At some point soon, perhaps as early as next week, Pirates owner Bob Nutting will appear before members of the media at PNC Park and take questions.

There will be no shortage of things to ask.

Never before during Nutting’s tenure as owner have the Pirates experienced this much turmoil, the season unraveling in the second half amid multiple altercations involving coaches and players, an alarming number of empty seats and the whole Felipe Vazquez mess.

Through it all, Nutting has remained silent — reportedly not OK with it all, but also not compelled, for whatever reason, to step to the forefront and speak.

Advertise with us

The last time anyone heard from Nutting was spring training, when he outlined how he thought this year’s group would win … which turned out to be horrendously wrong.

"The expectation of the fan base should be that we put a competitive team on the field that is built to win,” Nutting said back February. “That’s what their expectations deserve to be.

"Frankly, I think that a seven-game improvement [in 2018] was a meaningful step forward, and we are absolutely positioned to take another meaningful step forward and get us back into that range where we have a very good shot at playoffs and, once you get into the playoffs, of moving down the pike.”

The Pirates finished the 2018 season with a record of 82-79. They awoke Thursday 67-91 — at most an 11-win decrease from this previous season. The playoffs, as Nutting mentioned, seem miles away.

So, with that in mind, whenever he does talk, what should be asked of the Pirates owner?

Advertise with us

1. Why did you keep your primary leaders — president Frank Coonelly, general manager Neal Huntington and manager Clint Hurdle — in place, or why did you make moves?

It’s one of the most basic questions but also among the most important: the key to the direction of the franchise. And if any/all are dismissed, it’ll be fascinating to hear who lacked what and where it all came apart.

Whether he stays or goes, it should also be asked who supposedly gave Hurdle assurance that his job was safe and whether that affected the decision in any way.

While we debate the future of those three, it’s almost assumed at this point that pitching coach Ray Searage will be gone, the fall guy for a staff with possibly the franchise’s worst ERA since the 1800s.

2. Huntington has indicated that the pitching staff will largely be the same, with the possible addition of a back-of-the-rotation type. He’s painted a similar picture with position players. Why should fans believe that 2020 will be different?

Advertise with us

If you have the same people doing the same things, it’s tough to effect change.

Keeping the team’s key decision-makers inherently leaves undressed the altercations that have occurred between Keone Kela and Hector Morales (director of cultural initiatives); Kyle Crick and bullpen coach Euclides Rojas; and Crick and Vazquez, who traded punches in the clubhouse.

And not that anyone had reason to believe the club’s All-Star closer was fooling around with an underage girl, but it would also bring back the same group that presided over that whole fiasco.

3. How would you best describe the big-picture goals of the Pirates right now?

If Nutting thinks the Pirates can contend for a playoff spot, he should be comfortable explaining how they’re going to get there, the same for entering rebuild mode.

Advertise with us

The biggest problem is that the Pirates aren’t definitively in one category or the other; they’re caught in between, with very little help on the way.

Bottom line, it’s long overdue for Nutting to state what the franchise’s goal should be here moving forward.

4. How will you address the altercations that occurred this season involving both players and coaches?

Not that these are not alleged or reported incidents. They happened. The team acknowledged it. They released the information. We’re not talking about any sort of media fabrication.

Surely Nutting doesn’t think these things are normal or acceptable. In fact, his general manager admitted as much recently.

Advertise with us

“Obviously there are some lessons to be learned,” Huntington said two weeks ago. “We’ve tried to handle each situation head-on versus letting it either slide or pushing it under the rug and not acknowledging it because we want to handle it. We want to learn from it. We want to grow from it. “

5. Building off of that, Mr. Nutting, do you expect the perception of the Pirates right now — given the fights, the second-half collapse and the Vazquez stuff — to make it difficult to attract free agents?

Money talks, and if the Pirates threw around more of it in free agency, this wouldn’t matter.

But if the Pirates are bargain shopping along with a couple other teams and the offers are the same to free agents, which team do you think they’re going to choose?

It’s not enough that the off-field garbage has sabotaged this season. The Pirates — and Nutting — should be worried about it becoming a stench they’re unable to wash off their clothes.

Advertise with us

6. We can probably agree one of the most consistent criticisms of your ownership is that you don’t spend enough. Do you agree with that? Why/why not?

According to Baseball Prospectus, the Pirates have been an average of $45.1 million under the average Major League Baseball payroll every year since 2007. At the same time, according to Baseball Prospectus, the Pirates have spent an average of $66.4 million on players’ salaries during that time.

There are obviously some changes there due to the economy and the financial landscape within MLB, but this year the disparity between the Pirates and the league average is the worst it’s ever been.

The Pirates, again per Baseball Prospectus, spent roughly $74.8 million on players’ salaries. The MLB average is $134.7 million, meaning player salary-wise, the Pirates are operating at a little over half-capacity.

If the Pirates are spending enough, it will be interesting to hear Nutting explain how that’s happening.

Advertise with us

7. What do you like about owning the Pirates?

Everybody has a reason they do things, right? In this job, you want to write a good story or have something that nobody else has. Sales people want to sell. Contractors want to build cool stuff.

Does Nutting want to win? Does he like baseball? Does he want this for his kids?

We hear a lot about how the Pirates can’t spend like other teams. Fine. But is there some sort of goal to eventually get there? If Nutting likes baseball and wants to be the best, having a plan to get there should be the goal, no?

8. What can the Pirates as an organization learn from the Vazquez situation?

Advertise with us

It’s useless to ask whether the Pirates expected anything like this. They did not. Nobody did. And they received no indication there was an investigation into Vasquez’s personal life, per usual for those sort of things.

But they’re obviously not allegations anyone should take lightly. The Pirates should be looking at this as an opportunity to at least learn something.

9. Why should a fan invest his or her time/money into your team right now?

For a game against the Brewers last weekend, the Pirates fielded a team that made a combined $5,130,500. Seven Brewers will make more by themselves in 2019, while Ryan Braun will make more than three times as much.

On Wednesday, the Pirates took the field in a game directly influencing the National League playoff picture with a lineup where eight of the nine players spent time this season in Triple-A.

Advertise with us

Nutting will likely say something here about limitations or finding other ways to win.

That’s fine, but Milwaukee is a similar market. The Brewers have also drafted and developed much better than the Pirates, which leads us to the next question …

10. Do you see a problem with how those below you are drafting and developing players? Why or why not?

Give the man a chance on his terms, first off. But it would involve some serious mental gymnastics to say the Pirates have been even remotely adequate in this area.

The Pirates have struggled drafting the right guys. For those they do draft, getting them to realize their full potential here has been a struggle, especially with pitchers.

Advertise with us

There should be an explanation on if Nutting is OK with this and what, if anything, the Pirates plan to change when it comes to drafting and development.

11. Have you ever thought about spending more, with the expectation that you’ll make more money off the Pirates? If not, what has stopped you from doing this?

The Pirates are profitable. In Forbes’ annual valuations, they ranked 20th out of 30 MLB teams ($1.275 billion), with a 2018 operating income of $39 million that ranked 12th in baseball.

Say the Pirates spend a little more, and it works out. Pittsburgh is a great sports town. Wouldn’t the fans respond accordingly and, thus, make the Pirates even more profitable for Nutting?

It’s a business strategy that has been employed before.

Advertise with us

12. Do you have any interest in selling the team?

It’s doubtful Nutting addresses a group of reporters and drops this bombshell, but you have to ask.

The Pirates are worth a lot of money right now (see above), and Nutting could make a substantial profit if he got out. It’s happened to the Miami Marlins and Kansas City Royals within the past two years. Why not the Pirates?

Can't get enough of our in-depth Pirates coverage?

Support quality journalism. Subscribe today.

Jason Mackey: jmackey@post-gazette.com and Twitter @JMackeyPG.