CLEVELAND — MLB Players Association executive director Tony Clark initially gave a succinct answer about the MLBPA grievance against four teams including the Pirates.
“It’s still pending,” Clark said Tuesday at the Baseball Writer’s Association of America meeting. “It’s an ongoing legal situation and we try to be careful about how we address active litigation.”
That grievance was filed in February 2018 over the use of revenue sharing by the Pirates, Miami Marlins, Tampa Bay Rays and Oakland Athletics. MLB commissioner Rob Manfred countered before spring training this year that the Pirates finished above .500 last season and the Rays and A’s contended for playoff spots in the American League.
“Tony Clark started the assertion that teams aren’t trying to win by singling out four teams,” Manfred said. “He did a very poor job with those teams. One won 97 games, another won 90, and the other was a game above .500 … two games above .500. Our teams are trying. They all want to win.”
Manfred spoke to the BBWAA after Clark on Tuesday and reiterated his previous statements.
“This narrative that our teams aren’t trying is just not supported by the facts. Our teams are trying,” he said. “Every single one of them wants to win. It may look a little different to outsiders because the game has changed. The way people think about putting a winning team together has changed. But that doesn’t mean they’re not trying.”
Read More
The Pirates (44-45) are a game below .500 and 2½ games out of first place in the National League Central. They also have a payroll in the bottom five in baseball. One could argue the Pirates’ plan is working. One could also argue the Pirates might be in first place if they spent a little bit more money.
The Post-Gazette was able to catch up with Clark at batting practice Tuesday before the All-Star Game at Progressive Field, and he expounded further on the grievance and how it applies to the Pirates.
“The grievance we filed demonstrates we have some concerns,” Clark told the Post-Gazette. “The system we have now allows for dollars to be moved from one club to another. The MLBPA anticipates that each team will use those dollars in a fashion that improves the product on the field. That is what the agreement suggests.”
Clark believes the data his staff collected show the Pirates and the other teams aren’t allocating their revenue sharing money in accordance with the collective bargaining agreement.
“We track and follow all of the economic systems within the game. When we see concerns, we voice them to the other side,” Clark said. “Sometimes these concerns require a more in-depth look and that is what the grievance is about. Pittsburgh is one of the teams we’ve had concerns with, and we’ve also had concerns with them in the past. We’re hopeful that we continue to work through the questions and concerns in a way that works best for everyone going forward.”
Pirates team president Frank Coonelly has called the grievance “baseless” in previous statements to the media. Clark disagrees.
“He’s welcome to express his opinion to the extent that he’s willing to voice it,” Clark said. “There hasn’t been much shown in the way of particulars when it comes to how they are being compliant. We filed the grievance because of our concerns. We’ve followed up with those conversations. We aren’t satisfied with the outcome, so we are willing to keep working through it.”
Clark is acutely aware of fans being frustrated with the on-field payroll.
“Our industry is driven by fan engagement. Fans in Pittsburgh were already showing their frustration before the grievance,” he said. “We want fans in all 30 markets to feel excited about what the team they’re following is putting on the field. It’s not going to be a surprise if fans raise concerns. Our industry is in the best place when fans know the team is doing everything it can to put the best product on the field. Fans want to see their team find the best players possible and put the team in the best position they can to be the last team standing.
“We want a healthy game and the game is at its best when teams have the incentive to win. Fans in Pittsburgh and everywhere else shouldn’t have to question if their team is trying its best to win.”
Nubyjas Wilborn: nwilborn@post-gazette.com and Twitter @nwilborn19



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.