It is hard to get through a Pirates broadcast these days without someone reminding you that outfielder Bryan Reynolds and shortstop Kevin Newman are poised to become a rare duo to hit .300 or better as rookies.
Who, really, can blame those someones? In this lost season, the hope needs to come from somewhere.
Like most back-of-the-baseball card stats, though, this one does not tell the full story of their respective seasons. Even as those two and first baseman Josh Bell have performed at encouraging levels, they still remain a ways off from true star-level production that the Pirates need to form a young core of a winning team in the years to come.
Consider: Reynolds leads the team with 3.4 wins above replacement through Wednesday, according to Fangraphs. WAR, as we’ve discussed before, is not a perfect stat. But it gives us a nice baseline to gauge a player’s total value to a team, offensively and defensively.
Reynolds’ number puts him solidly in what Fangraphs calls “good player” territory, between 3.0 and 4.0 WAR. Outfielder Starling Marte follows him at 3.0, and Bell (2.5), Newman (2.3) and Adam Frazier (2.2) round out the team’s top five. All four are what Fangraphs would consider “solid starters” on its WAR scale.
None of those five players, you’ll notice, come close to the higher rungs on the ladder: All-Star at 4.0 to 5.0 WAR, superstar at 5.0 to 6.0 WAR or MVP at 6.0-plus WAR.
Read More
Therein lies the problem for the Pirates. Even with all the good things some of their young position players have done this season, their success must be qualified for a clear-eyed view of where they stand. Good, but still a fair distance from great.
True, most of them are pretty young and have room to grow into bigger numbers. In that group of five, only Marte is 28 or older, meaning they’re just entering their primes. Career years may well be ahead for all four.
Still, it’s important to keep their present production in proper perspective and talk about them in terms of what they are instead of what they could be. Consider the following an exercise in balance.
The 2013 Pirates that general manager Neal Huntington has — conveniently — compared both the 2019 and ’20 bunches to had three lineup regulars post an fWAR greater than 4.0: Andrew McCutchen (8.1), Russell Martin (5.4) and Marte (4.3.)
The 2014 club had four players in that category: McCutchen (7.4), Josh Harrison (4.8), Marte (4.5) and Neil Walker (4.1).
And the 2015 team that won 98 games? They only had two, but those two produced a lot; McCutchen was at 6.0 with Francisco Cervelli close behind at 5.9.
If you’re not already sensing a theme, consider some division opponents in the thick of the playoff race.
Both the Chicago Cubs and Milwaukee Brewers have at least two players at 4.0 or better. Only the division-leading St. Louis Cardinals are stuck below the 4.0 mark. Paul DeJong and Kolten Wong lead them with 3.7 WAR apiece.
All of those examples cast the Pirates’ feel-good performers more as solid complementary pieces and than franchise building blocks.
That’s not a knock on them so much as a critique of this team’s construction. In an ideal world, these guys would be supporting bigger stars. In the Pirates’ world, they are the stars.
Pitching, most would agree, remains the club’s biggest problem. If, somehow, it’s addressed in a meaningful way this offseason, the Pirates have a chance to be much better.
The lineup, however, is by no means complete. More production needs to come from somewhere, or those someones may need to dig even deeper to produce hopeful statistical nuggets.
Adam Bittner: abittner@post-gazette.com and Twitter @fugimaster24.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.