Welcome to the Pirates mailbag. As always, submit your questions via Twitter @nwilborn19 or email nwilborn@post-gazette.com. We received quite a few questions this week about the Pirates as well as other topics. We’ll touch on those non-baseball items at the end. Let’s get started:

Harry Silver: What happened to those 89 wins you predicted?

Nubyjas: I believed the Pirates would get strong performances from their starting pitching and bullpen. I was wrong. Injuries and poor play have beset them. I also didn’t realize they were going to be so fundamentally deficient.

The players play hard and don’t quit, as evidenced by the comeback win on Monday. But if they cashed in on several missed opportunities, they wouldn’t have needed a dramatic comeback.

Advertise with us

I believed that they would be good this season. I was wrong.

@rogerhuffman: Do you still think (Gregory) Polanco is better?

Nubyjas: Roger is referring to an article where I said I trusted Polanco more in right field than Bryan Reynolds. My argument at the time was that Reynolds had only played five or games in right whereas Polanco had more experience.

The beauty of time is that it informs our opinions. Reynolds has proven that he is a more than capable defender and a great hitter. He is a special talent.

But let’s not forget how good a healthy Polanco is. I think the best Pirate outfield for 2020 is Reynolds in left, Starling Marte in center, and Polanco — if healthy — in right.

Advertise with us

As far as who’s better? It’s hard to argue against Reynolds, but remember, it’s only been one season. Let’s see how the league adjusts and how Reynolds handles it.

Big shoutout to Ron Southwick. He had several questions.

Ron Southwick: Hey. I’m a big fan of the Pirates and I’ve enjoyed your coverage. Got a few questions I’m submitting in case there’s one that isn’t already asked. Here’s my biggest: What’s the status w/ Gregory Polanco? I know he’s done for this year but is he expected to be ready to go for 2020? Is he looking at any other surgical procedures in the offseason?

Nubyjas: It’s uncertain on Polanco. Pirates general manager Neal Huntington said that surgery isn’t out of the question.

“As complicated as his first surgery was, the challenges that we’ve had coming back through that, we can’t ever rule it out,” Huntington said. “They may need to try to get in there.”

Advertise with us

I wish I had more, but we don’t know. We’ll talk to the team doctor on Wednesday and hope to have more clarity then.

Ron: Is Cole Tucker likely the starting SS next year with Kevin Newman moving to second?

Nubyjas: There’s no reason to move Frazier or Newman unless Tucker forces the issue by hitting much better. Tucker is a great defensive player and will improve there. He has great skills. But he has to hit.

Ron: How does Adam Frazier fit in the picture: super-utility guy? I’d hoped for a bit more from him, but he’s hitting well this month so it’d be nice to see a strong finish.

Nubyjas: It depends on him; he’s the second baseman for now. He’s taken well to hitting seventh and that makes the Pirates lineup dangerous. He doesn’t have the greatest range, but he’s well-positioned on most plays and gets to balls.

Advertise with us

Ron: Are the Bucs going to look for a catcher in the offseason or are they hoping Elias Diaz can improve? It’s kind of a lost year for him, and I thought he could show himself as a viable starting catcher based on a promising 2018. I’m amazed he only has 2 HR all year compared to last year, when he had 10. And he’s actually had more at-bats this year.

Nubyjas: He’s regressed some. The problem with replacing him is the overall shortage of catching talent in baseball. I’m not certain that the Pirates will do what it takes to get one of the few good catchers that exist.

Now onto those non-baseball questions:

William Thornton: Why do you like AB so much? What’s the deal; don’t you understand that you live in Pittsburgh?

Nubyjas: OK, this got out of hand. Initially, I found it bizarre that more people spoke about Antonio Brown than any of the current players. I also thought it was comical that people thought the Steelers would get better without him. But yes, Brown behaved poorly on several occasions. I get why the Steelers parted ways. All I’ve said is that you don’t lose a player of his caliber and get better. That said, I do think the Steelers can have a good season despite the loss to the Patriots.

Advertise with us

Mitchell Watkins: Why do you hate the Steelers?

Nubyjas: I don’t hate the Steelers. I have no emotional attachment to them or any team. Steelers coverage drives the bus at the Post-Gazette. It’d be foolish of me to hate them or wish them ill will.

I’m assuming you asked the question because of what you perceive as my support of Brown. Let me be clear. I’ll never be the type of person to root for another man to fail. I can want the Steelers to do well and still want Brown to have success. I also understand that it may not make yinz happy.

Robert: Why does it seem like you’ve picked fights on Twitter?

Nubyjas Wilborn: I apologize that it seems that way. However, it isn’t true. I had an issue with some folks, and we’re in good places now.

Advertise with us

What’s the lesson? I need to chill on Twitter and not have rabbit ears. I’m better than that. Most importantly, the Post-Gazette is better than this. I will be better. I owe it to too many people who have poured into me.

Nubyjas Wilborn: nwilborn@post-gazette.com and Twitter @nwilborn19