Jason Mackey: Hi folks. Welcome to my first-ever Pirates chat. Happy to see some people here. Feel free to fire away now. Will be back at noon -- I keep wanting to type 1 -- to answer any and all questions.
Jason Mackey: Alright, with some Dark Star from 3-29-30 at Nassau Coliseum playing, let's do this ...
New castle Pete: Do you think Mitch Keller will be up soon or do you think they’ll wait to make a deal for a pitcher at the trade deadline?
Jason Mackey: Hi Pete. Do you know Carmen Nocera? He was my college baseball coach and a New Castle legend. Tell him I said hello if you do. ... I would imagine they would do the first thing soon, then go TBD on the latter. To me, it doesn't make much sense to delay Keller much more. I get wanting him to perfect a pitch. I even understand the Super Two issues. But, seriously, I mean they basically have two empty rotations spots right now with nobody to fill them. The opener is fine and all but two bullpen games out of every five is a little much.
rcc prof: Why won't this organization make a trade for a decent starter? San Francisco, Miami might go for a trade, and Kuechel is available. How much money could a 1 or 2 year contract cost this cheap organization? Maybe the fans might get interested again if they saw management do something other than sitting on their hands.
Jason Mackey: I understand your frustration, rcc prof. I'm in the process of understanding their thinking behind everything, but when I look at this team, I see a couple holes in the current rotation. I get you could have a surplus of arms once Taillon and Williams return, but to me, you cross that bridge when you come to it. Never such a thing as too much pitching. Plus, like you said, there are guys available and no salary cap.
Read More
Larry in KY: Archer will take the mound every fifth day in an attempt to justify the trade. Woe is us!
Jason Mackey: Archer should pitch, Larry. In my opinion, anyway. No, the guy hasn't been good enough, but he has earned the right to work out of this; you're not going to banish him to the bullpen or something like that. That's ridiculous. He should be allowed to pitch, and I think they should work with him on being a little more efficient with his pitches.
fan: I thought today was Wilborn's chat? Where is he?
Jason Mackey: This week was Brink's chat, I believe. Or so says our schedule. At minimum, we're working through a transition on the Pirates beat. You may see me do a weekly chat here if there's enough interest. Nubyjas will be there tonight. (So you know, we typically alternate chats and mailbags each week. ... I also just checked, and Nubyjas chatted last week.
111: Hey Jason! I've been a big fan of yours since your time at the PG, even when you covered hockey. I have no idea how you are coping with taking over the Pirates beat, but I hope it is going well. How many years of team control does Josh Bell have on his contract? And can he keep up the pace the rest of the season? thank you
Jason Mackey: Hi, 111. And thank you for the kind words about my coverage. I've been loving the Pirates beat thus far, although the challenges of covering baseball are not small. A lot to wrap your head around. ... To answer your questions, Bell has arbitration rights through 2022. ... I don't know if he can keep up THIS pace the rest of the way. It's pretty nuts. But from everything you hear, a lot has changed with Bell -- his approach, his workout habits, his confidence, etc. It's hard to see him suddenly plummeting.
Guest: Is wilborn cool to work with? In his last chat he got the nickname Gator cuz he has thick skin. Does everyone at the office call him Gator too?
Jason Mackey: Yep. That's what everyone around the ballpark calls him -- Gator. He's actually so into the nickname that he purchased a Gator AWD vehicle and cruises it around the South Side during his days off.
bucs 2019 ws champs: Jason, I know these last few months have been tough. Ed Bouchette left and he's the backbone of the PG. You got moved to hockey. Nesbitt I heard retired or moved back to France. And now you are on to baseball. I hope it treats you well. Which cities will you most miss now that you cover baseball? my guess is Montreal and Nashville. Thanks, Mr. M!
Jason Mackey: Ha. They have been. No other way to put it. Ed's tremendous. Stephen, too, although he didn't retire or move to France. They both went to the Athletic. That's cool. I'm happy for them. But I'm also proud of what we're doing here. We have a lot of talented people still at the P-G. As for me, I asked to move to Pirates. Nobody made me do anything. And I'm thrilled so far. Definitely trying to figure it all out; I don't have all the answers and never will. But i'm enjoying the process of learning. ... I will miss a few. Montreal is on the list, for sure. I saw enough Nashville. Will miss Vancouver. Columbus and Buffalo, as odd as that might sound. I also always liked going to Raleigh, another trip that's not possible on the baseball circuit.
Guest: Has Ray Searage lost his ability to be a "Pitcher Whisperer?" He used to be the man at developing and revitalizing arms, but now he is garbage at it. Thoughts?
Jason Mackey: I don't think Jordan Lyles would agree with that assessment. I'm not saying Ray is infallible, but he's done a terrific job with Lyles. I think you're probably making that statement based on Chris Archer, who absolutely has struggled. But are we really gonna blame Ray for that? I think there's some Pirates pitching philosophy stuff that might not totally agree with Archer -- the amount of sinker usage, for instance -- but I'm not ready to say Searage stinks because Archer has struggled. Trades don't always work out, and sometimes it makes zero sense. We saw that in hockey with Derick Brassard.
Bob: Could this be Clint H's last season with the Bucs? That is the word on the street in many of the baseball bars around town. My cousin even heard from Rainbow Jeremy (who is a longtime Bucs fan) that he might not make it to the All Star Game before he gets the pink slip. I'd hate to see him go, but is it time for a new voice of leadership in the club house?
Jason Mackey: Um, no. The Pirates are 24-21 despite having I believe an MLB-high 20 players on the injured list. That they're competitive at all right now is a huge tribute to Hurdle. Tell Rainbow Jeremy and the other decision-makers to slow their roll. Thx!
dead fan: Jason, does Grateful Dead music lend itself more to baseball than to hockey? I love to turn the volume down on the tv, turn up some Dead (preferably '86 - '87 era) and space out to the Bucs game. I know you love spacing out to Dead choice nuggs. With hockey it is hard to get in a groove due to how fast the action is...maybe late era Dead, but even that is dicey. Do you have a favorite Dead album to listen to on earbuds while watching the Pirates play?
Jason Mackey: I do not. Honestly, I like listening to home radio while the game is on. It keeps me plugged into the game the way I want, and it helps me think of things that might otherwise drift through my head and not stick. Plus, Pirates broadcasters do a tremendous job. When I'm writing or during downtime, different story. I've been on a big '89 kick lately.
Guest: What happened last night to the Bucs? Did they use Swiss Cheese Sticks or baseball bats at the plate? Yikes!!! Will we see more hitting over the weekend?
Jason Mackey: Did they even bat last night? I didn't notice. ... Yeah, they definitely had some trouble with Marquez. ... One of 162, though. It'll happen. So far it's not a trend.
789: Read any good baseball books lately? Wilborn reads a ton of baseball books, so you better catch up!!!
Jason Mackey: I'm re-reading Jason Kendall's Throwback at the moment. I will surely hit up Nubyjas for book recs. Good to know. I'll be honest, though, with the transition, plus having a family at home, recreational reading time has been hard to find. Maybe once the road trips start up.
Guest: Do many old Pirates drop in during the season to catch games at PNC? I'm not talking about Blass or Teke cuz they are there all the time. I mean like a Jay Bell or a Chico Lind or some other 80s/90s guys. Thanks!
Jason Mackey: I'm not sure, to be honest. I know it was fairly common with the Penguins. I'll be interested to see how that goes with the Pirates. Would be cool if they did. Sorry I can't be of more help; I'm new here!
**: Crazy all the upheaval at the PG Sports desk lately. With folks leaving in anger, moving to France, and switching beats. I never know if I'm reading the PG or watching Game of Thrones. Do you think you'll stay on the Pirates job for the forseeable future?
Jason Mackey: Haha. Good one. Yeah, I don't plan on going anywhere.
Thomas: Is there another sucker GM out there who would take Archer today? Not only is he not good, he is hard to watch. ALWAYS tugging at his hair and hat. He should just pitch, and try in the lower 1/2 of the strike zone. What a waste!
Jason Mackey: Tugging at his hair and hat? Who the heck cares? If he throws strikes -- which he needs to do a better job of, for sure -- how is that at all relevant? I don't think it matters whether someone would take Archer. I don't think the Pirates are even close to there in their assessment of Archer. They still think he can be as advertised here. They're not cutting bait yet, nor should they.
jason : Any buccos gonna make the all star team this season you think?
Jason Mackey: I would think Bell is a look at this point. Gotta imagine Vazquez gets a long look, too.
Guest: Hello Jason, I used to read your hockey chats on occassion and I remember someone asking you if Jim Thorpe ever played ice hockey. You said on a couple of occassions that you'd look into it, but I never saw the answer...it was probably in a chat I missed. Anyway, did Thorpe try his hand at hockey and was he successful? I know there was a rumor from back in the day that he had been offered a tryout from Montreal.
Jason Mackey: I'm not sure. I'll have to look into that one. Maybe I'll have an answer next week.
Guest: When is the media going to wake up in regards to Chris Archer. Local sportswriters talk about him as if he's still the good pitcher he was when he first came up with Tampa Bay. He was good for three seasons but those days are long. He was 9-19 with a 4.02 ERA in 2016, 10-12 with a 4.07 ERA in 2017 and 3-3 with a 4.3 ERA in 2018. With the Pirates, he was 3-3 with a 4.30 ERA and this year he's 1-4 with a 5.55 ERA. Face it, his glory days are over. He'll be lucky to be a 500 pitcher with an ERA around 4 for the rest of his career. The Pirates should have realized he was fading fast when they traded for him. They never should have traded Austin Meadows and Tyler Glasnow. I said that at the time of the trade, and I'll certainly repeat that now!
Jason Mackey: I certainly understand and appreciate your opinion. Not saying any of it is wrong. But I will defend our coverage: One of our columnists, Ron Cook, wrote today the trade, criticizing Archer and the Pirates, saying the trade has not been good enough. To say that local media is pushing some sort of narrative -- at least when you direct it at a P-G beat writer -- is not accurate: https://www.post-gazette.com/sports/ron-cook/2019/05/21/Ron-Cook-Pirat...
Guest: Are the fans still doing that Wooooo thing in the stands in not close games?
Jason Mackey: I hope not. Hate that. Wooing and the wave. The worst.
Guest: Who is the prankster on the pirates? Every team has a locker room prankster!
Jason Mackey: I'm sorry. I just got here. I'm sure that sort of thing exists, but I can't say I have a strong enough feel for who that might be, at least not yet.
PIRATES: What is up with Cervelli this season?
Jason Mackey: Tough year for him. It's the way it goes sometimes -- nothing goes right. The foul ball off the chest, for instance. It just seems like there's a magnet on him. Then in the field, he bungles the rundown. Gets a hit, he's out of the game. Just a tough year. I don't have a precise answer for you. I don't know if he or the Pirates have a precise answer at this point.
Guest: Jason, enjoy your first chat. I heard you were at a paper in Atlanta covering the Braves right before you took the Post Gazette job. Welcome to pittsburgh, amigo! Do you like the city so far??
Jason Mackey: I was not. I think you're confusing me and Nubyjas. I grew up in Pittsburgh ... went to Brentwood, played football and baseball, and then played baseball at Westminster College. Moved away, to D.C., for a couple years out of school (2006-10), then moved back. Have lived here ever since. Love this city!
section 115: Jason, so many of my BFFs are down on Clint, what say you?
Jason Mackey: Said it before, with all the injuries the Pirates have endured, I think Hurdle deserves a lot of praise for keeping them afloat. I wish he would give his pitchers a longer leash sometimes, but overall as a manager, it's hard to criticize too much. I think they've exceeded expectations to this point.
Chuck: Jason, I read the Pirates have been thinking about trying Chisenhall at 3B when he finally is able to play. Do you think this is a real possibility and has he played there prior?
Jason Mackey: Chisenhall has played plenty of third throughout his career, so this wouldn't surprise me. However, I think priority No. 1 for Chisenhall should be getting healthy. Worry about a position later.
rambler66: The Pirates take an approach that attempts to have them be competitive every year. The result of that seems to be a bunch of .500 teams. Would they be better served to keep payroll extremely low for a few years followed by a few years of high payroll. Seems to have worked to bring the Marlins a couple of WS championships over the past 20 years. The attendence would seem to average out too.
Jason Mackey: If the Pirates are going to change business models, I'm not sure that's the one to follow. How about increasing payroll a little bit, at least to middle-of-the-pack range? There's talent on the team, but they could use some help -- right now, for instance. This is a great sports city. Fans will respond and have responded before. I don't like what the Marlins did because it leads to a lot of lean years, but I do think the Pirates could stand to ramp it up a little beyond where their spending is right now. (And yes, I understand budgetary constraints, in case Bob Nutting is reading this. Still ... )
Mike Lanza: As a Pittsburgh guy new to the Pirates beat, I'd really appreciate your perspective on this: How can so many Pirate "fans" follow the team closely as they root against it? Sure, OK, they *hate* the owner, but in that case, why follow the team and get pleasure when it loses?
Jason Mackey: Hi Mike. I get what you're saying. I can see how people would get frustrated with that stuff, but it's not the players who are putting these constraints in place. You don't think the Pirates would love to see Dallas Keuchel walk through that door? C'mon. But I do get why fans get frustrated when they see the other two teams in town spending every available dollar. I think the Pirates could do themselves some favors by even spending a little more than they're comfortable with, and I think they did that last year with Archer and Kela, to their credit.
John in Augusta: Jason, welcome. I like Clint Hurdle and think he is a great guy and does well with what he has. Do you think the Pirate ownership is going to stick with him or will they start looking if the Bucs start to slide out of site as the season rolls on. thanks
Jason Mackey: Thanks, John. For all the warts the Pirates have right now -- and even at three games over, we'd be stupid to pretend they aren't there -- I don't see Hurdle as being one. I think he's better than your average MLB manager, and i think he's been a big reason for their success.
Ty: With the emergence of Josh Bell, would the pirates consider including Will Craig in a deal that could bring back starting pitching? Maybe Madison Bumbarner from the giants? Maybe could include Archer in the deal?
Jason Mackey: Hi Ty. Last part first: I can't see the Pirates moving Archer at this point. It's bad business: selling an asset at its lowest point. The sense you get is also that the Pirates believe Archer can figure it out. If that's the case, then they're not going to move him. I see what you're saying about Craig, though, and I would have to imagine that would be an option for them. If Bell keeps this up, that would obviously adjust their first-base pipeline.
Chester Cheese: Does this mean you are no longer on the Pens beat? And can you write some great background stories like you do with the Pens? PLEASE!
Jason Mackey: Hi Chester. Yes, it does. I'll full-time Pirates. And yes, I fully intend on bringing the same approach to Pirates -- the off-field stories, the human-interest stuff, quirky pieces, etc. I appreciate everyone's patience while I get my feet under me, though. Those pieces are tough to turn right away.
Jack Straw: Are you still on the Penguins beat or do you have a new assignment?
Jason Mackey: I switched beats at the P-G. I'm the paper's lead Pirates/baseball writer now.
Jason in Slippery Rock: You were terrific with your Penguin insider reports. But how long do you think it might take to establish similar relationships inside the Pirates organization?
Jason Mackey: I'm not sure, Jason. I don't know if you can put a timeline on such things. I'm going to work my hardest to do it ASAP, but that's also not the type of thing you can rush. Thank you for the kind words. I do think I'll be able to churn out some decent stuff soon, but yeah, there's also a startup period that I'm working through now.
Guest: Dark Star from 3-29-30? 1930?
Jason Mackey: Ah, damn. Good catch. 3-29-90. The Branford Marsalis show. It's musical heaven.
Ke'bryan Mays Hayes: German Marquez leads the NL in IP, already has a GGSO this year, is top 5 in bWAR and fWAR among MLB pitchers. Last night was his third start with 7+ scoreless innings. Any reason why it was presented as a surprise that he pitched well?
Jason Mackey: I don't think it was presented as much that Marquez is incapable as it was the Pirates bats going silent; they didn't do much of anything. I'll also admit this: It was my first-ever baseball game story. Criticism is fair, and I can take it. I had a billion things going through my head last night, and there's a bunch of stuff I wish I would have done different. I have better and you'll see it soon starting tonight.
Mike: I read that the Pirates sent scouts to watch the Giants and Orioles. Why? Have you heard anything?
Jason Mackey: I think you mixed up the New York Post story. The Giants and Pirates had scouts at Camden Yards last night. ... I wouldn't get too worked up over it, honestly. Can't imagine they're gonna go get Clint Frazier.
Rob fox: They have to free keller right?
Jason Mackey: I would think so.
2 balls 1 cup: Have you packed enough underwear for the next roadtrip? Clean Underwear
Jason Mackey: I haven't packed for the Cincy trip yet, but I do plan on bringing clean underwear.
Peter: Thoughts on EndGame?
Jason Mackey: Have not seen it.
Krugerrand: All of the #1 seeds fell in the first round as well as some #2s. Can the NHL playoffs really claim to produce the 'best' team, or has it become which team randomly survives?
Jason Mackey: Can't not answer a hockey question ... ha. I think these playoffs speak to the randomness of hockey. It's not always the best teams. More the team that gets enough bounces, gets hot, etc. I mean, c'mon. St. Louis was a hot mess earlier this year. How else to explain it?
Jenk: Has Searage lost his ability to be a horse whisperer?
Jason Mackey: I don't think so. Got this earlier, but my comeback would still be: What about Jordan Lyles? I'm not chalking Archer's situation up to a Searage issue.
Thanos: Will the Pens trade Malkin?
Jason Mackey: I don't think so.
BigAl: Hey, when you coming down to Fla? Would like to buy you a few coffees
Jason Mackey: Not this year, BigAl. ... Maybe next year, although I think Nubyjas likes the Atlanta-Miami swing. He can go nuts as far as I'm concerned. ... If they wind up in Tampa, I would want that, as my mom spends winters in The Villages, about an hour north.
Mike: Is it just me or are the Pirates announcers annoyingly bad? Talk about stupid stuff over and over.
Jason Mackey: It's baseball. You have to fill the time. In that regard, they're no different than announcers for other teams. I've watched and listened to a lot of baseball broadcasts. Has always been a hobby of mine in the summer. I think the Pirates guys do a tremendous job.
Jason in Slippery Rock: I heard it said on the PM team that the average age of an MLB fan is 57. What is your philosophy on bringing millennials into being fans of the game?
Jason Mackey: I believe it, first off. And yeah, they need to get younger people talking about baseball. I'd be lying if I said that wasn't a challenge I wanted to take at the P-G -- getting more people to care about a sport I love so much. I think they need to do a couple things. ... One, the games are too stinkin' long. And occasionally boring. I don't wanna watch for 30 minutes and see mound visits, pitching changes, dudes scratching themselves and spitting and one out recording. I'm a baseball dork. I get all of what's happening that maybe you don't see or think about. But you are in the entertainment business and if people are tuning you out, maybe it's time to re-examine how things are done. ... So, they have to shorten the games and make them more watchable.
Bambi: With all the injuries to SP how close are we to a Keller call up? Also with Hayes with how third base has played out has to be better than Elmore
Jason Mackey: I would imagine we're knocking on the door. You can't keep livin' with two of your five rotation spots being openers. I wouldn't think so, anyway. Keller seems to be producing some solid results. If he makes two more starts for Indy, I'd probably be shocked. ... As for third base, I'm less inclined to do anything there. No need to force it. I think Moran is serviceable. They have more options. I like Newman there, too.
Mark: Jason, the Pirates play in San Francisco September 9-12. You might want to circle that on your calendar. Seriously, my question is, what to do with Chisenhall if he ever gets healthy, which is no guarantee. I don't see him being an upgrade over anyone on the major league roster. What do you think?
Jason Mackey: I think you have to see, Mark. I think he can be. Also, these situations have a way of working themselves out. In hockey, everyone always wanted to know: Once everyone gets healthy ... ? Same thing. Cross that bridge when we come to it. But if he hits like he has throughout his career, they'll find a place for him. Nubyjas has this San Francisco trip, but yeah, that's gonna be a priority for me here moving forward. Ha.
DJ 9: Hey, 1 quick question while i'm making my way downtown and so walking fast. % Pirates make playoffs
Jason Mackey: I'm gonna go with about 10 percent.
Ke'bryan Mays Hayes: Please don't give a platform to people citing pitcher win loss records as useful data points
Jason Mackey: I don't think I did that.
Hotlanta: Please tell me you're going back to Atlanta
Jason Mackey: I'm not, don't worry.
Noppy: Which fans are dumber? Pens or Pirates?
Jason Mackey: I'm never gonna call fans of the team I cover dumb. C'mon. Mostly because they aren't.
HamOnTheCob: Who is your favorite Pirates broadcaster?
Jason Mackey: Hard to pick, although I think John Wehner does a tremendous job. Really underrated.
Mr. Ed: How long before these young whippersnappers at PG sports develop the cynicism, sarcasm and arrogance of the old regime?
Jason Mackey: Not my job to comment on anyone else at the P-G -- or at any outlet in town -- but you won't get cynicism or arrogance here. You may get some sarcasm, but it's all in good fun. I like to think I'm fairly open with readers, accessible and honest about what goes on here. I'm not perfect, but I would never, ever talk down to yinz guys and girls.
Jason Mackey: OK, folks. That's gonna do it for me. Got to do a couple things before heading to the ballpark. Thanks so much for participating. Can't wait to do another one of these soon!






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.