Jason Mackey: Hi folks. Welcome to my weekly Pirates chat. We're doing this a day early today because of a day game tomorrow. Thanks for stopping by. Fire away now. I'll be back at noon to answer your questions.
Rob: Who are the Pirates looking to part ways with as the trade deadline approaches. Some decent names we can unload and not miss all that much!
Jason Mackey: Hi Rob, should this continue, I would imagine the Pirates would start to explore moving the guys on expiring contracts. That means Cervelli, Kang, Dickerson, Cabrera and Liriano, of the ones who can maybe be moved, and I have some serious doubts about the first two. ... I think they would miss some with Dickerson, Cabrera and Liriano, but if you're not within striking distance of the division and not playing very good baseball, then it's worth it for the return, IMO.
SerraEagle76: What’s up with Chisenhall? Last I read he was at home consulting other dr’s and was still collecting a paycheck from the Bucs. What is being said about him?
Jason Mackey: Basically what you just said. He's experiencing symptoms and at home, getting another opinion every so often. I'm not expecting him to come back, but I'm also not expecting the Pirates to say or do anything that makes him look bad because it'll hurt their ability to sign off-the-street free agents.
SerraEagle76: I agree with Zeise that Bucs should buy or sell but not stand pat. Team as presently constructed is average at best. What’s your view?
Read More
Jason Mackey: It depends on return, and I don't think those of us on the outside can answer that. I certainly wouldn't trade guys like Bell or Vazquez. I suppose I'd listen on the others. It just depends on what you could or could not get. ... I'm also fine standing pat if they're close to the division, but it doesn't look like it's gonna be that wait after this Cardinals serious, unless something changes soon.
Jake in DC: How many more losses is it going to take before we sell? To be honest, I think we're more than a pitcher or two away anyway, so it might be time already.
Jason Mackey: Hey Jake. I get your point, but I see the point in putting a number on it. Neal Huntington should be having conversations, and some of it should be return. That said, if they lost five out of their next six, I think we'll know. Until that time, I think Neal is smart to keep having conversations and get a feel for what's out there. You don't HAVE to make a decision right now, even if they lose six in a row out of the break.
Jack: Is it time to be realistic and say this team as constructed and with the injuries is just not a playoff caliber team? Playoff teams just don't take a week off every month like this team has.
Jason Mackey: We're getting close, Jack, but as I said just said, I don't think you need to put a hard-and-fast date on it. That seems like the en vogue thing to do, like you have to put some sort of official stamp on it.
Jake in DC: I don't understand the clamoring to sell Vasquez. He's and incredible player on an incredible contract for THREE MORE YEARS. Isn't that the exact kind of player you'd want to be getting? I know we could actually get #1 prospects and whatnot, but I don't understand the point.
Jason Mackey: Same. The return would have to be just absolutely ridiculous. And hey, if the Dodgers want him badly enough, maybe they do it. But it would have to be a crazy-good return.
Rob: If the Pirates lose this series, do you think they start selling and if so who and when do you think those pieces move?
Jason Mackey: I see we're going a specific direction here ... and not reading what was asked in advanced. We'll answer it again: I don't think there's a black-and-white rule, but I think losing six in a row out of the break would very much tell Neal Huntington what he should do. That said, losing six in a row out of the break isn't gonna tell him to do a dumb deal. (I know, I know; he's made enough of those on his own. Will save you guys/gals the snark.) But seriously, OK, say he chooses to sell off some expiring contracts. Would make sense. He's peddling Kang, Cervelli, Liriano, Cabrera and Dickerson. First two probably won't get you much, next three might. But I wouldn't trade those guys for nothin'.
Jeff: Hey Jason thanks the chats. its seems like every year we are 1-2 players (1 great, 1 good) from truly competing. last year it was hitting this year its pitching. do you agree and if so why would the fans ever think its going to change? whereas I agree with trying to improve by getting Archer, Archer isnt Keuchel and you give up nothing to sign him.
Jason Mackey: They should have signed Kuechel, absolutely. Or at least tried. There's no guarantee Kuechel would want to come here, also. ... I would argue they're more than 1-2 players away, but fans should care because there's also a lot of good, young talent on this team. ... If I'm a fan, I'm wanting them to add pitching, but I'm also encouraged by the pieces already in place (Musgrove, Williams, Archer, Taillon, Keller if he can develop) ... plus Vazquez on the back end, Liriano if they can keep him around, Crick if he gets right, etc. ... There's a lot of reasons to like this team, but yeah, I can see why a fan would want management to be more aggressive. That's fair.
Bill: If this slide continues for the next 10 days or so, guys like Dickerson, Melky, maybe even Liriano have to be moved right? Worst place for an organization to be is stuck in the middle of mediocrity. Not good enough to buy and not bad enough to sell. Guys like Keller, Tucker, etc need experience if they continue losing.
Jason Mackey: Next 10 days, yeah, I would imagine that sort of thing picks up. Again, assuming this slide continues.
jds317: It's been suggested that the Pirates "sell high" on Marte as part of a restructuring. I don't see how they can as your outfield for 2020 would be B. Reynolds and the oft injured and currently ineffective G. Polanco. Any Marte trade would need to include a plug and play CF. Your thoughts?
Jason Mackey: I would be trying like hell to hang on to Marte. If someone offered me a top-tier starting pitching prospect or two -- they won't -- then yeah, I'll listen. But I would want my 2020 outfield to be Reynolds and Marte, for sure, then figure out the third piece. Hopefully it's Polanco, but if not you gotta find someone.
Tim F: Jason, have you heard the 4-19-84 dead show from Philly? I was there and it was a legendary set. Anyway my friend swears he saw Mike Schmidt there, but my friend also was on acid. I don't think Schmidt was there. He's very straight laced. Anyway, is it true that the Buccos tried to trade to get schmidt on the Pirates back in '89? And how would that have impacted the 90-92 glorious Pirates teams? Thanks, Jason!
Jason Mackey: Have not heard that show. I'll go back and listen and let you know if I hear Mike Schmidt in the crowd.
Guest: How would you rate Bell's All Star performance, both in the HR Derby and the Game Itself?
Jason Mackey: I thought it was a bit underwhelming, to be honest. Not to criticize Josh -- clearly he was trying -- but I thought it would be a little more exciting all-around.
Pirates win!: Jason, do you and Gator have similar taste in music, food, etc. And, if not, how do you decide what to eat and what to listen to on Road Trips?
Jason Mackey: Ha. We haven't discussed music, although he's not into the Dead, I don't think. Food is hard to not find common ground in Chicago. Baseball is different, too. Not a lot of "road trips." It was probably the only time other than spring training where we'll be in the same place for an extended period of time. Until, of course, the Pirates make a World Series run.
Guest: Do the Pirates make any trades and stand firm at the DEADLINE?
Jason Mackey: I can see them making a minor trade or two.
Guest: Do you think they could trade Bell for two very high end pitching prospects while hoping Craig is the answer at first base. Or is no team willing to give them such a deal?
Jason Mackey: Absolutely not. They better not. That would and should infuriate their fanbase, and I don't care how good the prospects might be.
Proud Yinzer fan: Is it possible that Rob Manfred is a worse Commish than Selig? This bum has tons of lousy ideas to "improve" the game, but he won't even let the owners pony up the money for new netting to protect the friggin' fans? I know you technically work for Manfred, but what is this guy's problem!
Jason Mackey: Dude, I do not work for Rob Manfred. I work for the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette. ... I don't have any problem with what he's doing. To be honest, I think he should be doing more. Baseball has a problem right now. People are tuning out and not going because it's slow and not appealing to a younger generation. I also think it has a safety issue with the nets. I give Manfred credit for doing what he's done, although I want to see him do more.
123: Is Pedro Alvarez still playing ball? Retired?
Jason Mackey: I don't believe he's playing anywhere.
Peter: we all know the stars have to align for this team to compete with such a low payroll. Will this happen in the next 50 years , or are we stuck in a continuous cycle of being used as other teams farm system?
Jason Mackey: I'm comfortable saying the Pirates are going to compete within the next 50 years.
Dead fan too: Jason, I read that the new Grateful Dead featuring John Mayor (which is terrible by the way) are playing some Train songs in their sets?!?!?! As someone who famously loves the Dead and has dissed Train in these chats, how do you feel about this? I'll tell you how I feel...It STINKS!
Jason Mackey: I don't have an opinion either way. Still need to listen to some more Train and get a good grasp of it.
Peter: With the best management team in sports, why are we as fans stuck with another down season? Injuries?? Please! Short of the mariners and nationals, no team has a longer stretch between World Series visits as the bucks!
Jason Mackey: The best management team in sports? Sounds like some sarcasm there.
George: The Pirates are 44-48 and getting closer to the trade deadline is it time to think about unloading the free agents and get younger players to help this team rise above .500 because we are not doing it with them that is for sure
Jason Mackey: I think there's still time to wait and see some more, George.
Steve: Jason, How about moving Vasquez to the starting rotation,-an idea suggested by Jim Deshaies of the Cubs' broadcast team
Jason Mackey: Someone asked me the other day about moving a reliever to a starter role. ... No. Just, no. I know Vazquez started before, but he's become one of the best closers in the game. Plus, it's not like flipping a right wing to the left side in hockey or something that like. That takes buildup and manipulation of the arm and throwing process. I'd never in a million years move Vazquez.
George: Got the answer I needed from previous posts
Jason Mackey: Thatta boy, George. Now if only that could catch on ...

Guest: Hear me out, any chance the Buccos front office reaches out to Jose Tabata? He's still young, has a great rapport with the fans, and can hit clutch as well as anyone. Plus, he's just sitting at home waiting for a call. Could the bucs bring him back, maybe on a 10 day contract?
Jason Mackey: It's an interesting idea, for sure. And maybe while they're at it they can get Pedro Cerrano, too. ... Grab Henry Rowengartner, Rick Vaughn and Nuke LaLoosh to help the rotation. ... Maybe Billy Heywood can take over for Clint Hurdle.
Rob W.: Let's go in a different direction. If the Pirates win 7 of the next 9 or so, and they become buyers, is there anyone you can reasonably see them getting?
Jason Mackey: I liked the Homer Bailey add. I can't give you names, but I would expect -- if that scenario plays out -- that they try to target someone on the cheap that they can fix and keep around as a possible fifth starter, should Lyles continue to struggle.
Alan: The Pirates of all teams know that closers are dispensable. Look at their trade history at that position. With that being said, why wouldn't you trade Vasquez for a Kings ransom? When you find yourself 9.5 games out in mid-August, what use is it to trot him out for save against the Orioles?
Jason Mackey: Because he's under club control for a couple more years, and it's not just about the rest of this season, which I think people forget. I'm not saying no. I'm just saying the return would have to be insanely good.
raplf: Jason, re: the guy who asked about the Trade for Schmidt...was that part true? I hadn't heard that? Thanks!
Jason Mackey: I have no idea. I don't think so.
Rob Weaver: If they Pirates win 8 of the next 10, who can you see them realistic adding?
Jason Mackey: While we're on the subject of adds, and I'm watching Kyle Crick and Keona Kela struggle some, know who might be intriguing to place a call on? Tony Watson. If the Giants are dealing guys, could be an interesting add for the Pirates. They could use a bullpen arm, that's for sure.
Mike from MD: Hello Jason. Loved your chats from when you were covering the Pens. Unfortunately, I am not of the belief that Pirates Ownership cares all that much about winning. Mostly profit. The only chance that the Pirates have of ever trying to win would be if the players strike and a salary cap, and most importantly, a salary floor is implemented.
Jason Mackey: Hi Mike, thanks for the kind words. Didn't really see a question in there, but I do agree that I wish there was a salary cap/floor in baseball. I can see why fans get frustrated with the Pirates, even though I also think they sometimes go overboard with it. ... A cap and a floor would solve a lot of problems we see in the game. I think it would help it from a business standpoint. Sadly, I also don't think it will ever happen.
Jake in DC: As frustrating as this season has been, I actually have solid hopes for the next few seasons. Most likely place to improve in infield, 3B and 2nd. How ideal that two of our top prospects are a 3B and middle infielder. Could use some pitching help. How ideal that our top prospect is a pitcher. What's that? Newman, Reynolds, and Bell are all playing exceptionally well and are super young? Sweet.
Jason Mackey: I think this is a reasonable way of looking at things. And yeah, they have a decent amount of good, young infielders. Could see them getting creative with maybe trying Frazier in the outfield again or even dealing someone for an outfielder, assuming Dickerson and Cabrera are gone. If Polanco steps up, that could be a very good outfield with Reynolds, Marte and Polanco.
Markus: How about Marte not running out ground balls again last night. Hurdle not immediately benching him sends a terrible message to the team, no?
Jason Mackey: Hurdle is in a tough spot there. Yeah, it was bad. Not defending it. But you also need wins right now, and he's been hot at the plate. I think you might kind of have to live with it.
Jake in DC: Follow up on the paragraph I accidentally submitted early. I know thinks looks slightly bleak after the last four games, but there is good reason to be hopeful for the coming years. Agree?
Jason Mackey: Yes, I agree. I knew what you meant.
Tim M: Attendance is down in the MLB, and Bucs' attendance is poor--26th out of 30 teams, and far off their 2013-2016 pace. Ownership did nothing to energize the fan base in the off-season, and the results on the field reflect it. Those of us of a certain age remember the constant bellyaching about moving the Bucs because of low attendance. Have the economics of the game changed to the point that attendance is no longer crucial, and when will Nutting start complaining about attendance (you know, blaming us for his failures)?
Jason Mackey: Given what has happened since the Pirates made the playoffs -- let's say in a politically correct way that he hasn't reinvested into the club as much as its fans would like -- I think it would be a really bad PR move for Bob Nutting to blame Pirates fans for not turning enough of a profit.
John: Do you have a list of all the 79' Pirates expected to return this Saturday?
Jason Mackey: I do not, I'm sorry.
Guest: Regarding your comments on Manfred, Jason... for being a Dead Head you sure do suck up to The Man a lot. Can't you at least acknowledge that Manfred is a stooge for the wealthy owners just trying to put some coin in their already filled pockets at the expense of us lowly baseball fans? The trick is as old as time. You have to acknowledge that even if you don't work for Manfred, as you claim! Thoughts?
Jason Mackey: I think you're reaching. I'm not sucking up to the man. I'm saying that baseball has some improvements it needs to make, and I think Manfred is trying to make some, specifically to speed the whole thing up a little bit.
Guest: Jason, you're sassy today! I've seen a few smart aleck answers from you!!!! Yowza
Jason Mackey: My bad. I'll try to watch it.
Mark: How many more shellings is it going to take to get Lyles out of the rotation and give Keller another shot? Thanks Jason.
Jason Mackey: Would imagine one more will do it, honestly.
actually: Jason, Rob Manfred owns the MLB, the Pirates effectively own the Post Gazette (in terms of granting access to players which is the paper's life blood), so you do basically work for Manfred. Is that why you were defending him earlier?
Jason Mackey: You think access to Pirates players are the Post-Gazette's lifeblood? The Pirates are very good with access, and I appreciate what we get. But you're way off base there.
John: Seems counter productive to move a gold glover in Dickerson and try to find his replacement? He does not seem to be expensive and may actually want to play here. Why not try an extension. What do you think?
Jason Mackey: If I'm Corey Dickerson, I'm gonna want to go somewhere where I can play every day. I'm also gonna take my Gold Glove and .300 average from a season ago and try to peddle it. Now, his 2019 season isn't doing him many favors, with the injuries and all. But if he can put together a strong second half, chances are teams won't care. ... Bottom line, I wouldn't close the door on it. But in Pittsburgh, at best, he's going to be part of a rotation with Marte, Reynolds and Polanco with the way they do things. And also, if you're Dickerson and can maybe get on the Astros or Dodgers or Yankees or a team with a legit shot at winning the World Series, wouldn't you rather do that?
TJ: Mackey, when you worked covering the Pens, did you defend the NHL Commish with the same blind vigor with which you defend Rob Manfred? That guy can do no wrong in your eyes it seems.
Jason Mackey: Gimme a break, man. This is ridiculous.
Bob: Why did players stop wearing stirrups?
Jason Mackey: Because I think they wanted to be wrong.
John: Good point on Dickerson I miss the old days when your kids could by a jersey and the player's name on back would still be with the team when they grew out of it. This team doesn't get the point.
Jason Mackey: Ha. I hear ya. But I hardly think that's confined to the Pirates. I think if they could re-sign him, they would.
Tim M: Manfred is not the problem with the Pirates--nobody is interested in these conspiracy theories.
Jason Mackey: Second that, Tim.
Alan: Are the Pirates running out of players to put on bobbleheads? Did they already have Ryan Doumit bobblehead night?
Jason Mackey: I think that's next week. It's either him or the Jason Jaramillo Bobblehead Night, can't remember which.
Guest: You're catching a lot of guff today about your Manfred comments earlier, Jason. I think you just need to lay it out for us fans...Do you support Manfred 100% and, if not, to what degree do you support him and his plans for baseball, such as eliminating the shift which would effectively destroy small market teams. I hope that helps. We still think you're a good writer, you just have to be careful how much you praise Manfred. You really went overboard on heaping on the praise to a fan base who he has turned his back on since he took over. Thanks!
Jason Mackey: I'm not in favor of eliminating the shift. I am in favor of improving the pace of play. ... I didn't "heap praise" on him. I said I agreed with some of the things he was doing. That's it.
Pirates Fan 2001: Noticed online last week I think that you had emergency dental surgery. Oh no! Have you recovered and what the heck happened?
Jason Mackey: Ha. Nothing major. I just had a filling come completely out and had a big crater in my tooth. "Dental emergency" was probably a crappy word choice on my part.
Kent: I get your point on Dickerson but why are Pirates so committed to Polanco. Dickerson is better in field and at plate. Polanco has more "potential" but we have seen that before. If Polanco goes they can easily afford Dickerson
Jason Mackey: Yeah, but Polanco -- whether you like him or not -- is under contract. If they could hand Polanco's contract to Dickerson, I think they might consider it. But they can't.
Guest: Jason, don't take the criticism personally. People still think you do a great job with the chats, in general!
Jason Mackey: Thanks. I appreciate that.
Adam in Boulder: By what year do you think the Pirates will win a division title?
Jason Mackey: There's no year I could pick that isn't just completely yanking one of the air ... so what the heck. Pirates in 2021!
Guest: From one Dead Head to another, Jason - even though you and I don't see eye to eye on everything you're still a great writer and a true Pirates supporter at heart! Shine on you crazy diamond!
Jason Mackey: Ha. Thanks for that.
Jason Mackey: OK, folks. That's it for this week. Thanks for the participating. Look forward to doing this again real soon. Thanks.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.