MILWAUKEE — With Major League Baseball’s worst ERA in May, the Pirates have basically been waiting, wishing and praying for a pitcher to step up and snatch one of two vacant rotation spots.
They may have finally found an answer on Friday, although it had little to do with their 10-4 loss to the Milwaukee Brewers at Miller Park.
Or what Rookie Davis and Nick Kingham did, which was struggle immensely with their command and execution.
Roughly 350 miles away, in Class AAA Indianapolis' game against the Toledo Mud Hens, Mitch Keller stated his case to join the Pirates’ rotation next Wednesday in Atlanta by striking out 13 over five scoreless innings.
At this point, especially given how Davis, Kingham and others have pitched, it would be an extremely unpopular move to keep Keller in the minors for another start. Or downright silly. Consider:
• Davis lasted just three innings. He walked four and needed 76 pitches to get nine outs. He did not look much at all like a starter.
Read More
To his credit, Davis’ owned his mistakes.
“I didn’t make the pitches I needed to make,” Davis said. “At-bats went way too long. Fastball command wasn’t there. I have to do a better job of getting quick outs and not leaning on the bullpen so much. Going three innings today is inexcusable.”
Perhaps Davis can be excused. After all, it was his first MLB start since September 2017. Criticize the Pirates for putting Davis in that spot, but that’s a tough ask for any pitcher.
• The bigger problem to take out of Friday’s game was Kingham, who allowed six runs (five earned) in 2 1/3 innings. After a clean fifth, Kingham imploded, turning a close game into a rout.
In his past seven games, Kingham has allowed 45 hits, 32 earned runs, six home runs and 13 walks in 24 1/3 innings. That works out to an ERA of 11.84 and a WHIP of 2.38.
"A lot of balls are ending up in the middle," Pirates manager Clint Hurdle said. "It’s with all the pitches. That’s been problematic. It’s been problematic throughout the start of the season until now."
That's not how Kingham viewed the outing. Like pretty much every time he's pitched of late, he was fine with it.
Kingham thought he did a lot of good things. The Brewers just happened to get a couple hits.
"Mixed my pitches and made some good pitches," Kingham said. "They were just hitting the ball really well.
"[Attacking hitters] was my gameplan. I feel like I executed it as good as I could have. It just didn’t work out."
Rookie Davis
• The Pirates will obviously have some decisions to make about the composition of their bullpen and whether they think they can get Kingham right.
They're also having to rely on Clay Holmes and Geoff Hartlieb, neither of whom have exactly been lights-out.
They could make a minor move to shore up the middle-relief situation, but the bigger storyline here will be Keller and whether the Pirates believe he's ready for a second MLB start.
Keller was admittedly nervous in his MLB debut last Monday in Cincinnati. He had to sit around and wait for the first game of a doubleheader to finish. On the mound, he didn’t find any semblance of a flow until about the second inning.
But once he did, you can see how the kid struck out 13 in just five innings. Keller has top-tier stuff, provided he can locate it.
Strange as it sounds, Friday was a winnable game at one point. After Kevin Newman's solo homer in the sixth, the Pirates only trailed by one.
But in the bottom half, Kingham gave up a leadoff double, lucked into an out when he snagged a hard-hit ball, then gave up a single to Christian Yelich.
Kingham went 3-0 on Ryan Braun before battling to a full count. Braun made Kingham pay by clobbering a fastball off the batter’s eye in center, pushing the Brewers ahead, 7-3, before it got really ugly.
In the seventh, Kingham allowed an RBI single to Travis Shaw, then two of his runs scored when Hartlieb coughed up a two-run single to Lorenzo Cain.
The bullpen woes have cost an offense that has founds its stride.
Besides Newman's homer, the Pirates keep getting tremendous production from Bryan Reynolds (now with a 15-game hitting streak after his RBI-double), an MVP-level season from Josh Bell and other solid performances.
Entering Friday’s game, Adam Frazier had the lineup's lowest batting average at .252. Their 2-3-4 hitters were all at .335 or above, and the Pirates had eight or more hits in 13 straight, the longest such stretch for them since August 2007.
Basically they’re hitting the ball well enough to win games. Furthermore, Corey Dickerson and Jung Ho Kang are due back Saturday, and they could have intense battles for playing time in both the infield and outfield.
But right now, the Pirates need pitching more than anything. It’s just sort of mystifying where they’re choosing to get it.
Kang, Dickerson speak
Kang returned to the Pirates on Friday and said his left side feels fine. He's excited to be activated on Saturday and potentially play in the afternoon against the Brewers.
"I’m in a good condition, a good body," Kang said through team translator Jeffrey Kim. "Everything is fine."
Kang said he didn't work on anything specific during his rehab stint with Class AAA Indianapolis. More just getting his timing back and making sure he was healthy.
"There’s no special things," Kang said. "Just try not to be injured and be healthy. That’s the most important part that I’m working on."
Asked whether he can cut down on the volume of strikeouts, Kang replied, "I'm hoping."
Dickerson is also ready to rejoin the Pirates, and that comes not a moment too soon for the Gold Glove-winning outfielder.
"I’m excited about it," Dickerson said. "Two months, it’s gone by quick. Also feels like a long time at the same time. To go through it mentally with them, being here, makes you want to get out there and help the team even more. I’m looking forward to it."
Appearing Friday on the Fan Morning Show on 93.7 FM, former Pirate Michael McKenry said he remembered Dickerson doing some pregame work in the infield and wondered whether that might be a possibility when Dickerson returns.
Dickerson shot that one down in a hurry.
"I played all the way coming up to college, but Michael’s crazy," Dickerson said with a laugh. "I proved myself a little bit last year. Baseball has a funny way of working itself out. All of us understand there’s a bunch of guys doing well and playing well. It all works out in the end."
Around the horn
Davis became the 11th different pitcher to start a game for the Pirates this season. Among MLB teams, only the Angels (14) have used more starting pitchers. … Frazier has hit safely in 16 of his last 19 games at Miller Park.
Jason Mackey@post-gazette.com and Twitter @JMackeyPG.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.