There are a few things we can learn from the discipline handed down by Major League Baseball on Thursday in the wake of Tuesday's brawl between the Pirates and Reds at Great American Ball Park.
One, the league has grown tired of this stuff. By suspending six players and both managers, it's clearly trying to send a message.
There's a lengthy history here of both sides getting upset over purpose pitches and message-sending, and Joe Torre, MLB's chief baseball officer, wants it cleaned up. Now.
Secondly, the league didn't take kindly to what Keone Kela said after Tuesday's game — admitting that he intentionally threw in the direction of Derek Dietrich’s head with a 97 mph fastball in the seventh inning.
After Kela said what he said, MLB had to respond.
Although Reds pitcher Amir Garrett was probably the most culpable party in all of this, given he charged the Pirates dugout and threw the first punch, Kela set the wheels in motion.
Read More
Kela got 10 games, Garrett eight. It probably should’ve at least been equal.
Amir Garrett went at the Pirates all alone, Yasiel Puig still came to his defense after being traded to Cleveland 🤭
— Bleacher Report (@BleacherReport) July 31, 2019
Madness in Cincinnati
(via @FOXSportsOH)pic.twitter.com/vqhNq9S2Ww
In addition, Jose Osuna got five games and Kyle Crick three to round out Pirates player suspensions. Crick’s suspension seemed at least somewhat warranted, given he went after Garrett, while Torre must’ve found something on video regarding Osuna, who was not ejected from the game.
Manager Clint Hurdle didn’t do much on Tuesday, but he has overseen plenty of inside pitches from his pitchers against the Reds, intentional or not.
Torre suspended Hurdle for two games, citing his club’s conduct Tuesday and Hurdle’s role in the years-long saga.
It was strange to see Hurdle’s counterpart, David Bell, get only six games. Bell was ejected for the eighth time this season earlier in the game — he leads the league in that category — then he came back on the field to go after Hurdle, who turned 62 on Tuesday and has a pair of artificial hips.
Other Reds suspensions included former Pirate Jared Hughes and Yasiel Puig, who both got three games. Hughes hit Starling Marte in retaliation for what Kela did and was ejected. Puig, who was technically Cleveland Indians property at the time, kept the fight going after it was basically done.
Both managers and all six players received fines, too. So did Trevor Williams of the Pirates and Joey Votto and Phillip Ervin of the Reds, in addition to a couple players on the injured list who came onto the field.
The suspensions were set to begin Thursday for the Reds players — and Puig — and Friday for those on the Pirates, although all six players have decided to appeal, meaning they can play while that’s sorted out.
“The incidents between these two clubs remain a source of concern, and it’s reflected by the level of discipline we are handing down," Torre said in a statement. "Everyone on the field should be aware of the example they are setting for fans, particularly young people. I firmly expect these two managers and all others to hold their players accountable for appropriate conduct and to guide them in the right direction.”
Bell will start his suspension on Thursday, while Hurdle will begin his on Friday. It’s presumed that bench coach Tom Prince will be in charge.

Jason Mackey: jmackey@post-gazette.com and Twitter @JMackeyPG






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.