ST. LOUIS — Chris Archer believes it’s possible.
While the Pirates pitcher appreciates the relationships he’s built with umpires over the years, Archer is also well aware of Major League Baseball’s ongoing flirtation with robots calling balls and strikes.
Soon, Archer realizes, his practice of exchanging pleasantries with the men behind home plate may be about as useful as a digital camera or desktop computer.
“I don’t know what it would entail,” Archer said of having robot umps call balls and strikes. “But I could definitely see it happening.”
Archer said he’s hasn’t been following what happened recently in the Atlantic League, where a computer system called balls and strikes for the first time during the eight-team, independent league’s All-Star Game.
But the fact that the Atlantic League is a partner of MLB and the process — where the home plate umpire uses an iPhone and earpiece to relay what a Doppler Radar-based computer system reads — went relatively smoothly, it seems only a matter of time.
Read More
If it happens, Archer won’t be the only pitcher who sort of begrudgingly embraces the change, realizing there’s only so much he can do.
“There’s pros and cons,” Archer said. “But at the end of the day, if MLB wants to implement a rule change or something of that nature, they can just do it. We don’t have that much of a say.”
Archer is probably right. Even if players are vehemently against the change, if commissioner Rob Manfred wants it, they’re probably going to have to lump it.
But Pirates pitchers definitely have opinions and feelings on the possibility of robotic umpires. Here’s what they think might happen if MLB goes this route.
Pitcher friendly
The most common theme seemed to be that any sort of robotic system will favor pitchers, in large part because you would theoretically only need to clip a part of the zone to register a strike call.
A couple guys even floated the possibility of bouncing a pitch to get a strike.
“Pitches like big curveballs will really come back with force because if all you have to do is clip the bottom of the zone, you can literally be bouncing curveballs, and they’re strikes,” Steven Brault said. “You can clip the back end of the strike zone. You can go on top of it. It would be weird to see.”
Pitchers like Kyle Crick, who have a sweeping slider that runs away from right-handed hitters, could really stand to benefit. While that pitch might not be called a strike now because it finishes way outside, it could nick the proper area now and become one.
Crick isn’t dumb and neither are his peers, and he predicts they’d quickly try to game the system.
“Robot umps would be highly exploitable,” Crick said. “There are pitches that cross the zone that aren’t hittable. Sometimes sliders can catch the bottom of the zone, and they can still hit the ground.
“Big league pitchers are too good not to exploit that.”
Missed connection
Another issue or hiccup with using robotic umpires involves the human element of the game.
Some might look at this and say it’s a good thing, that too many calls were being missed, and conceivably that will no longer happen.
However, there’s a human element to pitching that would disappear. Pitchers know umpires. Umpires know pitchers. Their paths cross a bunch of times every year for multiple years, and relationships are built.
Pitchers also learn umpires’ strike zones, where they can go to get a call, and at least the Pirates’ guys don’t want to see that part of the game go away.
“Just like hitters, they have hot and cold zones,” Joe Musgrove said. “That’s another part of it — the relationships you build with them, you’ll get more calls with certain guys. You’ll start to understand each guy differently. I think it’s a good part of the game that shouldn’t be taken away.”
Building off of this, there’s the reward factor for pitching, which by itself is a lost art these days. Call it the Tom Glavine Effect.
Glavine was famous for establishing the outside part of the plate and picking and picking until he was getting strike calls several inches off the plate.
If a pitcher is around the strike zone, he’s going to get more calls. If he hits the glove as opposed to throwing a pitch the catcher has to reach for, he’s going to get that call. Instead, with robotic umpires, none of that would matter. It’s black and white.
“You wouldn’t get those extended strikes,” Crick said. “You wouldn’t get rewarded for hitting spots throughout the game. Especially veterans, if they throw to that same spot in the first couple of innings, they can get a little more in the next couple.”
The young guy/veteran dynamic is something that makes Archer think robotic umps might actually be a good thing.
If there’s a 50/50 pitch, something on the edge of the strike zone, Archer said it’s normal for the call to go to the veteran rather than the young player.
With the game skewing younger and younger — the All-Star Game was perhaps the youngest it’s ever been — Archer questions whether that’s a dynamic MLB wants.
“Does the fan want to see someone egregiously getting strikes called because they have more time than the guy who’s hitting?” Archer said. “The human element is, ‘All right, it’s on the edge. I’m giving it to the more veteran player.’ It just happens. It’s not conscious. Close enough, strike.”
Bet on it
What may trump all, Archer explained, is gambling.
With more people betting on baseball than ever before, Manfred and others may not want to risk one blown call changing the complexion of a game, something that could conceivably be avoided by using robotic umps to call balls and strikes.
At minimum, there’s a human-less computer to blame if something is missed.
“The people behind gambling are powerful,” Archer said. “If they want the game to be perfect, there’s a good chance it might be.”
Final say
In the Atlantic League, home plate umpire Brian deBrauwere stayed behind the plate, in the event the system malfunctioned. Allowing the man behind the dish final editorial approval is essential to the process working, the pitchers felt.
Not only because pitchers might literally start bowling for strikes but also to apply some sort of in-game logic to it. Maybe a pitcher has earned a borderline call. Or say it’s a lopsided score, and both teams have to travel.
Someone not necessarily to intercede and exert a crazy amount of influence over the game, but just to sort of babysit the process.
“They should add some of the human element to it,” Clay Holmes said. “That would be better than a light flashing whether it was a ball or strike. I just think it would be really tough to lose that person back there.”

Jason Mackey: jmackey@post-gazette.com and Twitter @JMackeyPG.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.