Kyle Crick discusses altercation with teammate Felipe Vazquez

SAN FRANCISCO — Pirates reliever Kyle Crick is out until 2020 after injuring his finger in an altercation with closer Felipe Vazquez, the team announced late Tuesday.

The incident happened in the clubhouse before the game Monday against the Giants.

“The behavior exhibited by these two players last night is unacceptable, inconsistent with the standards expected of a Major League player and will not be tolerated by the organization,” GM Neal Huntington said in a statement.

The Pirates said both players were fined an undisclosed amount for the altercation. After the incident, Crick had surgery Tuesday in San Francisco to repair a tendon in his right index finger. The Pirates project him to be ready in time for spring training.

Advertise with us

This is Crick’s second incident with a member of the Pirates organization. This summer, Crick and bullpen coach Euclides Rojas were involved in an altercation that resulted in Rojas’ suspension. Crick also was suspended three games this season for his role in the benches-clearing brawl against the Reds in Cincinnati.

Pirates manager Clint Hurdle addressed what losing Crick does to the bullpen after the Pirates’ 5-4 loss on Tuesday.

“Kyle Crick was such a valuable part of our bullpen last year and like many of our guys had a solid first half,” Hurdle said. “He was meeting some challenges in the second half trying to get better. It’s a man down. It’s a man we won’t be able to go to. Part of the September surplus is that some guys will get opportunities. It’s unfortunate that his season ended that way.”

Hurdle also expressed concern about the third known incident within the Pirate clubhouse.

“I have concerns about three individual incidents that have gone on this year. I’ve been here nine years and we’ve had none,” Hurdle said. “Now we’ve had three this year. Two that resulted in suspensions and one that had fines involved. We’ve spoken to the club today. We had a conversation. We revisited internally as a family about how we meet challenges and rise above them.”

Advertise with us

Crick gave his side of the story in the same visiting clubhouse where the fight happened.

“It was one of those clubhouse altercations. A lot bickering back and forth,” Crick said. “Punches were thrown and at some point stand up for yourself and start throwing them back. It’s one of those deals where it’s unfortunate. There are two losers in this deal. Nobody can win a fight with a teammate.”

Crick said that Vazquez threw the first punch, and Crick believed he acted in self-defense. The reliever was also disappointed that his season ended because of an altercation with a teammate.

“It’s about the most unfortunate thing that can happen in a season,” Crick said. “Getting injured off the field is never a good thing.”

According to Crick, it was nowhere near the first time that he and Vazquez had a disagreement.

Advertise with us

“I don’t know if anything really started it,” Crick said. “Things happen over the course of a season. It’s been a tough season. Frustration is pretty high. It got to a boiling point and it tipped over.”

Vazquez declined the opportunity to comment on the situation.

Baseball players are around each other every day from the start of spring training in February until the end of the season in October.  A lot of issues can fester over that time, especially if a team is under-performing. Hurdle understands the rigors of a long season better than most. He also seemed to be grappling with finding a way to fix the issues.

“Anytime you have a family that spends a lot of time together as teams do in sport… Nobody likes when it happens but unfortunately, it does happen,” Hurdle said. “What can you learn from it? How do you put yourself in a better position for it not to happen again? That’s my concern. That’s my directive. That’s what comes on my plate as everything else does under my leadership title.”

“I’m looking for ways to make a difference or provide a better understanding of the standards that we have in place that need to be followed. Choices are made every day by everybody. We can’t choose the circumstances of our choices sometimes. And sometimes those circumstances are unfortunate. We need to get better in some areas there.”

Advertise with us

Hurdle ended the post-game press conference by reiterating that the team is working to regain a positive atmosphere.

“You have those conversations. There’s been suspensions. When people are pulled from play or fined money you get their attention,” Hurdle said. “We need to get a change of thought when times get itchy or get complicated or there’s a challenge professionally or personally. How do you meet those challenges? How do you overcome? How do you rise above and find a way to work within the group? That’s what my goal needs to be. I need to provide the right kind of direction for this to stop.”

Nubyjas Wilborn: nwilborn@post-gazette.com and Twitter @nwilborn19.