Jason Mackey: Hi folks, welcome to my weekly Pirates chat. We're going to get started at noon. Leave your questions, and I will get back to them then. Thanks, Mackey.

Shiver me Timbers: Hi Jason...with all the talk about Clint Hurdle and Neal Huntington possibly being let go, is there any talk about who might replace them? Thanks.

pozone: Jason any chance Hurdle and Huntingdon get the boot?

Jason Mackey: I think there's a chance, yes. However, I would say Hurdle is more likely than Huntington, if I'm ranking them. But from the sound of it, you don't hear a lot of full-scale changes, which is obviously what would have to happen for Huntington to lose his job. If they replaced Hurdle, I think it would be with someone like Jeff Banister or Tom Prince -- someone on staff.

Advertise with us

GSMP: MLB has always publicly backed Pirates ownership on the team's spending. But is there any sense behind closed doors that MLB is pushing the Pirates to make significant increases in the MLB payroll?

Jason Mackey: I don't think so, in large part because they would have to push a couple other teams first. Plus -- and I know fans don't wanna hear this right now, but it's true -- it wasn't long ago that they were actually competitive. Even at the All-Star break, they were 2 1/2 games out of first place, with the same payroll.

fan: Jason, I was floored by the news of the death of Neal Casal. I think I was perhaps his biggest fan and loved all of his work. Very sad news indeed. Do you happen to know if he ever played with the Dead back in the 60s or if he ever did any work with any modern artists? I haven't followed him in about 15 years or so. Very sad. Thanks Jason

Jason Mackey: I believe Neal was involved in Move Me Brightly, a show that celebrated what would've been Jerry's 70th birthday. Loved Casal. So sad.

Guest: Name of 2020 FA who might sign with the bucs for next season, please.

Advertise with us

Jason Mackey: I don't think it's going to be anybody big, No. 1. Two, perhaps someone like Michael Wacha. But again, it's a little early to start just randomly throwing out names.

GSMP: How would you rate the current state of the Pirates minor league prospects. To me there are some decent prospects like Craig and Hayes. But no one that really gets you excited. Cruz would be the closet. I'd say its a C- right now.

Jason Mackey: I think that's fair. It's certainly not as good as it should be for how they conduct business and where they draft. Quinn Priester -- recently promoted to Morgantown and starting tonight -- is also an intriguing option. He seems to be handling the pro ball thing very well. But they do lack in the upper echelon prospects.

Alex: Jason: Is there a realistic scenario in which Bob Nutting will sell (or be forced) to sell the team so we can get an owner that will increase payroll and spend more money on talented players?

Jason Mackey: I'm sure there's a scenario, but I don't see that as a realistic possibility. It would make sense for Nutting to cash out, with some naming-rights issues with PNC Park and an expiring TV deal ahead. However, I've heard nothing to indicate Nutting is interested in selling.

Advertise with us

histroy buff: Jason, what is the baseball retirement equivalent to Andrew Luck stepping away from the game this week? Historically, I'm guessing maybe Lou Gehrig. Thoughts? Some might say Sandy Koufax.

Jason Mackey: Honestly, I don't know if there's much an equivalent anywhere for a player of Luck's stature doing what he did.

Tito: Mackey, "If I Had the World to Give " by the Grateful Dead (album version). I had it going on repeat yesterday during the Bucs game from the 4th inning on. We won, but it darn near drove my daughter crazy. She doesn't like the Dead all that much. A lot of scholars have talked about music and the connection to positive thinking and extrapolating that to an ability to send positive (or groovy) vibes to help people out. I truly believe that that song helped the Pirates yesterday. Its vibes helped. Have you ever read up on this phenomenon? Also, you might be interested to know that I followed theDEAD for three years in my youth and I met Jerry and he was cool. Thanks, Mackey.

Jason Mackey: I have not, sorry. But glad you enjoyed the listen.

Guest: Who would be a good candidate to replace Hurdle next season? In your opinion, what KIND OF manager does this team need?

Advertise with us

Jason Mackey: I think the team needs a younger manager with different ideas, someone to relate to younger players and taking this thing in a direction more commensurate with what's happening around baseball right now. I also think it wouldn't hurt to spend some money and draft and develop better. Those things aren't on Hurdle, at least the money and drafting part.

Guest: Jason, the pirates are garbage. And there are SO MANY more games left. With all of the "improvements" Manfred has eyes on for the game (including the NL DH, which you support in your chats for some reason), do you think he's ever considered shortening the season? Hear me out, it creates more interest, drama. Sure you lose a few bucks at the box office, but the TV ratings jump. THoughts?

Jason Mackey: I don't think this is something that has gained legitimate traction, sorry.

123: Who is the GREATEST MLB PLAYER you have ever seen play in person? Also, who is the nicest Pirate on the current team?

Jason Mackey: Nicest Pirate is probably Steven Brault. Greatest player I've ever seen in person is a difficult one. Trying to think back to my childhood ... Maybe Bonds. Pujols? Greg Maddux or Randy Johnson would be up there. Probably A-Rod, too.

Advertise with us

team 1: JM, I was sad to see Cervelli go. End of an era. I've been looking in the paper and online and have been surprised no one picked him up. Is he just letting his body heal for the rest of the season and planning to sign elsewhere in the offseason? Any chance that elsewhere could be right here in Pittsburgh? I know the fans would love to have him back.

Jason Mackey: Francisco Cervelli is playing for the Braves. It's been in the paper and online. He's doing quite well, too.

Evan: Do you think the sale of the Royals might move the needle at all for Nutting to think about the payday he could receive by cashing out? Or is he resolute on milking a civic institution turned cash-cow for generations of Lil' Nuttings to come?

Jason Mackey: I've heard that he wants to keep the franchise in the family, although the Royals cashing out is an interesting thing. Again, this isn't based on me understanding what Nutting plans to do, but I do think he could stand to make a large profit if he sold.

Josh B.: Jason...is the momentum for the National League possibly adopting the designated hitter increasing or dormant? Personally, I would like to be able to focus on my hitting and extend my career by being a designated hitter. Go Bucs!!

Advertise with us

Jason Mackey: I think you would fit, Josh, although you made a nice playing with some range last night. I don't think there's been any significant movement either way, but I do it happening eventually.

Ideas for baseball: MLB IDEA: In order to generate more national interest in the MLB I had an idea that I drew from history. I don't always read your chats, but I noticed once that you get touchy about Jim Thorpe, not sure why (hope this is ok to mention), but I read in a bio the other day that in 1913 he and some other big leaguers went on a barnstorming tour of the USA in the offseason. What about a similar idea for MLB players now? Go to small towns and play exhibitions or do HR Derbys. That could be really cool. Any chance Manfred might go for it?

Jason Mackey: I don't see that happening. Major League Baseball uses the ASG -- as does other sports -- as sort of a coup to existing markets. Sending it weird places would not only decrease revenue, but it would also take that away.

Guest: Happy Birthday, Jason! I think I heard your name mentioned on the radio this morning for local birthdays! Enjoy it, man!

Jason Mackey: It's not my birthday. Was born Nov. 7, but I'll tuck that one away for later. Thanks.

Advertise with us

Nick: Hi Jason, how is Josh Bell Ranking among MVP candidates so far this year?

Jason Mackey: I don't think you'll see him finish as a finalist because of his massive slump out of the All-Star break and the fact that the Pirates aren't going to make the playoffs.

Sean: Chances Felipe Vazquez is a pirate come Opening Day 2020? Or are we going to kid ourselves and say we can compete for the division next year.

Jason Mackey: I think they will look to move him this offseason. I think Neal Huntington was intrigued at the deadline, but the return available prohibited them from doing anything. They have someone in Kela who can close. They're also not going to be competing for a division title and should be realistic about that. I think a team will overpay for Vazquez in the offseason.

Tone Loc: Jason, has Brian Reynolds accumulated enough at bats to be eligible for the batting average title? And, how do you rate his chances for ROY?

Advertise with us

Jason Mackey: Yes, he has. He's among the leaders now. I could see him being a finalist, but I don't know how it doesn't go to Pete Alonso in the NL. Believe he has, what, 42 home runs?

LA Matt: I understand that, for PR purposes, Neil Huntington has to spew forth the Pirate spin, but do you really think that he believes even half of what he is saying? Yes, they were 2.5 games out of first at the All Star break, but they were a below 500 team. Yes, if every starter has a career year in 2020, they will be a contender. Etc.....

Jason Mackey: I think Neal has taken an optimists view of the situation. I'm with him on some of it. I do think they have some nice young pieces in Bell, Reynolds, Newman, etc. They should feel good about that. I like Marte's year, I think Moran is better than he's given credit for. But they need to fix some serious holes -- catcher, starting rotation, bullpen. I can agree that they're better than 20 games under .500, but are they really a team that would've been 2 1/2 games out of a legitimate division? No.

rcc prof: Jason, I am curious. What is the criteria for a small market? Is this a valid reason to explain some teams' failures or is it an excuse?

Jason Mackey: I don't think there's definitive criteria. It's more just logic when comparing Pittsburgh to, say, Chicago or New York.

Advertise with us

LA Matt: PLEASE,PLEASE quit quoting the Pirate justification for this joke of a team: "They were 2 1/2 out of first place at the All Star break!" They were BELOW 500 even after a very hot streak prior to the break! Anyone who knows the game knows that they were a bad/mediocre team before the break and a very bad team afterwards.

Jason Mackey: I'm the beat writer. It's my job to quote people in charge saying things. It's a columnist's job to give his/her opinion, and it's your right to formulate what you think based off of those comments. That's why I presented Huntington the way I did -- getting the heck out of the way. He's allowed to feel the way he feels. Do I agree with everything he said? No. But in the article that's not presented because it was supposed to be Neal's thoughts.

John: Can we please stop suggesting MLB will make Nutting sell? There is very little precedent for this, and when it happens, it's not because of a lack of spending. It's when someone like McCourt literally can't fund the team to properly operate it. All the league wants is a business run competently, and there is nothing to suggest the Pirates are not that. If anything, Nutting righted the ship that was way off course under prior management.

Jason Mackey: Yeah, I don't see MLB forcing Nutting to sell. If Nutting sells, it's because he believes he can make a lot of money by doing so.

MjB: Why would anyone think that every player is going to have their best stuff every single night???? I try so hard to understand why Clint Hurdle believes that four or five relievers will have their best stuff on a given night. It's so statistically impossible for anyone to believe that. Let a guy a throw two-three innings if he has his good stuff, and when it's apparent he does not, i.e. Rodriguez/Stratton, get them out of there!

Advertise with us

Jason Mackey: Throwing 2-3 innings is simply not the way relievers are handled anymore. That's not a Hurdle thing. That's a baseball thing. People are just reeeeally careful with that stuff because the numbers back it. I do wish Hurdle would be a little more relaxed with his starters' pitch counts. Those guys can go longer than they're being allowed.

Wayward: Which of the minor leaguers do you see getting called up either 9/1 or when AAA season ends?

Jason Mackey: I think you'll see Tucker, Martin and Kramer, although those are easy. I also think that Ke'Bryan Hayes will get a chance. Perhaps Yacksel Rios, too.

John w: Jason....I definitely feel like it's time for Hurdle to go and I agree a younger manager that can relate to the players would be a better move for the Pirates to make.....that said is there anyone out there in the Farm system right now that would fit the bill in Pittsburgh?

Jason Mackey: Maybe Brian Esposito in Indy; however, I still think either Prince or Banister would be preferred options.

Advertise with us

Wayward: Neal has said they don't need/want to do a tear down/rebuild. In my mind if you move Vasquez and Marte and come up with young sp, catching and maybe another power corner guy to combine with the young core would be a good start. What do you think?

Jason Mackey: I'm OK moving Vazquez because they're insulated against it with Kela and Crick, if Crick can get right. They don't have another center fielder who can do what Marte can. Plus, I think he helps more than he would fetch on the trade market. I think it's different for a closer, who really is only gonna help a contending club. Plus, if they traded Vazquez, it should and would be for a pretty good haul.

John: In the CBA, there are Market Scores, which are used for revenue sharing calculations, with 100 being an average. While there's no definition of how Market Score is calculated, Pittsburgh is 27th with a Market Score of 56. I believe that's a good place to start with the definition of a "small market".

Jason Mackey: Thanks, john. You win.

John: REVENUE SHARINGMARKETSCORE

Advertise with us

* Phased in over four years (2017–2020) at 25% per year, per Article XXIV(A)(12).

RANK CLUB SCORE DQ% 1 NYY 235 100% 1 NYM 235 100% 3 LAD 178 100% 3 LAA 178 100% 5 CHI 124 100% 5 CWS 124 100% 7 TOR 119 100% 8 WSH 113 100% 9 PHI 111 100% 10 OAK 108 100%* 10 SF 108 100% 12 BOS 101 100% 12 TEX 101 100% 14 ATL 96 0% 15 HOU 93 0% 16 SEA 81 0% 17 MIN 76 0% 18 DET 74 0% 19 ARI 72 0% 19 TB 72 0% 21 BAL 70 0% 21 COL 70 0% 23 MIA 69 0% 24 CLE 64 0% 25 SD 60 0% 26 STL 57 0% 27 PIT 56 0% 28 KC 53 0% 29 MIL 52 0% 30 CIN 51 0%

Jason Mackey: Appreciate the assistance here.

LA Matt: My criticism is not that you quoted Huntington, just that you too said the same thing in response to an earlier question on this very chat. I expect it from Huntington, not from an objective beat writer.

Jason Mackey: You expect, what, me to disagree with everything the general manager says because you do? I'm allowed to have my own opinions on things, and a chat is a good forum for them. You're allowed to disagree with me, too. It's OK.

Advertise with us

jds317: What's the latest on Polanco? He's been injured/ ineffective all year. Any real hope that he comes back strong next year? Is Osuna a viable OF option?

Jason Mackey: I think Osuna would be a viable bench option, but they don't want to have him playing every day. Latest on Polanco is that he's doing full baseball activities in Bradenton and has participated in a sim game down there. We will know more today after talking to director of sports medicine Todd Tomczyk. They expect him to be back this season.

Tone Loc: Given the injury history, is it possible that the Pirates start 2020 with Osuna in right instead of Polanco? I realize Polanco has a greater upside, but he really can't be trusted to an everyday player at this point, can he?

Jason Mackey: I think they would like to start with Polanco. That's really their best option. And if they don't have him, I would expect them to sign someone like Lonnie Chisenhall -- although you would hope that this player, you know, actually winds up playing for them.

Jason Pagliaro: Any chance the team could sign Bell and Reynolds to extensions before they hit arbitration or do you think they ride it out with both?

Advertise with us

Jason Mackey: I can't speak as much for Reynolds, but I have my doubts on Bell after talking to his agent, Scott Boras, at the All-Star Game. I will say this: It would be smart of the Pirates to get both done while they can. And it may even make sense for the players, in a way, at least as a bridge to arbitration.

ke'bryan mays hayes: " I think Moran is better than he's given credit for. "

Jason Mackey: Someone disagrees, I see.

ke'bryan mays hayes: "I think Moran is better than he's given credit for." You are wrong. He is not only terrible, he is overrated.

Jason Mackey: He has an OPS of almost .800, fourth-best on the team and higher than that of Kevin Newman (nothing against Newman). Will likely drive in more than 80 runs while hitting around .280 and should finish with more than 15 homers. Again, I'm not gonna put him in the Hall of Fame tomorrow, but i think "terrible" is a little harsh.

Dave: Any chance we will hear directly from the owner as to what the organization will do to improve?

Jason Mackey: I'm told Nutting will talk at the end of the season or around then. (Yes, I know there's a month left.) I think he should talk ASAP. Fans deserve to hear from him and clearly want to hear from him. Trust me, you're not the first person who has brought this up.

Chuckster: If the Pirates would surprise everyone and fire Hurdle, would Mike Matheny be a good replacement? He would bring a different and fresh perspective as opposed to someone like Tom Prince or Jeff Banister.

Jason Mackey: I don't think so. I think they need someone younger, someone who is willing to screw around and try some different stuff because they definitely don't have a traditional roster. For those reasons, I question whether Prince or Banister would be the ideal choice, but they're already on the payroll, so ...

Don't vote Moran: But 103 wRC+ (so, basically average), with bad base running and defense. So, nah.

Jason Mackey: Moran wRC+ = 103 ... salary: $507,500

Jason Mackey: Manny Machado wRC+ = 109 (rank 16; Moran was 19th) ... salary: will make $30 million next season. I can live with the shortcoming. Plus, again, I didn't say he was the greatest player ever. Just that he wasn't terrible. Geesh.

Raymond: Would Jay Bell or Andy Van Slyke be a possible replacement manager? Win over fans that way?

Jason Mackey: I really hope not. If they're trying to win over fans, investing money in the club would be a much better option.

Jason Pagliaro: Who do you see the Pirates looking at as their starting catcher for 2020?

Jason Mackey: I think they're going to sign someone this offseason, probably someone else's No. 3. I don't think it will be a big name.

Raymond: Heck could just have Manny move from his centerfield grill to the clubhouse

Don't vote Moran: Plus, a 0.5 fWAR and 0.0 bWAR.

Jason Mackey: You don't like Colin Moran, we get it. And also, to my earlier point, no I was not providing a legit comparison to Manny Machado. Just trying to make the point that he shouldn't be banished to Single-A.

Scott: Who starts opening day for the Bucs?

Jason Mackey: At this point I would say probably Joe Musgrove, with an outside chance of Trevor Williams if he's able to have a strong finish. Steven Brault is an interesting case, but I don't necessarily see that happening.

G: Who could the pirates add this offseason in terms of catcher

Jason Mackey: I think you're blindly throwing darts. It would be via trade, IMO. The free agent guys are all up there. Would have to be who could be involved in a trade, and the answer to that just isn't simple.

Chuckster: Last season Elias Diaz had a breakout season. He was good defensively, batted well and hit 10 home runs. How do you explain his regression? Is he still part of the Pirates' future?

Jason Mackey: I don't know if anyone can, to be honest, Elias and the Pirates included. He's been extremely subpar defensively, but he also hasn't hit, especially for any shred of power. Future plans? I have a tough time seeing it. I could see them keeping Stallings as a backup, but they need a legit starter back there, and I don't think they have that guy in the organization right now. Maybe the virus with Diaz, but that should be cleared up by now.

Raymond: Wondering why it took until recently for Pirates to be more aggressive on the basepaths. The team has a decent amount of speed. Should stealing bases be more of a priority?

Jason Mackey: Yeah, they picked the series against J.T. Realmuto to start running. Ha. No, seriously, I think they should to. I like it. They have to create runs in some way, and it isn't going to be by hitting home runs.

ke'bryan mays hayes: moran has a wRC+ hovering around 100. it's up to 103 now thanks to his good couple games. NL third basemen are 106. So he's a below average bat for his position, on top of playing oafish defense and being utterly worthless on the base paths. he's one of the biggest holes on a team full of them.

Jason Mackey: You're entitled to your opinion, I'm entitled to mine. With Hayes in the system and other options around the infield, Newman included, I'm fine with what's happening here. Moran makes peanuts. I'm sure as heck not ready to blame the Pirates problems this season on Colin Moran's wRC+, but apparently he clogged your toilet or let the air out of your tires or something.

Jason Pagliaro: Throwing a few names out there if Hurdle is fired.. Chad Mottola, Darren Bush, Marcus Thames,

Jason Mackey: Rays, A's and Yankees, all 45 or younger. We're throwing darts here, but I agree, those are interesting. They jibe with what I (and others) think the Pirates need.

Jason Mackey: OK, folks. That does it for this week. Thanks for participating and trying to get Colin Moran to switch careers. Have to head to the ballpark now. Until next time ...