Joe Musgrove on his Thursday performance
It never should have come to this.
While that sentence could probably describe the Pirates’ entire 2019 season, it also came into play on Thursday in the 11th inning against the Mariners at PNC Park.
With runners on first and third, Pirates second baseman Kevin Kramer had to make a split-second decision — one that cost the Pirates a key run in a 6-5 loss, the sixth straight for the beleaguered ballclub.
There was plenty of nuance to what Kramer did, but the bigger-picture point is simple: The Pirates right now have a razor-thin margin for error.
They haven’t hit a home run in six games, and four of their five runs Thursday came in one inning. The Pirates had totaled one run in their previous 18 innings against Seattle.
“We haven’t been barreling balls up,” manager Clint Hurdle said. “That’s been the story. ... We had one inning where we had some extra-base hits, but outside of that, it’s been a little barren.”
Read More
Kramer wasn’t wrong to do what he did. With one out, the Pirates had their corners up and middle back, meaning a hard-hit ball to first or third necessitates a throw home. One up the middle means turn two.
Seattle’s Austin Nola did neither. His soft grounder to Kramer negated the possibility of a quick double play. Kramer also couldn’t tag catcher Omar Narvaez running from first to second to get the second out.
Playing the infield that way also made sense. Play everyone in, and you cover less ground. You also almost assuredly won’t turn two.
But it didn’t afford Kramer much time to potentially nail Shed Long at home given the leadoff man’s speed. So Kramer did the best he could and initiated a double play, though one that didn’t finish until the run had scored.
“It’s unfortunate,” Kramer said. “I was trying to be aggressive and go right after him, but [going to first] was the play I thought was best. That’s just how it worked out.”
Added Hurdle, “I don’t think he had a play at the plate. The ball was hit too soft.”
Again, it never should have come to that when you consider the Pirates’ mistakes in this one:
- Long reached on an error by Jose Osuna to start the inning.
- The Mariners tied the game, 5-5, when Francisco Liriano issued a pair of two-out walks in the seventh inning before Nola dumped a single into right.
- Seattle scored four runs in the second, helped along by Cole Tucker’s wild throw and Joe Musgrove’s inability to field a sacrifice bunt off the mound. The Pirates now lead the National League in errors with 112. They’re 28th in Major League Baseball, their fielding a surefire problem they need to address in 2020.
The miscues were unfortunate for the Pirates (65-88) because they had a couple interesting things happen on Thursday.
Joe Musgrove made his 30th start of the season — he said it accomplished a preseason goal — and wound up bouncing back from that troublesome second inning, when he relied on his curveball a little too much and got burned.
Musgrove wound up allowing four runs (two earned) over five innings with two walks and six strikeouts.
“It’s something for me to build on, for sure, especially late in the year being able to still have quality stuff and still be able to get outs and navigate through games,” Musgrove said of making start No. 30, a milestone for starting pitchers. “It’s really important to me.”
So was what transpired in the second inning. It was sort of hilarious, too.
That’s when the Pirates exploded for four doubles, an out-of-nowhere splash of power. Musgrove drove a ball to the gap in right-center field and started to think about a triple.
Until, of course, his legs got a little tangled around set, and he wound up crashing to the dirt. Musgrove ultimately retreated back to second and figured it was probably a good thing, too.
“There might’ve been a chance of me getting thrown out at third,” he said.
On Kevin Newman’s single, which extended his hitting streak to 13 games, Musgrove came around to score with a head-first slide into home.
For a pitcher, that’s not normal. Then again, Musgrove isn’t your average pitcher. He’s a position player trapped in a pitcher’s body.
“That heart beats hard,” Hurdle said. “It beats fast when he’s competing, and it’s something I don’t want to mess with right now. It can be contagious as well, and we could use some of that.”
Added Musgrove, “My hip kind of hurt after busting ass to second base. The more athletic play, the better way to avoid the tag and make sure that we score the run is go head-first. I’m comfortable doing that.”
The Pirates also got three hits from Jake Elmore, which was another great story by itself. Elmore was shopping for a sectional sofa a couple days ago when he learned that he had been promoted to the major leagues, long after rosters had expanded at the start of September.
He had also been stuck in an 0-for-19 skid at this level before he doubled in the second inning.
Elmore, a career minor-leaguer, finished second in the International League in batting (.322) and fourth in on-base percentage (.387), and he deserved the chance to show what he can do the rest of the way.
“He got real engaged [Thursday]. Good for him,” Hurdle said. “He worked extremely hard for us all year in Triple-A. Showed up well. Worked with the younger players. He’s a professional.
“It’s nice to see a guy like that go out and be able to have a game because the hits were few and far between his first time up. It was a good day for him.”
Jason Mackey: jmackey@post-gazette.com and Twitter @JMackeyPG.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.