ALB: Hi, Nubyjas. Is it somewhat depressing for you personally to cover a team like these Pirates? Do you envy the Atlanta reporters who have a first place team to write about?

nubyjas wilborn: I’ll be honest. I enjoyed covering players like Freddie Freeman, Ozzie Albies, Ronald Acuna, and so many others. Brian Snitker was also a dream to cover as a manager. That said, I enjoy covering the Pirates. There are a lot of great people in the org and I also respect the challenge of finding different angles. For example, I saw the team doing PFP’s and other drills so I wrote about it yesterday.

nubyjas wilborn: Good afternoon, Pirates fans! I’m so honored to be here with you. Let’s chat.

Ben: Will the Pirates trade Starling Marte this winter?

Advertise with us

nubyjas wilborn: I don’t see it.

Richard Mallary: I think I would like Clint Hurdle if I met him. But I’m struggling to think of any team in any sport that went from a contender to possibly the worst team in its sport almost over night. You can analyze each piece of the puzzle and see individual faults by ownership, players and office management, but doesn’t the dimension of this collapse have to fall squarely on Hurdle? He had (has?) a group of players capable of contending — they proved that. But I’m thinking it is VERY fundamental for a manager to be judged by his/her ability to rally a team when adversity arrives, and keep them in some semblance of how they finished the first half.

nubyjas wilborn: The Pirates have to fully evaluate what went wrong this season. But one of the glaring things I’ve seen is how often the Pirates fail at doing the fundamentals. They would be so much better if they did run the bases well, played sound defense, threw to the right base, and got quality at-bats. Some of that falls on Hurdle.

Newman: That Mackey guy thinks Cole will be the long term answer at short. I think it’s more likely to be yours truly. Where do you stand?

nubyjas wilborn: Shouldn’t you be resting before the game? But seriously, the bat has played and so has the glove. Right now Kevin Newman is the shortstop because he’s earned it.

Advertise with us

Bob Prince: I have been a fan of Clint Hurdle but he has to take some responsibility for the team’s performance after the All Star break. Reading stories about clubhouse issues, etc. Does he survive?

nubyjas wilborn: I think he’ll survive. I’m not certain that he should.

Rich from Indio CA: This current slide is almost exclusively on the pitching staff — both the starters and bullpen. How can NH say with a straight face we plan to go with this pitching staff in 2020.

nubyjas wilborn: Maybe he sees something we don’t. I’m not certain as to what it is, but he truly believes what he’s saying.

Alan: Hi Nubyjas. Do you have a feel for how other organizations in MLB view the Pirates brass in terms of how they operate and the decisions they’ve made? Is there any derision based on the unwillingness to spend and sitting back and collecting revenue sharing checks?

Advertise with us

nubyjas wilborn: Most people I’ve spoken to respect Neal Huntington as a general manager. The consensus is that he does as well as he can with the budget he has available. It’s also no secret that the Pirates haven’t spent on payroll.

Frustrated Fan: Do you think Bob Nutting understands the importance of an owner / CEO being front and center with the public when things go awfully wrong? Why has he not made himself available to address the current situation with the Pirates?

Newman: If it turns out Hayes can’t hit, as recent evidence may suggest, what about me at third and Cole at short?

nubyjas wilborn: I’m sure your bat will keep you in play. But they’re going to make every effort with Hayes because of his glove.

Raymond: Any idea what kind of young pitching is going to be brought up once rosters expand? Will Dario be in the rotation next season?

Advertise with us

nubyjas wilborn: You’ve pretty much seen all of them. And Dario will have an opportunity.

JB: Is my future as a DH in the junior circuit? Hard to hide my inability to throw a baseball. Keep in mind that Craig guy still has a lot to prove.

nubyjas wilborn: I haven’t heard “junior circuit” in ages, which tells me that you’re clearly not the real JB. Also, who’s to say the DH won’t be in the National League soon ;)

coworker to be named later: if you were in charge and could wipe out and replace the whole rotation except for one guy, which starting pitcher would you keep

nubyjas wilborn: Tough question. If you’re asking me as a journalist, Chris Archer is the best interview. If you’re asking as me being a GM, I’d say Musgrove.

Advertise with us

Raymond: If Hurdle does get sacked, which he probably won’t, who would you put on a shortlist for manager? If you had that power

nubyjas wilborn: Jay Bell, former Pirate and current manager in the Yankees minor league system. Tom Prince, current Pirates bench coach. Joe Espada, Astros bench coach, or Jeff Bannister.

Mark: IMO, the only pitcher who improved from last year is Brault, Vasquez is the same, and everyone else regressed. Wouldn’t you think that would cause the pitching coach’s seat to warm up?

nubyjas wilborn: You’ll have to ask why each pitcher regressed. Trevor Williams had injuries, Taillon as well, Musgrove and Archer entered the season off surgeries. I haven’t gotten any inclination that the team is blaming Searage.

Patty: Are we keeping Frank Coonelly?? Please say yes!

Advertise with us

nubyjas wilborn: I’d be very surprised to see Frank go.

Raymond: Would love to see Bell or Bannister honestly! Those would go over well with fans. Andy Van Slyke (Tigers system coach I think) would be my dream candidate

nubyjas wilborn: Maybe Bell hires Van Slyke.

nubyjas wilborn: Let’s finish strong, boys and girls! I know yinz have more questions.

Glenn: Who’s starting in RF opening day 2020?

Advertise with us

nubyjas wilborn: Gregory Polanco, maybe …

Wayward: Although the catching situation is looking a little shaking I still think the positional core, including some of the AAA guys are pretty solid. What are your thoughts?

nubyjas wilborn: I like Jacob Stallings as a backup catcher. His demeanor reminds me of Tyler Flowers with the Braves. He knows his strengths and weaknesses. Stallings is great with pitchers and could be a manager one day if he wanted. I’m not sure what happened to Elias Diaz, I can’t help but wonder if he’s fully recovered from the illness that caused him to miss spring training

Felipe: I like it here, but it’s clear I need to be used to get some starting pitching. Just send me somewhere decent. Your two cents?

nubyjas wilborn: They tried, but you’re too valuable.

Advertise with us

Glenn: What do u think about getting rid of Frazier who’s been a big disappointment and moving Moran full time to 2nd base?

nubyjas wilborn: I don’t believe that would be a good answer.

Dave: When might the owner speak to the press about the plan for going forward?

nubyjas wilborn: Good question. I don’t know. Requests are being made. Stay tuned.

Dave: I think they need to replace Frazier; he only hits for part of the year, is in a funk for the rest of the year. Newman at second and cole at short, or newman at short and Kramer at second, I think they should spend September doing that. bench fraizer

Advertise with us

nubyjas wilborn: I’m not sure if there’s a question here. However, we’ll likely see Kramer get a shot coming up soon. I don’t see a need to move Newman anytime soon.

Dave 2: you think that Oneill Cruz from Altoona will be up in September

nubyjas wilborn: I doubt it, but he’s fun to watch. He will be a player one day.

jack: You were not here last year so perhaps you do not know the answer, but it would be nice if you could find out the reason the P.G. does not post the total attendance figures like they used to. It was always placed under the players stats and would include current year, last year and the record year. I believe all were based on tickets sold. I have seen this in print once this year. It makes it look like the Pirates want to keep it out of print. I mean we keep hearing they are ahead of last years figures, but why not show that?

nubyjas wilborn: The Pirates have no impact on what we print at the Post-Gazette. I’m honestly not sure why we don’t. However, the attendance numbers are easily found on baseball-reference or fangraphs or MLB.com

Advertise with us

Chris: Im interested in Tom Koehler....if the Pirates further pare down their payroll further in the offseason (as many of us believe), Mr. Koehler could end up being the highest paid person on the Team next year … is this guy hanging out in Lonnie Chisenhall’s basement or something?

nubyjas wilborn: I’m not certain what Tom does in his spare time. That said, I’m pretty sure Josh Bell will get a lot of money in his first arb year.

Dave 2: Do you think pirates view Will Craig as a Rob Deer/Dave Kingman type that either hits homeruns or strikeouts or they view him as a legit 1st baseman, he seems to be average to good in the field at 1st

nubyjas wilborn: They like him as a first baseman, problem is there is a big roadblock in his way by the name of Josh Bell

nubyjas wilborn: Are all hearts and minds clear? If so, I’ll talk to you guys in two weeks. Jason Mackey has the chat next week and I have the mailbag.