It remains one of the more interesting questions facing the Pirates this season: When will top prospect Mitch Keller get another shot with the big club?
The answer is probably at some point before the end of the 2019 season, but anything more than that gets a little tricky.
Speaking to reporters Sunday before a game against the New York Mets at PNC Park, Pirates general manager Neal Huntington outlined the challenges his club faces as it pertains to potentially bringing up Keller for a fourth time this season.
“We have Mitch Keller pounding on the door to get an opportunity in our rotation,” Huntington said. “The challenge is who do you clear out to put him in that rotation?”
Two names Huntington brought up unprompted were Dario Agrazal and Steven Brault, who will pitch Monday and Tuesday against the Brewers. They both have done enough to keep their spots, Huntington said.
The Pirates also want to allow Trevor Williams, Joe Musgrove and Chris Archer to continue building toward next season. Even if that sounds insane, a case can be made for at least two of the three.
Read More
Williams’ workload has been light because of a side strain, an illness and the birth of his adopted daughter. Thus, he’s only at 94⅔ innings, a far cry from the 170⅔ he threw in 2018. Williams has been trending in the right direction of late, and the Pirates would be wise to let him keep doing what he’s doing.
As for Archer, they have a decision to make. They can exercise a club option on him over the summer and pay him $8.25 million or buy out Archer for $1.75 million. So far out of the All-Star break, Archer has shown signs of turning the corner — but still has lacked consistency. To determine which route to go, the Pirates need to see more.
Musgrove is a bit different. He already has set career-highs in wins, starts, innings pitched and strikeouts, going 8-10 with a 4.69 ERA. But Musgrove also has been hit hard at times, including Sunday when he allowed eight earned runs in 3⅓ innings. Musgrove has allowed two or more homers in five of his past eight starts.
“As much as anything else, it’s about opportunity,” Huntington said. “With what Brault and Agrazal have done, it’s tough to move them out with the way they’ve pitched. Joe Musgrove, Trevor Williams, Chris Archer — another great sign for optimism [Saturday] night; the last handful of starts have been better.
“We’re seeing some positives there, so as you start to look around the rotation, part of it is opportunity. With Mitch, it’s just continuing to refine the things that are going to allow him to be successful up here. You run down the laundry list like you do with every young pitcher. This is the same.”
Keller, too, has made it a tough question.
While he ranks second in the International League in ERA (3.56) and leads in strikeouts (123), Keller has pitched to a 5.13 ERA over his past six starts. In three chances with the big club, Keller is 0-1 with a 10.50 ERA.
One thing the Pirates have considered, Huntington said, is shifting to a six-man rotation; however, the schedule complicates things. They’re in the middle of a stretch with three consecutive Thursdays off. In September, the Pirates have three of the first four Mondays off.
That means pitchers sometimes could be pitching on seven days of rest, which doesn’t always work.
“It’s a conversation we’ve had,” Huntington said. “[Going to a six-man rotation] could be a consideration, depending on how things come together.”
Talking innings
As the Pirates process what happened to Jameson Taillon and why, here’s something that should not go overlooked: He threw 133⅔ innings in 2017 and jumped to 191 in 2018, an increase of 57⅓ or a little over 40 percent.
It’s rare to see something so significant, especially in a player who has had injury issues in the past, including Tommy John surgery. Taillon also is only 27.
That innings increase did not, by itself, cause Taillon’s right elbow flexor tendon strain. But it would make sense if the Pirates were a little hesitant with anyone encountering a similar situation in the future.
The good news is that crowd may be small. Musgrove, 26, could be in a similar situation. He had pitched a career-high 121⅓ innings before Sunday, an increase of about one start already over last year (115⅓).
Keller, 23, had thrown 115⅔ innings and was in no danger of blowing past what he did last season (142⅓). Dario Agrazal, 24, has thrown 117 innings, which is an increase from his 2018 total (93⅔). But Agrazal logged 150 innings in 2016, meaning he should still be fine.
“A lot of it comes back to pitchers’ recovery, the quality of the stuff that we’re seeing,” Huntington said. “There’s a lot of art to it. There’s not a ton of true science to it. We’re working through that with our guys.”
Jason Mackey: jmackey@post-gazette.com and Twitter @JMackeyPG.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.