wilborn: Okay, ladies and gentlemen, I'm out.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.