PHILADELPHIA — Serving as a vocal leader has never been a problem for Andrew McCutchen. During his nine years with the Pirates, McCutchen stepped up and delivered a message plenty of times. But in the back of his mind, McCutchen always wondered whether that message got through.
Because as accomplished as McCutchen was, especially when he finished top-five in National League MVP voting during a four-year stretch from 2012-15, he simply never experienced something some of his teammates did — failure.
Now, after a difficult two-year stretch that saw McCutchen bounce from the Giants to the Yankees to the Phillies, with little on-field success along the way, the former franchise player for the Pirates feels like he has a little bit of a difference voice, one that can help him relate to every player on the Phillies roster.
“It’s a cool concept because you’re able to say certain things, and more people are going to listen because of your experience and because of the teams you’ve been on, people you’ve been around and encountered, the success and the failures you’ve had,” McCutchen told the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette. “People are listening more than they would when I was finishing Top 4 or 5 in MVP voting for four years in a row. People listen, but they don’t because they say you’ve never struggled. It’s just a different thing now. I’m able to talk and more people listen, because of your experiences, because of your highs and lows.”
This year has been a tough one for McCutchen, who suffered a season-ending ACL injury in June. McCutchen had surgery and still spends time around the club at home, though he doesn’t travel, instead spending the time around his family.
He’s followed the Pirates some from afar, but he’s also been plenty consumed by his own situation.
Read More
Nevertheless, McCutchen has been surprised to see the Pirates struggling so much, especially out of the All-Star break.
“I see where they are in the standings,” McCutchen said. “Seeing what their record is, it doesn’t seem like they should have the record that they have with the team that they have. That’s a bit odd.”
Pirates manager Clint Hurdle still talks to McCutchen around once a week, usually via text, and called him “one of my favorites.”
On the opposite end of the spectrum, Hurdle can see where McCutchen is coming from. In his career, Hurdle said he had a tough time relating to star players.
But Hurdle has been impressed watching McCutchen handle everything later in his career and also thriving and maturing as a leader.
“That presence that he has now, he’s been through hard, he’s made it look easy, he’s had some success, he’s had some challenges,” Hurdle said. “He’s fought back and recreated himself in some ways as well. There’s a lot of experience to pull from. He’s a dad. He’s gone through all that. And he’s been moved a few times now. He’s had some different experiences and environments to pull from. He’s putting together a pretty nice mosaic.”
Can’t get enough of our in-depth Pirates coverage?
Support quality journalism. Subscribe today.
Moran hitting lefties
For much of this season and last year, Hurdle was hesitant to use Colin Moran against left-handed pitchers. Now, that could be changing.
Moran has seven hits in his last 19 at-bats off lefties (.368) and overall is hitting .302 (16-for-53) against them this season with four extra-base hits.
Moran entered this season with a .194 average (13-for-67) with four total extra-base hits against lefties.
“We’re in a situation now where we’re trying to match him up against certain left-handers to give him a little opportunity for growth,” Hurdle said. “He hit ‘em all through the minor leagues. He hit ‘em through college. It’s not like you’re asking a guy to do something he hasn’t done.
“Sometimes you have matchups in positions where you break players in and need to take advantage of two players at one position. We have the opportunity right now to give a little more opportunity and see some left-handers. I think he’s handled ‘em very well.”
Before this season, Moran said he let hitting left-handed pitching get in his head. He thought about it entirely too much, and that affected the results.
Now, he’s not doing that anymore. He’s treating those at-bats the same as the ones against righties, and the results have been better for it.
“I think maybe last year I tried to make more of an opportunity than it was, trying to do too much,” Moran said. “This year, I’m just treating it like another at-bat, being thankful for an opportunity and trying to make the most of it —not trying to hit a home run every time up there, just trying to carry out a good at-bat when I get an opportunity.”
Jason Mackey: jmackey@post-gazette.com and Twitter @JMackeyPG.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.