Jason Mackey: Hi folks. Welcome to my bi-weekly Pirates chat. Lots to talk about, obviously. Leave your questions, and I'll be back at noon to answer 'em. And thanks, as always, for participating.

Jon Snow: The Pirates could add 20 million dollars next year to pick up 2 starters and still have a payroll under 90 million dollars. The small market line has worn out. Cleveland, Cinn, and the Brewers all spend more than the Pirates and put a better product on the field. The Pirates need to stop trying to sign bargain basement free agents (see Chistenhome lol) and use that money to sign proven talent.

Jason Mackey: Jon, I'm not sure you've come up with some revolutionary concept -- no offense. Although I do love the nickname of Chisenhome. I don't know how we've been missed that this whole time. Agree 100 percent with what you're saying. I think they have some good pieces right now, but they also have some flaws. If they're not going to strip it down and start over, then they need to spend some money patching their current holes -- starting pitching, catcher, a bullpen arm.

FloridaSteelers: Jason, talk me off this cliff, do you see ANYTHING positive happening with this team in the next couple years?

Advertise with us

Jason Mackey: I think there's the possibility for something decent to happen. So they have Reynolds and Marte in the outfield. If they find another guy, that could be pretty decent. Hard to not like Newman. Moran has shown signs. You have Bell plus Tucker and Hayes on the way. Should the Astros and Yankees start cowering in fear? No. But there could be improvement ahead. Ditto for the pitching. I like Keller. I think Brault has turned a corner. You'd like to think you could get two competent starts among the following group: Archer, Williams, Musgrove, Kuhl and Agrazal. If they add a legit starter, that's not terrible. It's at least competitive. Bullpen-wise, you have Vazquez. Crick is better than he's shown. Rodriguez and Feliz are serviceable. Maybe it's Kela, but I'd look to improve there. Still, it should be competitive.

Joe: Do you feel more confident when Bell bats from the left side? I sure do. He looks unnatural in my opinion from the right side of the dish.

Jason Mackey: I do think he looks more natural from the left side, but I don't think he should stop hitting righty. In a perfect, DH-filled world, I might have him stop playing the field. But not stop hitting from the right side.

Tom: Was just reading, Mackey, that the guy from Bon Iver recently played on stage with Dead and Co. and he apparently did LSD before his set. Now is that commonplace? How could you play music on drugs of that caliber? Have you ever tried LSD or other drugs like that when you were younger? Thanks. P.S. I'm hoping to see the Dead play at some point, even though the lineup is different.

Jason Mackey: The Dead and LSD have long been intertwined, dating back to the Acid Tests. I, however, have never tried it. Nor do I intend to.

Advertise with us

Hades: Any chance in Hades that Hurdle is the Bucs manager on opening day 2020?

Jason Mackey: I don't think so, personally. If something doesn't happen in-season, I could see him deciding that retirement was simply a better option and moving on, maybe with a nudge or two from the organization.

Guest: The Pirates are stinky, so I gotta ask an MLB question - who do you like to win the World Series this season? Houston? Yankees?

Jason Mackey: Just because they're out of playoff contention doesn't mean they're not worth talking about, IMO. ... I would take the Astros because of the ridiculous pitching.

Jason too: When I look at a player like Will Craig in Triple A Indy, I see a player who could possibly be a leader going forward with a +.500 pirates team. Do you see him factoring in big time in the Pirates long term plans?

Advertise with us

Jason Mackey: Will Craig and long-term ... I think it depends on his ability to play the outfield or any possible rule changes with the DH. If there's a DH, yeah, I do. He would be a perfect first baseman, and you DH Bell. If not, I have a tough time seeing it. I don't think he would be someone I'd run out to right field every day. It's a tough spot. He also needs to get more consistent in his approach at the plate, as I understand where he's at with his development.

Guest: Hypothetically - Would you trade Josh Bell, Taillon, and the next 10 first round draft picks for Mike Trout? Consider trout's age and contract #.

Jason Mackey: Ten first-round picks? Um, no.

SBJ: Hi Jason. In light of Taillon’s surgery and rehabilitation, do you see the Pirates going after a quality #1 pitcher either in free agency or in a trade?

Jason Mackey: I think Taillon's injury means they'll pick up the option on Chris Archer. I also think they might sign a pitcher in free agency. However, while Taillon was a No. 1 for them, I don't think his injury means they're going to pay front-of-the-rotation money. That would be waaay out of character. But even if they got a legitimate MLB starter, that would be a step in the right direction.

Advertise with us

dougp: Have you watched the Hulu TV show "Letterkenny"? It is outstanding. Truly funny.

Jason Mackey: I have not, but thanks for the recommendation.

Bob: I know the Frontier League (Washington Wild Things) is not a "minor league" per say, but could a MLB team sign their players?

Jason Mackey: They could, yes. And I believe that some players have signed with MLB clubs. The list is short, though.

True fan: Hey Jason, thought you might beinterested to know that i just found out that i have an uncle who apparently went to monroe elementary school with Jerry Garcia. He said that Garcia was playing piano back then and that he was missing part of his finger. Is that TRUE? How could a guy with part of a finger missing wail on guitar so well later in life? I'm just trying to figure out if my uncle is lying because he's a bit of a trickster. He once shaved all of our heads because he said we had lice, but we didn't really. haha. Thanks, Jason!

Advertise with us

Jason Mackey: Don't know about your uncle and sorry about your hair. But, yeah, Garcia was missing a significant chunk of his right middle finger. Believe it was the result of an accident involving his brother. It's one reason you don't hear Jerry finger pick a ton.

Guest: How much do you miss covering a good team (Penguins) now that you are covering a bad team (Pirates)?

Jason Mackey: We've been over this, but it never seems to go away. ... I hate being insulting to fans/readers, so please don't take this this way. But we're not you. I try to keep in good perspective what we get to do for a living. We're incredibly lucky, and I love this job. But if the team I cover wins or loses, it doesn't change my job. They win, we write. They lose, we write. Just do it without overtime or any lead changes. ... If you're doing this job to write about only wins, you're doing it wrong. Honest to God, one of the ways I realized I wanted to do this was living in D.C. and reading Barry Svrluga on some really bad Nationals teams. And he made me care, because he was good. If I'm doing my job and doing it well, I'm giving you stuff to care about, win or lose. So, no, I don't miss my old beat because the Penguins were better results-wise. They each present their own challenges. There are some things easier with my baseball, and some things that I find more difficult. None of them involve wins or losses.

#21: Jason...is the possibility of Clemente’s number being retired gaining any momentum or decreasing? Thanks .

Jason Mackey: I'm assuming you mean on a league-wide scale ... honestly, I don't have any sense either way on that. But I do think it's grown even more rare for players to choose No. 21, especially latin players. It's almost explicitly off-limits.

Advertise with us

Duke: Do you think the Pirates will reopen Vasquez trade talks with the Dodgers over the winter?

Jason Mackey: I think it depends on how they fare in the postseason. If they win a World Series with tremendous relief pitching, maybe not. But if they fall short again, I think it would make a lot of sense.

dead fan 1971: Jason, not a pirates question or Penguins, but did you read the piece today in the LA TIMES where Fogerty says that the DEAD messed up CCR's performance at Woodstock? Basically, the Dead hogged the stage for like 5 hours and kept CCR from going on until the very early morning. By that time the crowd was asleep. Also, is the Dead's set at Woodstock any good? Can you listen to it all online? Thanks for the chat!

Jason Mackey: I did not read the piece, but I will. That's interesting. Had never heard that before. Do love Fogerty. ... No, I don't think it's available anywhere. As I understand it, the performance was so bad -- guys were literally getting electrocuted because of the rain and equipment malfunctions -- that they insisted on it not being included on the DVD or released.

Guest: Marte - a Pirate in 2020 or on some other team?

Advertise with us

Jason Mackey: I think he's a Pirate in 2020.

Mark: Hi Jason. I could definitely see next year's starting staff being Big Joe-Trevor-Arch-Brault and either Kuhl or Agrazal. That is simply not good enough in my opinion. What do you think? Thanks.

Jason Mackey: It depends on how they're pitching. If we're talking Musgrove's best stuff, 2018 post-break Williams, Tampa Bay Archer and maybe Mitch Keller thrown in, then yeah, I think that could be very good. I also don't think it's terribly likely you get all that, which is why I think they should add someone, to insulate themselves from those inevitable struggles.

CampHillguy: The Dickerson give away — — can we conclude this was a simply dump of Corey’s remaining $2.8 M salary ? Any word on the PTBNL? As for the $250k in international bonus pool $$s received in the deal, do we know if NH has even spent the international bonus pool amounts allocated to the Pirates the last few years?

Jason Mackey: Yeah, it was a dump. I'll admit that. But the Pirates do use their allotted pool money in international signings, I'll give them that. Also, it's not actual money per se. It's what they're allowed to spend. But the Pirates do use it, if I'm not mistaken.

Advertise with us

Jason Mackey: No word on the PTBNL. Does me zero good to have information on someone or something and withhold it until I'm asked in a chat.

Nick: The cubs are coming here and they can't win on the road to save their soul. So 3 wins against Cubs should spark the Pirates in to panant race right?

Jason Mackey: It could. Won't do them much good in the pennant race, but in the race for the panant, anything can happen.

bucs stink: Jason, there are a lot of Pirates games left. And I know you work for the team and you have to find reasons to get us to tune in and come out to the ballpark, so give me ONE GOOD REASON that I should keep watching this wretched team play out its season. Thanks, Mr. M!

Jason Mackey: Um, Mr. M, I don't work for the team. I work for the Post-Gazette. There's a BIG difference there. Here's what I used to a reader earlier who asked sort of the same question. FloridaSteelers asked if I saw anything positive happening in the next couple years: " I think there's the possibility for something decent to happen. So they have Reynolds and Marte in the outfield. If they find another guy, that could be pretty decent. Hard to not like Newman. Moran has shown signs. You have Bell plus Tucker and Hayes on the way. I like Keller. I think Brault has turned a corner. You'd like to think you could get two competent starts among the following group: Archer, Williams, Musgrove, Kuhl and Agrazal. If they add a legit starter, that's not terrible. It's at least competitive. Bullpen-wise, you have Vazquez. Crick is better than he's shown. Rodriguez and Feliz are serviceable. Maybe it's Kela, but I'd look to improve there. Still, it should be competitive."

Advertise with us

Mark C.: Maybe you can fill me in here, do you know anything regarding SP James Marvel at AAA?

Just based on numbers between AA and AAA (13-5, 2.74 ERA, inclduing being 4-0 with a 1.82 ERA during his time at AAA), he seems like a candidate to have some say in 2020.

Maybe he is just a guy, nothing special, just don’t know any background on him.

Jason Mackey: I can't say I know a ton, Mark. I've not actually seen him pitch. But I agree with you. His numbers tell me he's worthy of a look in September. ... Why not sooner? Good question. Probably don't want to piss off any of the older members -- Archer, Williams and Musgrove -- and Brault has been good. Agrazal became Keller. If you're gonna take someone out, it's Archer, Williams or Musgrove, and I think there's probably a reluctance to do that.

Nick: Is anybody at Pirates checking waivers constantly. There is a lot of cheap talent and Pirates are high in picking order, right? May be a chance to build up team for pennant race?

Advertise with us

Jason Mackey: Seems like Nick has the sarcasm factor covered. Yes, I'm pretty sure they're checking the waiver wire.

Guest: A lot of people who talk about Mickey Mantle fail to mention his bunting abilities. When batting lefty, he could lay down a sweet bunt to the 3rd base line and beat it out with his speed to get a single nearly every time. Historians and talking heads tend to focus on his HR hitting, which was good, but his bunting is JUST ONE OF MANY areas in which I think no ball player since has matched him. When you think of the last let's say 10 MLB seasons, who do you think is the most gifted bunter? Not who has the most bunts necessarily, but who is the best at bunting? Thank you as always, Jason.

Jason Mackey: I don't feel qualified to say who has been MLB's best bunter over the past 10 years. Sorry. You can flip through the BaseballReference situational hitting tools if you're really into it. This season Kolten Wong leads with nine: https://www.baseball-reference.com/leagues/NL/2019-situational-batting...

Nick: How can the announcer tell if its a 2 seam or 4 seam fast ball?

Jason Mackey: A two-seamer generally has run away from the arm side. A four-seamer is straight. There are exceptions, of course. But that's a quickie guide. A sinker -- you guessed it -- sinks. Announcers, like writers, also go by what MLB game loggers classify pitches as, so as to ensure accuracy.

Advertise with us

Guest: Sorry to interrupt the Pirates talk, Jason, but I usually read, but don't post, in your chats. I've noticed over the years that you are asked occassionally about the band Train. I just learned that their lead singer Pat Monahan is from Erie, PA. So if you have no other reason to pull them up online that is maybe the best reason. Drops of Jupiter and Meet Virginia and Soul Sister are their best jam tracks. Anyway, I enjoy and respect your reporting style. Thanks for the chats and articles! - Thanks!

Jason Mackey: I'm well-aware of Train. Thank you.

Mike: Jason, Help me understand why the Bucs DFA'd Kang for Reyes and Gonzalez. Neither is hitting well (or ever will) while Kang had 10 HRs and 24 RBIs. Yes he struck out a lot, but what did the Pirates have to lose by playing him more and keeping him until the end of the season? This seems like a no brainer to me, what am I missing?

Jason Mackey: I think they wanted to open up the spot to see what they have. I agree with you -- Gonzalez and Reyes have not offered much. However, the Pirates are learning that. I think eventually you will see them give Tucker and Hayes a shot, too, to see what they can do.

Doley: In the considerable pushback against the idea they've fallen behind analytically re pitching, has anyone in the organization addressed the repeated, specific comments by Cole, Morton, Glasnow, Baz, et. al that once they went elsewhere, they were immediately presented with analytics tools they'd never seen before?

Advertise with us

Jason Mackey: Neal Huntington said this past Sunday that they need to revisit some of their practices and how they're preparing players. I would imagine this was part of those comments.

Guest: IF THERE'S A DH?!?!?!? Jason, you're scaring me, man! Do you see the entire MLB having the DH in the near future?

Jason Mackey: I don't. But I'm trying to answer all possible angles of the questions.

?: In response to the Will Craig question, you mentioned casually that the DH might be a part of the NL. You've been accused before of being a lackey for Manfred, but the way you mentioned the DH so casually shows me that you are indeed a lackey who tries to normalize the DH. Shame on you, Jason.

Jason Mackey: Stop it with that junk.

Advertise with us

Joe: Though he got walloped pretty good last night and most other nights, I had no idea Hartlieb threw gas like he did. 97 and 98 on the fastball. Why is he so ineffective in your opinion?

Jason Mackey: He misses his spots too much. They're major league hitters. They can hit 97 or 98 mph fastballs if they're in bad spots. Hartlieb misses up and out of the plate far too much.

Alan: Jason, are there really that many Pirates fans out there that think there is even the remotest possibility that the Pirates will go out and obtain a true "#1" starter to replace Taillion, or are all these people online bots? These can't be real people, right? And lets be serious, Taillion is a #3 at best on a WS contending team.

Jason Mackey: I think there are fans that hope the organization will address the loss of Taillon by bringing someone in, and I think that's a reasonable way of looking at it. I don't think anyone is looking at the Pirates to be the Yankees, but they do want them to spend money where it's required. That's fair.

c'mon man: C'mon, Jason. You can't seriously hope the DH is implemented in the NL, even if it would help the Pirates and Craig. You can't let Manfred's propaganda get to you, man. You have to be an independent voice as a journalist!!! C'mon, Jason! C'mon Man!

Advertise with us

Jason Mackey: I don't care either way about the DH. Just trying to address all angles of the question.

no DH ever: I thought you were an independent voice covering the Pirates, but apparently you're just spewing whatever the MLB wants you to regarding the designated hitter. You have to be unbiased, Jason. Just because R. Manfred wants a DH universally doesn't mean you should be championing it in your chats. That stinks buddy. However, i do generally dig your reporting style and work covering sports

Jason Mackey: You're over-reacting.

Guest: You rock, Jason!

Jason Mackey: Thank you.

Guest: I was going ask a baseball question but apparently this a music chat. My ad.

Jason Mackey: You can still ask it. No reason to get upset.

Mark: I forgot about Keller. Did you see who pinch hit for Corey Dickerson the other day in Philly? None other than Sean Rodriguez. Ouch.

Jason Mackey: At least Rodriguez didn't treat him like the Gatorade cooler. Come to think of it, that would be a pretty good fight.

Frasier: Hey, did I do enough to stop the talk about Cole or Newman moving to second? I think I did, but I may be biased.

Jason Mackey: You spelled your last name wrong, Adam. ... I think they're going to give Cole a chance. If he works, and he very well might, I think you could get pushed out of a job. But for now, you're the guy.

Ray Searage: What coaching staff changes do you see coming after the 2019 season? Will I still have a job?

Jason Mackey: I don't think so, Ray. I'm sorry. I like you. You're a very nice man, and I think you're done some good work here. But I think the Pirates really do need to go in a different direction pitching-wise.

Tucker: Say Mackey has to bet everything he owns in this world, monetarily of course. Me or that Newman guy the long term answer at short?

Jason Mackey: You. Newman goes to second or third, depending on what happens with Moran, Frazier and Hayes.

Scott Stout: I saw Fogerty live in concert and he told the same story. Interestingly enough, Dead fan Bill Walton was at the concert as well.

Jason Mackey: Good to know. I'm definitely going to check out that article.

Alan: On Jason Mackey bobblehead night, is your bobblehead wearing a Grateful Dead shirt or a Westminster baseball jersey?

Jason Mackey: How about a tie-dyed Westminster baseball jersey? Or a Grateful Dead shirt with a Westminster baseball hat?

Austin: How do you see the starting infield next season?

Jason Mackey: I'm gonna say Moran at third, Tucker at short, Newman at second and Bell at first. Hayes stays in the minors and comes up midseason.

Clint Hurdle: Hi Jason, will I still have a job next year? If not who has the best chance of replacing me?

Jason Mackey: I think you're gonna think long and hard about moving on, Clint, and I think you will ultimately do it. I think it's either Prince or Banister, with an outside chance of Esposito.

BVA: Probably a no but do you think Bell signs an extension???

Jason Mackey: Yeah, no. Sorry. I don't see that happening. I think the Pirates would be smart to try. But if I'm Josh Bell, I'm taking my arbitration money, then I'm going to get paid the first chance I get. And it won't be here.

AJ: Jason, what extension do you likely see for the Pirates??? Bell??? Reynolds??? Do you think they Pick up Chris archers option???

Jason Mackey: I think they will pick up Archer's option. I think they have to with the Taillon news. I don't see them extending Bell. I think they can wait on Reynolds. There's no rush. If he continues this next year, then yeah, I could definitely see them trying to get something done with him.

Jason Mackey: OK, folks. That does it for this week. Thanks so much for participating, as always. Talk to you again in two weeks!