Mitch Keller on his tough night in Philadelphia

PHILADELPHIA — This is what the Pirates signed up for with Mitch Keller.

And allowing him to pitch at this level remains the right move, regardless of what transpired Wednesday during a 12-3 loss to the Phillies at Citizens Bank Park, one in which Keller picked up a fair amount of punchouts but was ultimately punched out himself after four-plus innings.

When the Pirates committed to having Keller in their rotation for the duration of this season, it was done for a reason: to allow the 23-year-old rookie to learn on the job, to make some mistakes and not have them disrupt — gasp — some sort of playoff push.

They also went into this knowing there would be a fair number of inconsistent outings, and the Pirates got all of that on Wednesday.

Advertise with us

The right-hander struck out eight, at times looking like the guy who whiffed nine while pitching into the seventh inning during his last time out. There were other portions of this one where Keller looked like someone new to pitching, presenting gifts for Phillies hitters in prime parts of the strike zone.

In addition to his eight strikeouts, Keller wound up allowing eight earned runs during an eventful evening, one that should serve as a teaching point here moving forward.

"There’s never an intent to struggle," Keller said. "But going through the struggles, hopefully down the line it will help me out."

Before digging deeper into where this thing fell apart, it should be noted that the entire evening wasn't Keller's fault.

A night after playing really good defense, the Pirates (56-77) didn’t field the ball particularly well, working around an errant pickoff throw, an overthrow from the outfield and a passed ball that scored a run. They also didn’t mount much in the way of sustained offense, relying instead on home runs from Josh Bell and Starling Marte.

Advertise with us

But during a difficult fifth inning, with the Phillies initially holding a one-run lead, none of that mattered.

Former Pirate Corey Dickerson continued to torture his former team, homering to lead it off. It came on a fastball up in the zone.

Catcher J.T. Realmuto tripled to re-ignite the rally, and the Phillies made it 5-2 with right fielder Bryce Harper’s line drive to right. After a walk issued to first baseman Rhys Hoskins, Jean Segura singled to load the bases.

Instead of going to his bullpen, Pirates manager Clint Hurdle stuck with Keller, who had thrown 94 pitches at that time and had allowed the first five batters of the inning to reach base. Keller could not get a key out, as second baseman Cesar Hernandez singled, scoring two.

“We needed a little bit more from him, so I wanted to give him every opportunity to finish the fifth,” Hurdle said. “It didn’t happen."

Advertise with us

With Yefry Ramirez relieving Keller, the Phillies tacked on an additional run (charged to Keller) on center fielder Adam Haseley’s groundout, but by then, the game was out of reach.

Catcher Jacob Stallings said Keller made some good pitches early on, as indicated by his ability to get swing-and-miss, but the young pitcher seemed to tire in the fifth inning.

“That’s when his execution kind of deteriorated,” Stallings said.

The lesson there could be better pacing or figuring out a way to navigate a sticky situation and to simply make better pitches. However, wiggling out of those jams is hardly automatic. It’s a lesson learned over time.

When Hurdle pulled Keller, he made a double switch that removed Bryan Reynolds — the NL’s batting leader coming in —from the game.

Advertise with us

Afterward, Hurdle explained that he wanted to bury the pitcher’s spot as deep as possible, knowing Ramirez was going to have to eat some innings.

The Pirates’ bullpen has been beaten down, Hurdle argued, and they wanted to start a series with the Rockies on Thursday fresh.

“We had one pitcher that I wanted to use,” Hurdle said. “If you don’t take the full complement of nine hitters, you go seven, the situation might run up where I end up back with [Michael] Feliz or [Richard] Rodriguez in a game where we’re way underneath. I didn’t want to deal with that.”

Ramirez wound up finishing the game, allowing four runs (three earned) on six hits. It let the bullpen rest and Ramirez earned some points in the clubhouse, but the end result was the Pirates dropping the series to the Phillies.

The Pirates were able to get some offense going in the fourth. Marte led off with a single, and Bell took a high fastball the other way, out to left, for a two-run home run.

Advertise with us

It was one of two bombs the Pirates hit against the Phillies. The other came off the bat of Marte in the sixth, a solo shot out to left that had an exit velocity of 111.8 mph and traveled 428 feet, per Statcast.

But none of that came close to the biggest story on this night: Keller learning a valuable lesson, even if it resulted in a loss.

“Any time anybody goes through ups and downs, hopefully they learn from it,” Stallings said. “He’s so young, there’s going to be outings like this right now.

“That’s the challenge for any young player — consistency in the big leagues.”

Jason Mackey: jmackey@post-gazette.com and Twitter @JMackeyPG.